Montague Diner

All 24 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What’s your “nemesis spot” in NYC ?4 pts
replying to u/eb112233: Why? The tater tots are delightful.
“multiple service issues (over an hour for an inedibly salty spinach artichoke app) and other food related issues (burnt latkes, raw steak- part of previous hour plus ordeal).”
H3
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?12 pts
“Montague Diner in BK Heights! Get the chocolate chip pancakes”
H2
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?9 pts
replying to u/mattattack26: Montague Diner in BK Heights! Get the chocolate chip pancakes
“While I don’t mind Montague Diner, it’s slightly over priced and portions a relatively small IMO.”
H2
in:Restaurants with housemade / top tier mozzarella sticks?3 pts
“Montague Diner in Brooklyn Heights, which just opened, had killer ones when I went last week—old school classic, similar to Bernie's.”
H2
in:Lower Manhattan ‘neighbourhood’ feel restaurants 1 pts
“The Montague Diner was opened by a bunch of friends who work in the film industry and they created a diner in the space of an older blah diner that is pretty amazing.”
H2
in:Diner for 9 people1 pts
“Montague Diner. It’s a diner opened by Hollywood people who had a fantasy of what a diner could be with echos of the old Florent which would be the place to go if it were still around. Takes reservations too.”
H2
in:Another pancake question (I know, don't hate me)1 pts
“Montague Diner in Brooklyn Heights has exceptional Latkes and Buttermilk pancakes made to order. It’s a modern neighborhood diner with reasonable prices and excellent food and service.”
H2
in:Looking for the best chicken caesar wrap1 pts
“It was good enough, but bonus: it had croutons in it -- which isn't something I've often found in wraps and made for a nice crunch.”
H2
in:What’s your “nemesis spot” in NYC ?0 pts
replying to u/Born_Stable5668: Montague Diner.
“The tater tots are delightful.”
H2
in:Similar to Golden Diner Options15 pts
“Montague Diner in Brooklyn Heights or Kellogg's Diner in Williamsburg are two other good options.”
H1
in:What’s your “nemesis spot” in NYC ?9 pts
“Montague Diner.”
H1
in:Help us find the BEST DINER in NYC - we want to feel like in a movie8 pts
“I like Triple Decker in Greenpoint, Montague Diner in Brooklyn Heights, Purity in Park Slope, Remedy in the LES, and Kellogg’s in Williamsburg.”
H1
in:Similar to Golden Diner Options7 pts
“I've had 2 bad experiences here but people like it”
H1
in:Roast my itinerary- 2.5 days in NYC6 pts
“Kogane (ramen), Montague Diner, and L’Appartment bakery in Brooklyn Heights are good food options.”
H1
in:What restaurants in NYC deserve the "Eisenberg's" treatment (i.e., don't change the food, but bring everything else into the 21st century)?6 pts
“I think Kellogg’s Diner and Montague Diner are two that did it right”
H1
in:Good breakfast spots3 pts
“Montague Diner is good.”
H1
in:Urgent: Birthday Dinner3 pts
“Montague Diner is cute!”
H1
in:Best mozza sticks?2 pts
“Montague diner”
H1
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?2 pts
replying to u/Icegrip: I actually prefer Grand Canyon Diner across the street. While I don’t mind Montague Diner, it’s slightly over priced and portions a relatively small IMO.
“Montague Diner is good but a bit bougie.”
H1
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?2 pts
“Food was okay.”
H1
in:Similar to Golden Diner Options1 pts
replying to u/esbu: Kellogs, La Bonbonaire, Joe's Jr., Montague Diner (I've had 2 bad experiences here but people like it), Veselka, Clinton St. Baking Co.
“I disliked my one visit to Montague Diner and never went back. Guess people believe the hype.”
H1
in:birthday breakfast suggestions for a newly minted adult please1 pts
“Maybe Montague diner for slightly upscale”
H1
in:Best Martini and Burger Combo?1 pts
“Montague Diner”
H1
in:Recs for a taste of New York for European visitors0 pts
“A classic diner could also be fun, relatively nearby there's Cobble Hill Coffee Shop, Montague Diner, Tom's, Neptune diner.”
H1