Brooklyn Diner

All 30 rated mentions, most helpful first

postWhere we went in 6 days110 pts
“7/10 - felt a bit fleeced but the pecan French toast is superb”
H2
in:Best chocolate milkshakes in NYC?5 pts
“I’ve had great chocolate milkshakes recently at Brooklyn Diner near Carnegie Hall and Schnippers.”
H2
in:Child friendly dinner spot somewhere around midtown3 pts
“A more expensive option with insane pot pie is Brooklyn Diner (also on 57th).”
H2
postJust returned from our first visit to NYC1 pts
“* Brooklyn diner: I had to try a diner, as it was our 1st ever time in the US. I thoroughly enjoyed the food and experience, but wow, we paid the price all day for such a massive sugary breakfast, we had to skip our lunch plans because of this lol.”
H2
in:What are your go-tos when you can’t decide what to have for dinner? 1 pts
“Brooklyn Diner has great matzo ball soup.”
H2
in:Any badly reviewed spots that you actually love?1 pts
“Brooklyn diner has the best burger…”
H2
in:What’s the non-touristy Cheesecake Factory of NYC?107 pts
“You want upscale, go to au cheval or Brooklyn Diner.”
H1
in:Kids Birthday near Times Square13 pts
“Brooklyn Diner”
H1
in:Looking for a good milkshake9 pts
“Cliche, but Brooklyn Diner on 57.”
H1
in:Grown man with the palate of a 9 year old7 pts
“There are lots of diner options in Midtown - Westway or Brooklyn or Murray Hill Diner, New York Luncheonette, etc.”
H1
in:Food recs Midtown near 50th and Madison w/a 10 year old3 pts
“Brooklyn Diner.”
H1
in:American cuisine2 pts
“Brooklyn Diner’s location near Carnegie Hall is fun and more elevated than the typical diner”
H1
in:Hell’s Kitchen/Midtown Recs2 pts
“Brooklyn Diner on 57th and 7th has standards but is actually pretty good!”
H1
in:Food Recommendations with a toddler2 pts
“Also check out stretch pizza, Brooklyn diner (Jewish), Carnegie diner”
H1
in:Looking for brunch2 pts
“Or a couple spots on 10th Ave are nice: Brooklyn Diner and Cookshop”
H1
in:Best Breakfast Diner?1 pts
“Brooklyn diner by Columbus circle”
H1
in:Looking for a good milkshake1 pts
“They are incredible.”
H1
in:Best breakfast/lunch/dinner takeout 7th and 55th area1 pts
“soulvaki GR, Brooklyn diner, blue willow and blue ribbon are on the pricey side but delicious.”
H1
in:Times Square - I know...1 pts
“Brooklyn Diner on 57th (one of our favs)”
H1
in:Recommend me your go to diner, mine’s jumped the shark1 pts
“Brooklyn Diner on 57th between 7th and Broadway”
H1
in:First time in NYC. Are we missing something on our 7 day trip?1 pts
replying to u/International-Tie-67: We already decided to skip It but looking for diner tips instead around there.
“brooklyn diner on W 57”
H1
in:First time in NYC. Are we missing something on our 7 day trip?1 pts
“go to Brooklyn Diner on 57th.”
H1
in:Help us find the BEST DINER in NYC - we want to feel like in a movie1 pts
“Brooklyn diner!”
H1
in:Help us find the BEST DINER in NYC - we want to feel like in a movie1 pts
“As would Brooklyn Diner on 57th.”
H1
in:Are there any quarter pound hot dog vendors in the city?1 pts
“Easiest bet is somewhere like dyckmans or Brooklyn diner”
H1
in:Where can I find a great breakfast/diner (first NYC visit)1 pts
“Near the Park, higher end, Brooklyn Diner on 57th”
H1
in:Favorite milkshake joints in NYC?0 pts
“Brooklyn Diner in Midtown”
H1
in:Dinner Near St. Patrick’s Cathedral Before a 7pm Show??0 pts
“Brooklyn diner”
H1
in:Where is the best french toast in midtown (or brunch overall)?0 pts
“Brooklyn Diner”
H1
in:Recommendations please-1 pts
“I liked the Brooklyn Diner at Times Square.”
H1