Davey's Ice Cream

All 42 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Unique ice cream in the outer boroughs1 pts
replying to u/justflipping: - Max and Mina's - Malai Ice Cream - Spot Dessert Bar - Mango Mango - SkyIce - Purple Dough - Maya's Snack Bar - Taiyaki - Patisserie Tomoko - Yamada - Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain - Eddie's Sweet Shop - Davey's Ice Cream
“It was watery and icy, and had literally no flavor. It was also $10 a scoop. We were in disbelief.”
H3
in:Who has the best cake in the city?16 pts
“Otherwise huge fan of Davey’s ice cream cake, Veniero’s Oreo cheesecake and rainbow cookies, Little Cupcake Bake Shop, and yes Magnolia’s cupcakes and cake slices (but mostly the Key Lime icebox bar).”
H2
in:Where Are the Best Milkshakes in NYC Right Now? -Summer 202610 pts
“Daveys Peanut Butter Pie milkshake is a favorite, though not cheap”
H2
in:What to get at Moynihan/Penn Station?7 pts
“Davey's Ice Cream cookies, rice krispies treat, or brownies”
H2
in:VC and private equity owned spots7 pts
replying to u/VeryPuffin: I’ll say, nobody has a bigger and better vegan/non dairy options than VLW. If there is, that aren’t just sorbets at gelato spots, I’m all ears!
“daveys ice cream in greenpoint has a vegan rocky road thats better than any vegan ice cream van leeuwen has ever made”
H2
in:Best place to get a birthday cake? 4 pts
“Red gate bakery, davey’s for ice cream cakes, veniero’s for same-day cakes”
H2
in:Favorite Sweets Recommendations 3 pts
“Ice Cream: Morgernstern's, Caffe Panna, Davey's”
H2
in:Favorite restaurants to get just desserts in Brooklyn?3 pts
“Davey’s for ice cream and/of brownies. Just a dessert place, not a restaurant but excellent”
H2
in:Ice cream cake3 pts
“Davey’s. Combine speculoos and Nutella chocolate chunk. Best combo.”
H2
in:Family Friendly Places2 pts
“Morgernstern’s, Davey’s and Caffe Panna for ice cream.”
H2
in:Best small/casual eateries2 pts
“Morgernstern’s, Davey’s,Caffe Panna for ice cream.”
H2
in:Hot Chocolate?2 pts
“Daveys Ice Cream is really thick and really rich”
H2
in:Best chocolate milkshakes in NYC?2 pts
“I really like the Chocolate Chocolate milkshake from Davey's.”
H2
in:Seeking snickerdoodle cookie anywhere in 5 boroughs2 pts
“Their speculoos ice cream is also one of my favs”
H2
postDavey’s Ice Cream hot chocolate recipe?1 pts
“I had some amazingly delicious hot chocolate from the Davey’s Ice Cream place in Moynihan Train Hall a bit ago and I’m looking for the recipe so I can make it at home. It was rich, decadent, and thicker than other hot chocolates.”
H2
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?1 pts
replying to u/iheartaginganddying: Daveys is #1
“Yep. The biscotti cookies and cream is my weekly treat.”
H2
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?1 pts
replying to u/iheartaginganddying: Daveys is #1
“Their brownie is next level”
H2
in:Looking for a good milkshake1 pts
“Davey’s (which has some of the best ice cream in nyc).”
H2
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/Clear_Hunt_5644: Fat witch has good brownies
“Best brownie in NY is from Davey’s Ice Cream!”
H2
in:Best cookie in nyc? 1 pts
“Davey's ice cream has the best regular cookies. Do not get the ice cream.”
H2
in:Best cookie in nyc? 1 pts
replying to u/quibble42: Davey's ice cream has the best regular cookies. Do not get the ice cream.
“My sons got shakes at Penn Station and they were chalky.”
H2
in:I need Hot Chocolate reccs for the winter.1 pts
“Davey’s Ice Cream Hot Chocolate”
H2
in:East village1 pts
“Davey’s for ice cream”
H2
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?1 pts
“My favorite is the Peppermint Chip.”
H2
in:It’s National Ice Cream Sandwich Day — who makes the best one in NYC?1 pts
“Davey’s in the east village had the best one I’ve found in the city”
H2
in:What are your favorite places for Ice Cream or Milkshakes in Manhattan?17 pts
“Davey’s Ice Cream”
H1
in:Unique ice cream in the outer boroughs12 pts
“Davey's Ice Cream”
H1
in:Ice cream10 pts
“Davey's, Ralph's, Uncle Louie G's, Ray's Candy, Marvel Frozen Dairy, Brooklyn Farmacy, Eddie's, The Social (some fancy flavors but they also have simple flavors), good ol' Carvel”
H1
in:Surprise scoop nyc? On 1st Ave - Ice Cream??7 pts
“Just go to Daveys or Sundaes and Cones or Noonas or hell even van Leeuwen (all in the same neighborhood) and ask the worker “surprise me with the flavor” that way at least youre for sure getting good ice cream😭”
H1
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?5 pts
“Daveys is #1”
H1
in:Ice cream cake4 pts
“Davey’s”
H1
in:Travel to NYC 1/12 with fam bam3 pts
“As for food, Levain for cookies, Ess -a-Bagels for bagels, Burger Joint for burgers, Morgernstern’s, Davey’s and Caffe Panna for ice cream.”
H1
in:Restaurant to impress 12 yo step daughter near Chelsea3 pts
“Davey’s”
H1
in:I need Hot Chocolate reccs for the winter.3 pts
“Davey’s Ice Cream in the east village or Moynihan”
H1
in:Best Brownies In NYC?3 pts
“Davey’s - Greenpoint or Midtown (Moynihan Hall)”
H1
in:What's your most shocking ripoff meal in NYC?2 pts
“don't get me wrong, I LOVE Davey's”
H1
in:Hot Chocolate?1 pts
replying to u/ecb74: Daveys Ice Cream is really thick and really rich
“seconding this its incredible”
H1
in:Help my food crawl1 pts
replying to u/OkPerformance6864: I’d say replace Van Leeuwen with Caffe Panna for something more unique (and better imo)
“Davey's!”
H1
in:Best thicc dark hot chocolate1 pts
“DAVEYS ICE CREAM. Yes, I know. GO”
H1
in:Best brownie sundae in the city?0 pts
“Davey’s in Greenpoint”
H1
in:**First-time visit to NYC from Toronto!**0 pts
“For ice cream places with more unique flavors, consider Chinatown Ice Cream Factory, Davey's Ice Cream and Malai.”
H1
in:Went about trying the so called best ice creams in NYC ! Cafe Panna , Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream , they were pretty average compared to the local shops in NJ ! Where do you get the best ice cream in NYC ?-7 pts
“Salt and straw, Daveys, van leeuwen”
H1