My Little Pizzeria

All 31 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?2 pts
“it's legit one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. all the pizzas look sad af in the display case. got a fresh pie and the crust was just terrible, the cheese tasted cheap.”
H3
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?1 pts
replying to u/festinalente27: My Little Pizzeria is the best classic slice shop in the area. Table 87 is great for something a little fancier.
“my little pizzeria is top 5 worst pizzas I've ever had, and i got a fresh pie. flimsy, bland, crust tasted like a cracker”
H3
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?1 pts
replying to u/CinnamonBunion: My Little Pizzeria and Table 87 are close and very good.
“bought a pie from my little pizzeria based on the recommendation of someone. absolutely disgusting! the crust sucked, the cheese tasted cheap, it was only slightly a step above school pizza.”
H3
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?13 pts
replying to u/CinnamonBunion: My Little Pizzeria and Table 87 are close and very good.
“My Little Pizzeria is the best classic slice shop in the area.”
H2
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?2 pts
“I personally found My Little Pizzeria and Pronto Pizza to taste doughy and bland.”
H2
in:Brooklyn Neighborhood of the Week: Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens and Columbia Waterfront1 pts
replying to u/JoshLyuksm: Pronto? Is it better than my little pizzeria next to the movie theatre? I remember I was 12 years old maybe and got chicken bacon ranch pizza at pronto and vomited it up once I got home. That was about a decade ago so maybe things have changed lol
“My little is much better imo. They have solid square slices.”
H2
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?1 pts
replying to u/freefromthenegative: My Little Pizzaria on Court? Seriously?
“i can't believe this place is getting raves either, terrible pizza”
H2
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?1 pts
“My Little Pizzeria might be my favorite pure slice shop in the city, but my God, is the service awful.”
H2
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?1 pts
replying to u/pillkrush: i can't believe all these people are recommending my little pizzeria. it's legit one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. all the pizzas look sad af in the display case. got a fresh pie and the crust was just terrible, the cheese tasted cheap. felt like i was eating a cheese tortilla. the pizza didn't even fit the box. y'all only like it cuz it's a cheap slice shop, no way you're going on taste
“I hope people are confusing My Little Pizzeria at 114 Court, with Little Pizza Parlor at 192 Duffield. 114 Court doesn’t even look clean let alone hood.”
H2
in:Favorite pizza spot, most underrated pizza spot, and worst pizza you’ve had (no national chains)1 pts
“Favorite: My Little Pizzeria for a slice joint”
H2
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?34 pts
“My Little Pizzeria and Table 87 are close and very good.”
H1
in:Pizza Recommendations -Downtown10 pts
replying to u/heepofsheep: Joes is pretty much like any decent slice you can get in region. If you live in an area with terrible pizza then yeah it’ll be great but if you’re coming from NJ, CT, PA, etc it won’t be anything special.
“After that I rank Joe's (and on the right day My Little Pizzeria on Court Street).”
H1
in:Shoutout to the unhyped independent neighborhood pizza places of NYC9 pts
“my little pizzeria in downtown bk!!”
H1
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?4 pts
replying to u/CinnamonBunion: My Little Pizzeria and Table 87 are close and very good.
“+1MLP”
H1
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?4 pts
“My little pizzeria”
H1
in:Best slice in Dumbo?3 pts
replying to u/CodnmeDuchess: There aren’t any good slices in Dumbo. Juliana’s and Ignacio’s are the best pizza restaurants in the neighborhood though, but they don’t do slices.
“Seconding My Little Pizzeria”
H1
in:Shoutout to the unhyped independent neighborhood pizza places of NYC3 pts
replying to u/lavenderived: my little pizzeria in downtown bk!! and little pizza parlor
“My Little is our family's fave.”
H1
in:Shoutout to the unhyped independent neighborhood pizza places of NYC3 pts
H1
in:What are the best by the slice pizzas in New York?2 pts
replying to u/bigbird2003: My Little Pizzeria in downtown Brooklyn/edge of Brooklyn Heights, on Court Street
“Might not be the "best" slice, but, definitely a good rep of the "NYC slice" and never let me down.”
H1
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?2 pts
replying to u/CinnamonBunion: My Little Pizzeria and Table 87 are close and very good.
“MLP was my go-to for delivery back when I lived in Brooklyn Heights - glad to see the quality has kept up even after 20+ years.”
H1
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?2 pts
“Fascati and My Little Pizzeria are solid”
H1
in:Sals pizza - Boston2 pts
“I like My Little Pizzeria”
H1
in:What are the best by the slice pizzas in New York?1 pts
replying to u/LeftReflection6620: The true Slice category to me are the places that serve slices like Buffalo Chicken and Margherita with thick slices of mozz and tomato sauce and are usually $4 or less for a good slice. With that said, I love Brooklyn Home Slice on Vanderbilt, Rosas on Metropolitan, and Antonio’s Pizza in Flatbush. Honorable mention for Luigi’s in Clinton Hill. I love F&F and and L’Industrie but they’re in another category of “gourmet” slices and not representative of the NYC slice.
“"My Little Pizzeria" on Court Street in Brooklyn was where I got most of my slices”
H1
in:What are the best by the slice pizzas in New York?1 pts
“My Little Pizzeria in downtown Brooklyn/edge of Brooklyn Heights, on Court Street”
H1
in:your top 5 NYC restaurants1 pts
“My Little Pizzeria, Govinda’s, Woorijip, A&A Bake Doubles and Roti”
H1
in:Recs for doughy pizza1 pts
“These are all doughy and delicious”
H1
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?1 pts
replying to u/YosephusFlavius: MLP was my go-to for delivery back when I lived in Brooklyn Heights - glad to see the quality has kept up even after 20+ years.
“no it's not, it's disgusting”
H1
in:Shoutout to the unhyped independent neighborhood pizza places of NYC1 pts
replying to u/PriorCod4320: I love this post. Not all pizza places need to have lines. Great slice places are all over the city. Shout out to some of the places near where I’ve lived over the years: - Freddie & Peppers: Amsterdam & 74th - Mimi’s: Broadway & 88th - My Little Pizzeria: Court Street (Brooklyn)
“My little is absolutely goated. I have so many great memories of going there after watching a movie at the Regal cinema on the corner (RIP)”
H1
in:Pizza suggestions Boerum Hill1 pts
“For a good slice. Not fancy sit down wait for reservation but a good solid slice.”
H1
in:I'm not a fan of third wave pizza, what are some classic spots people like?0 pts
“My Little Pizzeria by the Trader Joe’s on Atlantic Ave is a zero frills, zero hype slice shop that’s better than most.”
H1
in:Best Pizza in Downtown Brooklyn?-2 pts
replying to u/CinnamonBunion: My Little Pizzeria and Table 87 are close and very good.
“One isn’t good and one isn’t close? Weird response.”
H1