Carnegie Diner & Cafe

All 30 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What’s a Really Good Diner?20 pts
“my favorite is Carnegie Diner on 57th and 7th. Incredible pancakes”
H2
in:Recs near Carnegie Hall13 pts
“The food at Carnegie diner is actually pretty good. Servings are huge though so I’ve never had a chance to try their desserts, which look amazing”
H2
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?12 pts
replying to u/Serpichio: Maybe basic but my favorite is Carnegie Diner on 57th and 7th. Incredible pancakes and right on top of the q stop
“the food is actually great with huge portions and pretty solid service.”
H2
in:Tasting and ranking of seven chocolate cakes in the city2 pts
replying to u/Jnm124: Have you ever had the giant layer cake from carnegie diner? I need to know if its worth the coma
“It’s good but gigantic. I thought it was on par with strip house, which also was good. Not worth $30 good, but good enough.”
H2
in:Which diners can I visit while on vacation in NYC to get the authentic American diner experience?1 pts
“Times Square Diner and Carnegie Diner are good, but they're more modernized than the classic diner you're looking for.”
H2
in:Times Square - I know...1 pts
“my friend and I really liked the club sandwiches at Carnegie Diner!”
H2
in:Recs near Carnegie Hall1 pts
replying to u/AestasBlue: The food at Carnegie diner is actually pretty good. Servings are huge though so I’ve never had a chance to try their desserts, which look amazing
“100% and reasonably priced.”
H2
in:Best Restaurants in the Theater District?1 pts
replying to u/thebalancewithin: Has anyone tried Carnegie Diner? Been meaning to try it
“Way overpriced, food is average”
H2
in:Is Junior’s THAT bad?0 pts
“carnegie diner at like 50th/8th i think is a solid sit-down, family spot. it's pretty spacious and the food is decent.”
H2
in:Poor quality yet expensive restaurant recommendation to give to an enemy ?31 pts
“send them to the abomination that took over Thalia's.”
H1
in:What’s the non-touristy Cheesecake Factory of NYC?11 pts
“Carnegie diner 🤷🏾‍♂️”
H1
in:any typical American-style Breakfast recommendation?8 pts
replying to u/lithopsbella: I’m partial to Andrew’s diner on 7th, good flavor, no frills, and they don’t charge twenty damn dollars for an omelet
“Carnegie diner is really tasty”
H1
in:Jet-lagged Kids Late Night at JG Melon: Si or No?5 pts
“Go to a diner instead , like Carnegie diner or flame”
H1
in:Child friendly dinner spot somewhere around midtown3 pts
“Carnegie Diner on 7th and 57th.”
H1
in:Brunch Times Square area2 pts
“Carnegie Diner if you're looking for a solid American diner”
H1
in:Food Recommendations with a toddler2 pts
“Also check out stretch pizza, Brooklyn diner (Jewish), Carnegie diner”
H1
in:Solo dinner after a late Broadway show?2 pts
“Carnegie Diner.”
H1
in:Child friendly restaurant near W 50th and 8th?2 pts
“Carnegie diner!”
H1
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?2 pts
replying to u/TheLunarVaux: Came here to say this. It feels like a potential tourist trap due to its location and Carnegie Hall branding, but the food is actually great with huge portions and pretty solid service.
“If you go at the right time, they have some really good specials.”
H1
in:Great breakfast places1 pts
“Westway Diner, Cosmic Diner, Carnegie Diner. All great breakfasts!!!”
H1
in:Best delibbreakfast pancakes? 1 pts
“Carnegie Diner - it’s not a hidden gem though.”
H1
in:Lower Manhattan ‘neighbourhood’ feel restaurants 1 pts
“Carnegie diner (not great but very diverse menu)”
H1
in:Weill Café at Carnegie Hall for dinner1 pts
“Carnegie Diner across the intersection is decent and close.”
H1
in:Breakfast recommendations in NYC1 pts
“Carnegie Diner - up 8th Ave at 50th! So good!”
H1
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?1 pts
replying to u/TheLunarVaux: Came here to say this. It feels like a potential tourist trap due to its location and Carnegie Hall branding, but the food is actually great with huge portions and pretty solid service.
“It’s maybe not old-school, but it’s top quality.”
H1
in:Recs near Carnegie Hall1 pts
“We ended up going to Carnegie Diner and had a lovely time.”
H1
in:What’s the non-touristy Cheesecake Factory of NYC?1 pts
“carnegie diner”
H1
in:First night eats0 pts
“Carnegie Diner”
H1
in:Recs near Carnegie Hall0 pts
replying to u/AestasBlue: The food at Carnegie diner is actually pretty good. Servings are huge though so I’ve never had a chance to try their desserts, which look amazing
“Carnegie diner is great. I took a date there one time and it was great. Good food and prices.”
H1
in:Where to eat 59th & Broadway-1 pts
“Carnegie Diner”
H1