Bobbi's Italian Beef

All 29 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Apologies for a low end question, but: Greek gyros?1 pts
replying to u/OutlandishnessNo8737: I am also a Midwestern transplant & I've found nothing *exactly* like it here, but I like King Gyros in Bay Ridge. As others note, Astoria might be our best shot. I might ask the people at Bobbi's Italian Beef if they have any recc's.
“The Bobbi owner is so genuine and is clearly trying to do it right, but man are those beefs disappointing. The meat is always too crumbly, and the bread is just not right at all.”
H3
in:An Italian beef, Jalapeño cheddar dog & meatball parm from Bobbi's Italian Beef in Cobble Hill13 pts
“this place had some super dry beef.”
H2
in:Favorite hot dog spots?10 pts
“Bobbi's Italian beef in Carrol gardens area does a perfect Chicago dog.”
H2
in:Best Spots off the G Train8 pts
“Bobbi's Italian Beef has great hot dogs and Italian beef sandwiches.”
H2
in:Brooklyn Neighborhood of the Week: Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens and Columbia Waterfront7 pts
“Bobbis Italian beef is a vibe. Cheap pitchers, great hot dogs. The must get is the tavern style pizza.”
H2
in:What popular meals are missing in NYC?6 pts
“Bobbi's Italian beef!”
H2
in:What are you guys favorite places in Brooklyn for big meaty sandwiches?5 pts
“Bobbi's Italian Beef might be exactly what you're looking for.”
H2
in:What popular meals are missing in NYC?4 pts
“I think Bobbi's on Brooklyn has the best Italian beef in the city.”
H2
in:An Italian beef, Jalapeño cheddar dog & meatball parm from Bobbi's Italian Beef in Cobble Hill3 pts
“I tried the chicken parm from this place and it was terrible.”
H2
in:Favorite unique sandwiches in Brooklyn?3 pts
“Bobbi's Italian Beef I thought was unique. It's good, but kind of heavy for my taste.”
H2
in:What are hard to find food items for you?3 pts
“Bobbi's Italian Beef on Smith St. in Brooklyn definitely does this. They use Vienna Beef dogs and [they look](https://i.imgur.com/sfBxbGL.jpeg) just like the ones I've had in Chicago and match all of your listed criteria.”
H2
in:Dog Day Afternoon (at H&H Reserve)2 pts
replying to u/SoothedSnakePlant: The alternative is Bobbi's Italian Beef over by Clover Club on Bergen, and it was the better of the two Chicago places IMO.
“In my experience (and others in this thread) DDA is much better than Bobbi’s”
H2
in:What's a chain in another state or country that you wish had a location in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/bigazn350: Portillo’s
“bobbi’s italian beef on smith st in brooklyn is pretty fantastic and definitely hits the spot when i’m craving a proper chicago dog or italian beef.”
H2
in:An Italian beef, Jalapeño cheddar dog & meatball parm from Bobbi's Italian Beef in Cobble Hill1 pts
“I got a cheesy beef from there and loved it”
H2
in:An Italian beef, Jalapeño cheddar dog & meatball parm from Bobbi's Italian Beef in Cobble Hill1 pts
“The Chicago Dog from here was really great”
H2
in:Favorite unique sandwiches in Brooklyn?1 pts
“i think the italian beef from dog day afternoon (better than bobbi's italian beef) and the italo disco club from ciao gloria are both very worth your time.”
H2
in:Chicago Dogs and Fries at Dog Day Afternoon1 pts
“Bobbi's Italian Beef in Cobble Hill does a great Chicago dog, too.”
H2
in:What are you guys favorite places in Brooklyn for big meaty sandwiches?1 pts
replying to u/sha256md5: Junior's has some wild burgers topped with pastrami that are pretty good. Bobbi's Italian Beef might be exactly what you're looking for.
“Bobbi's Italian Beef is great. Their full size sandwiches are massive, and the Italian beef is quite good.”
H2
in:What’s the best cheesesteak I can get here?1 pts
“Bobbi's Italian Beef with cheese”
H2
in:Dog Day Afternoon (at H&H Reserve)1 pts
“bobbi's italian beef was kinda a let down...their hot dog was decent but their beef was too thickly cut and dry.”
H2
in:What popular meals are missing in NYC?16 pts
“I’m sure it’s not really up to par with Chicago but Dog Day Afternoon (had the one in H&H) and Bobbi’s Italian Beef are pretty good”
H1
in:Dog Day Afternoon (at H&H Reserve)7 pts
replying to u/donut_butt: Great Chicago style hot dogs (though what’s the alternative? shake shack? These are way better) Very nice Italian beef too (though again, no alternative) The fries were a pleasant surprise, easily the best or second best fries in Williamsburg. https://www.instagram.com/dogdayafternoonbk?igsh=aXFscTA1aXJ5djZ5
“The alternative is Bobbi's Italian Beef over by Clover Club on Bergen, and it was the better of the two Chicago places IMO.”
H1
in:Dog Day Afternoon (at H&H Reserve)7 pts
replying to u/mcwerf: I gotta try this place soon since bobbi's italian beef was kinda a let down...their hot dog was decent but their beef was too thickly cut and dry.
“It’s better.”
H1
in:Looking for somewhere I can buy soft poppy seed hot dog buns2 pts
“Bobbi’s Italian Beef on Smith St in BK”
H1
in:What's a chain in another state or country that you wish had a location in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/lazyadjacent: it’s not quite portillo’s but bobbi’s italian beef on smith st in brooklyn is pretty fantastic and definitely hits the spot when i’m craving a proper chicago dog or italian beef.
“Had a terrible experience at Bobbi’s Italian beef”
H1
in:An Italian beef, Jalapeño cheddar dog & meatball parm from Bobbi's Italian Beef in Cobble Hill1 pts
“This place is totally mediocre”
H1
in:Favorite unique sandwiches in Brooklyn?1 pts
“Perfect winter “sandwich””
H1
in:Dog Day Afternoon (at H&H Reserve)1 pts
replying to u/SoothedSnakePlant: The alternative is Bobbi's Italian Beef over by Clover Club on Bergen, and it was the better of the two Chicago places IMO.
“bobby's is decent”
H1
in:Good Spots in West BK that take walk ins?1 pts
“Vinnies, Bobbis Italian Beef”
H1