Madonia Bakery — all mentions

in:My favorite spots after a week in NYC14 pts
“I’d highly suggest PUGSLEYS (chicken roll and plain slice with their spicy chili oil - you have to ask at the counter for this) and fresh filled cannolis + rainbow cookies at Madonia Bakery.”
H2
in:Little Italy Bronx8 pts
“Grab some pignoli cookies at Madonia for dessert”
H2
in:Bronx hit list7 pts
“Madonia bakery for great bread and pignoli cookies. Get some cannoli freshly filled.”
H2
in:best bites in the Bronx 🙏🏻7 pts
“Madonia Bakery and Gino's have some of the best cannoli in the city.”
H2
in:Cannoli from Gino's in the Bronx. Not sure there's a better cannoli in the city but be sure to comment if there is one! I still haven't been to Villabate Alba in Brooklyn and plan to hit it soon.7 pts
“Madonia in the Bronx has great cannolis”
H2
in:Freshest mozzarella in the city?5 pts
“canolis/white chocolate bread/garlic&cheese bread at Madonia”
H2
in:Little Italy Bronx4 pts
replying to u/before8thstreet: Dominick’s has a hilariously good vibe but the food is extremely mid. Emilia’s and Zero Otto Nove are best for food, Tra Da Noi not bad either. Madonia bakery is the best
“Love Madonia. The fresh mini connolis never make it a day in our house. Incredible.”
H2
in:Best cannoli in New York City?3 pts
“Madonia, but you have to have them filled to order and eaten fresh.”
H2
in:What are some good Italian restaurants to take 7 midwestern dudes (all in their 60s) who have never been to NYC?3 pts
replying to u/supericakr: zero otto nove’s manhattan location is excellent, bronx is better but it had always been a standout. i also like franks in the e.vil but it is cash only and might be small for 7.
“Stop at Madonia bakery cash only and get raisin fennel bread and jaw breaker biscotti”
H2
in:My favorite spots after a week in NYC3 pts
replying to u/aspiring-green-thumb: I am SUPER impressed with this post!!!!! As an ex Fordham alumni, I love that I see Arthur Ave spots on here!! If you get to go back, I’d highly suggest PUGSLEYS (chicken roll and plain slice with their spicy chili oil - you have to ask at the counter for this) and fresh filled cannolis + rainbow cookies at Madonia Bakery. Since I’m based in EV, I’m stoked to see The Pastry Box and Andrea’s Pizza here as well, they deserve all the love. My husband loves chocolate chip cookies and you did right with Wegmans and The Pastry Box. Well done!!!!!!
“I actually did try out a cannoli from Madonia as well, it was good but I liked Gino's a lot more haha.”
H2
in:Vacation Itinerary and Questions2 pts
“While one person is standing on line, another can go get some treats over at Madonia Bakery - cannolis are insane and the white chocolate bread is spectacular (I'm not a huge white chocolate fan and this is fabulous).”
H2
in:They say bread is life2 pts
replying to u/Relupo: Madonia bakery on Arthur ave is unmatched
“I think about their cannolis and white chocolate bread all the time”
H2
in:Planning a bakery crawl2 pts
“Madonia is great for bread.”
H2
in:Italian bakery that makes biscotti in Manhattan2 pts
“Madonia is my favorite for biscotti.”
H2
in:Caputo Bakery in Carroll Gardens has closed!! :'(2 pts
“Tried Madonia on Arthur Ave but it was a complete salt bomb and I could barely get through it.”
H2
in:Rainbow cookie crawl. (14 bakeries, Queens, Manhattan, and Brooklyn)2 pts
“Madonia on Arthur Ave makes one of the best cakier ones.”
H2
in:best NYC Italian goods to bring home to family ?1 pts
“Madonia for breads and pastries. Their cookies are insane.”
H2
in:Arthur Ave 1 pts
“Best cannolis are at Madonia”
H2
in:Arthur Ave 1 pts
“Madonia bakery has some of the best bread you’ll ever have (I especially love their olive bread)”
H2
in:In search of the best Italian cookies and Sfogliatelle in Bronx’s Little Italy. Anyone have experience with the bakeries by Arthur Avenue?1 pts
“Cookies were so good, I wish I'd gotten more!”
H2
in:Bronx Arthur’s Ave Recommendation1 pts
“Bread at Madonia. It’s the specialty product stores that are very good there over the restaurants.”
H2
in:Bronx1 pts
“Madonia for bread”
H2
in:Viral Food that’s actually worth the hype?1 pts
“Olive bread from Madonia”
H2
in:So I finally had the cheesecake from Veniero’s1 pts
replying to u/cocomang: Also the best cannoli in the city
“Madonia. No pre-filled cannoli would even be in the running.”
H2
in:Looking to purchase authentic THICK New York Cheesecake1 pts
“Madonia (great cannoli too)”
H2
in:🌈🍪🏆 I Tried Every Rainbow Cookie in Queens So You Don’t Have To 🏆🍪🌈19 pts
“Ok, here is what I have as our favorites citywide (out of what we visited and recorded.”
H1
in:Little Italy Bronx12 pts
“Madonia bakery is the best”
H1
in:In search of good cannolis 9 pts
“Madonia on Arthur Ave in the Bronx”
H1
in:They say bread is life5 pts
“Madonia bakery on Arthur ave is unmatched”
H1
in:Best Italian bakeries in Bronx or Brooklyn5 pts
“Madonia or Terranova in the Bx.”
H1
in:Lard bread: Caputo vs. Mazzola5 pts
“Bella Vita and moretti bakery (Staten Island) are worth checking out - also Madonia on Arthur ave”
H1
in:Top Italian bread and pastry shops!4 pts
“Madonia Bakery”
H1
in:In search of good cannolis 3 pts
replying to u/efsitz2: Madonia Bakery, Little Italy Bronx. Arthur Ave
“I just got a cannoli from there on Sunday, omg I never had a cannoli that delicious. It’s definitely worth the trip, especially with all the other restaurant options around.”
H1
in:What Happened to Eataly Flatiron1 pts
“A1 shops that have been around for decades. Teitel, Vincent’s Meat, Madonia, Terranova & Artusos bakeries. So much authentic goodness for a fraction of what you get overcharged for in Mnahattan.”
H1
in:Lard bread: Caputo vs. Mazzola1 pts
replying to u/Garconavecunreve: Bella Vita and moretti bakery (Staten Island) are worth checking out - also Madonia on Arthur ave
“+1 for Madonia”
H1
in:Rainbow cookie crawl. (14 bakeries, Queens, Manhattan, and Brooklyn)1 pts
“Madonia Bakery in the Bronx wins”
H1