The Onion Tree Pizza Co.

What Reddit says31

View all

in:Onion Tree Pizza Co. (Neapolitan/Indian fusion) in the East Village closing, last day Feb 221 pts
replying to u/zxyzyxz: Some previous experiences: https://reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1p64shd/the_onion_tree_makes_underrated_neapolitan_pizza/ (gallery: https://www.reddit.com/gallery/1p64shd) https://reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1j5bdku/most_underhyped_pizzas_in_nyc/ (OP says: noteworthy primarily as a fusion desi pizzeria, but the dough itself is really excellent here, and I'd argue one of the better Neapolitan bases in the city)
“Update: I just went, it was alright, like 7/10. The pizza lacked salt or MSG or umami or something, the crust was great but the toppings lacked flavor for some reason.”
H3
postMost Underhyped Pizzas in NYC264 pts
“the dough itself is really excellent here, and I'd argue one of the better Neapolitan bases in the city”
H2
postBest bite you had in 2025?71 pts
“Honorable mentions: * Masala Margherita Neapolitan Pizza at The Onion Tree”
H2
postThe Onion Tree makes underrated Neapolitan pizza38 pts
“their Marsala pie is bomb and so is their Burrata chaat.”
H2
in:Onion Tree Pizza Co. (Neapolitan/Indian fusion) in the East Village closing, last day Feb 2213 pts
“OP says: noteworthy primarily as a fusion desi pizzeria, but the dough itself is really excellent here, and I'd argue one of the better Neapolitan bases in the city”
H2
in:Best Food Mashups in NYC 11 pts
“Onion Tree Pizza Co. in the East Village does an Indian-Italian mashup that is Delicious”
H2
in:What are some of the best sit down pizza places with a full bar?7 pts
“Onion Tree Pizza Co (Indian pizza) in E Village is delicious, great appetizers and cocktails as well.”
H2
in:Italian Overkill???3 pts
“the best onion rings I have had in my life”
H2
in:Onion Tree Pizza Co. (Neapolitan/Indian fusion) in the East Village closing, last day Feb 223 pts
“Checked this spot out last year and felt it was expensive compared to other great pizza offerings, but most definitely delicious.”
H2
in:Best Onion Rings3 pts
“Dosa onion rings at onion tree pizza”
H2
in:What’s the best Indian restaurant that has an unique set of menu items and also quite affordable in NYC ?2 pts
replying to u/rickymagee: Omar's Indian Fine Cuisine in Prospect Heights might be easy to overlook, given that they also serve bagels and pizza. Weird, I know. However, their Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza is a surprisingly delicious. Beyond that, they offer a full range of classic Indian dishes, with highlights like the rich, flavorful Butter Chicken and the perfectly spiced Goat Biryani.
“Onion Tree Pizza in the EV is Indian Pizza is you wanted that again”
H2
in:Looking for Indian food recs in Manhattan / Lower East Side2 pts
“I love the food at Onion Tree Pizza! The chicken tikka pizza there is my fave and the burrata chaat is also delish.”
H2

See all 31 mentions

The Onion Tree Pizza Co.CLOSED

What Reddit says31