Fat Witch Bakery

All 35 rated mentions, most helpful first

postThree nights in Manhattan215 pts
“the brownies from Fat Witch I just didn't understand the hype. Tasted like just regular ole brownies to me!”
H2
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?35 pts
“Fat witch has good brownies”
H2
in:NYC Food or Foodie thing that travels well?26 pts
“[Fat Witch](https://maps.app.goo.gl/2nXqKghXw7oLjzDY7) Bakery in Chelsea Market has good brownie.”
H2
in:Food Halls & Speciality Grocery Stores9 pts
“I think they're good but I think all brownies are good, Fat Witch didn't feel significantly better than other brownies that I've had in my life but it's worth a try.”
H2
in:Best Brownies In NYC?8 pts
“Not a big brownie fan, but man… that Fat Witch is damn good”
H2
in:Food souvenirs to bring back to Europe5 pts
“[Fat Witch Bakery](https://maps.app.goo.gl/3BzYZznkarHjQD158) in Chelsea Market specializes in brownies, you can grab a bunch of bite size brownies.”
H2
in:I’m going to Chelsea Market this week. Can I ask what you all liked/didn’t like if you’ve been there?5 pts
“I always enjoy a brownie from Fat Witch.”
H2
in:WTF Halloween baked gods for office party4 pts
“Fat Witch bakery brownies. Absolutely wonderful if you're in NYC.”
H2
in:NYC-only chocolates worth taking home?3 pts
“If you’re not stuck on chocolate and would consider interesting brownie flavors then go to Fat Witch, also in Chelsea Market.”
H2
postThree nights in Manhattan2 pts
“the brownies from Fat Witch I just didn't understand the hype. Tasted like just regular ole brownies to me!”
H2
in:Chelsea recs fall 242 pts
“Fat witch bakery in CM has good brownies.”
H2
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?2 pts
“Fat Witch is my favorite of the moist type brownie.”
H2
in:Fat Witch Bakery - free range eggs?2 pts
“Love their brownies though so good!”
H2
in:Best send-off pastry?2 pts
“Fat Witch brownies from Chelsea Market”
H2
in:NYC-only chocolates worth taking home?2 pts
replying to u/TheeWut: Go to economy candy they have a huge selection and it’s cheap. The main one is in the LES but there is a small one in Chelsea Market. If you’re not stuck on chocolate and would consider interesting brownie flavors then go to Fat Witch, also in Chelsea Market.
“I second Fat Witch. The brownies are great and the name makes them fun to take some home.”
H2
postThree nights in Manhattan1 pts
“the brownies from Fat Witch I just didn't understand the hype. Tasted like just regular ole brownies to me!”
H2
in:Trying to eat as much as I can in 4 days. What do you recommend?1 pts
“and grab a mini brownie at Fat Witch.”
H2
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/Clear_Hunt_5644: Fat witch has good brownies
“So overrated”
H2
in:Best Brownies In NYC?1 pts
replying to u/aforawesomee: Fat witch. I tried their boxed ones where you make it at home. It’s not the same. Just buy whatever you already have prepared there.
“Overrated”
H2
in:NYC trip plan lunch help1 pts
replying to u/TheMaderan: I do think Eataly is pretty cool. We have been several times. Any feedback on Chelsea Market? I have herd good things about that area and the High Line. Is it worth trying to get to that area?
“Fat Witch has good brownies.”
H2
in:Best Brownies In NYC?21 pts
“Try Breads or Fat Witch”
H1
in:Chewiest chocolate chip cookie (zero crisp)6 pts
“Fat Witch has a great one.”
H1
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?5 pts
replying to u/Clear_Hunt_5644: Fat witch has good brownies
“this place is dope. Any place that only sells brownies and has the confidence to call them witches, knows what they're doing.”
H1
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?2 pts
“+1 fat witches”
H1
in:Best Brownies In NYC?2 pts
“Fat witch no question”
H1
in:Best Brownies In NYC?2 pts
“Just buy whatever you already have prepared there.”
H1
in:WTF Halloween baked gods for office party1 pts
replying to u/Guypussy: >Fat Witch $200-250 for twelve should just about cover that.
“They're just so gooood 🤩”
H1
in:4 days NYC trip itinerary feedback1 pts
“One of the best desserts in the city.”
H1
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/Clear_Hunt_5644: Fat witch has good brownies
“Yessss”
H1
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/Clear_Hunt_5644: Fat witch has good brownies
“I took this rec because of this thread and was SO disappointed. Tasted like grocery store nonsense I fear.”
H1
in:Who sells the best brownies in Manhattan?1 pts
“Fat witch”
H1
in:Looking for chewy brownies 1 pts
“Fat witch”
H1
in:Best Brownies In NYC?1 pts
replying to u/aforawesomee: Fat witch. I tried their boxed ones where you make it at home. It’s not the same. Just buy whatever you already have prepared there.
“Came here to say this. Fat Witch for the win.”
H1
in:best blondies suggestions1 pts
“Red gate bakery and fat witch”
H1
in:best blondies suggestions1 pts
“I thought fat witch was disappointing”
H1