“Vic's has been the most awful sit-down meal I've had in New York. Maybe the kitchen had an off night but every single thing was incredibly salty to the point of being inedible.”
H3
All 37 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Vic's has been the most awful sit-down meal I've had in New York. Maybe the kitchen had an off night but every single thing was incredibly salty to the point of being inedible.”
H3
“I love Vic’s on great jones. Busy but not too busy. Good vibe good food.”
H2
“Roast corn pizza from Vic’s, honorable mention to their crispy potatoes”
H2
“Vic’s doesn’t have fries, they have crispy potatoes and they are amazing. Good wine, good salads too.”
H2
“The best pizzas of my life, on god. Seasonal changes all the time with fresh market produce. And they’ve perfected the rainbow cookie.”
H2
“I did a really fun and affordable team dinner at Vic's in NoHo. We had a table back in the kitchen area. Everyone loved it.”
H2
“Vic’s in NoHo is very solid and you can always get a table.”
H1
“Vic's remains one of the worst meals ever for me.”
H1
“Il Buco, Peasant, Emporio, Rubirosa, Charlie Bird, Vic’s, Jean’s, 19 Cleveland, Shuka, Cafe Select, Thursday Kitchen (more fun and challenging), Kenka, Emmett’s (Chicago deep dish pizza), Boqueria (any location), Pasquale Jones, Tacombi, Pinch, Fish Cheeks (warning, spicy!), Ayat, and Nowon, just to spitball a few ideas!”
H1
H1
“Vic’s”
H1
“Vics is so bad in comparrison”
H1
“Il Buco or Vics! Not as much hype as some of the west village Italian spots but still pretty good and easier to get a resy”
H1
“Italian: Lartusi, Vic’s, Barbuto, Foul Witch, Osteria Carlina, Reddit’s”
H1
“Vic’s.”
H1
“Vic’s on Great Jones”
H1
“Vic’s in NoHo”
H1
“Bar Primi, Elvis, Vic's, Lafayette”
H1
“I’ve only had positive experiences there.”
H1
“Vic’s is great”
H1
“You can go old school with Vic’s and del ponte bakery”
H1
“Italian would probably be best for all of you. o suggest Vic’s in NoHo”
H1
“Pastis or Vics”
H1
“Avoid Fish Cheeks and Vic’s - both are great but always packed and noisy.”
H1
“Vic’s”
H1
“Was just there in November and had Italian at Vic's: https://www.vicsnewyork.com/ Quite good.”
H1
“I love the one at Vic’s”
H1
“I went to Vic’s and it was fine… not the same level as the top 20% of Italian in the city imo”
H1
“Vic’s on Great Jones St”
H1
“Vic’s, Fish Cheeks”
H1
“For good Italian I go with Vic’s in Noho. It’s consistently good”
H1
“Vics”
H1
“Vic's”
H1
“the menu at each of these places is about the average price of a run of the mill experience in Manhattan but better quality”
H1
“food is above average but not outstanding. Also, I just went there just once and the service was below average.”
H1
“Da Andrea or Morandi, Village; L’Artusi, WV; Lavagna, EV; Vic’s, NoHo; Ci Siamo, Hudson Yards”
H1
“Da Toscano, Ci Siamo, or Vic’s - they’re both usually reservation only but given that it’s a week day, you may be able to walk in and ask what their availability is like”
H0