Wingbar

6.8/10

AI-generated summary

Come for the wings and little else. People say they're the closest thing in the city to real Buffalo style, big and well seasoned, but only when they come straight out of the fryer. Others have had them dry and overcooked, so it's hit or miss. Cheap pitchers and TVs make it a sports bar first, and one regular says stick to the wings while another swears by the .

275 Smith St, BrooklynCarroll Gardens / Red Hook, BrooklynGoogle Maps

What Reddit says37

View all
  • replying to u/InsatiablySouthern: WingBar in Cobble Hill

    Cheap pitchers too. Unbeatable combo when they come out piping hot out of the fryer.

    H2

  • replying to u/Icy_Fact: Wing bar in Carroll gardens can be hit or miss but when they’re good they’re good!

    great nachos too

    H2

  • replying to u/Impressive_Champion4: Having eaten the best wings in Buffalo. Wing Bar in Carrol Gardens is the only place I have personally been to in NYC that comes close to the real deal. These are far and away the best wings in the city IMO. I would not recommend any non wing food on their menu though as it ranges from average to flat out bad.

    They are the closest to true Buffalo style I have had here and are well seasoned.

    H2

  • replying to u/Impressive_Champion4: Having eaten the best wings in Buffalo. Wing Bar in Carrol Gardens is the only place I have personally been to in NYC that comes close to the real deal. These are far and away the best wings in the city IMO. I would not recommend any non wing food on their menu though as it ranges from average to flat out bad.

    Wingbar is amazing when they are coming right out of the fryer which is why it’s my favorite sports bar to go watch a ballgame with a buddy (also very affordable pitchers!).

    H2

  • replying to u/Desperate_Hunter7947: For the city the best I’ve had are Dan And John’s, Wingbar in Carrol Gardens, and Bonnie’s Grill in Park Slope. You gotta check out some westchester spots though for the truly great wings. Sherwood’s and The Larchmont Tavern in Larchmont, Candlelight Inn in Scarsdale

    And wingbar has to be the best spot in NYC if you just want to put away a bigass bowl of 100 wings.

    H2

  • replying to u/Impressive_Champion4: Having eaten the best wings in Buffalo. Wing Bar in Carrol Gardens is the only place I have personally been to in NYC that comes close to the real deal. These are far and away the best wings in the city IMO. I would not recommend any non wing food on their menu though as it ranges from average to flat out bad.

    It was so dry when I went. Maybe a bad day.

    H2

  • replying to u/grooveman15: Honestly, I find their wings pretty substandard. I live in the area and go there out of convience but they are nowhere near my top wing. Small, dried out - solid sauce though and good pitcher prices

    I feel like their wings are big compared to other places in the city

    H2

  • replying to u/Icy_Fact: Wing bar in Carroll gardens can be hit or miss but when they’re good they’re good!

    It’s always miss. Wings there suck. I don’t get why people like them. They’re over cooked and the flavor is meh.

    H2