Sable's Smoked Fish

All 43 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Chopped lover9 pts
“Sables on UES has good chopped liver”
H2
in:1 Weekend in the Upper East Side7 pts
“Sables for Smoked Fish and Appetizing”
H2
in:LF Russ & Daughters alternative5 pts
“Sables in UES is the move. Go for all the smoked fishes but don’t sleep on their lobster salad.”
H2
in:Best Bagel on the UES?!4 pts
“The move is to grab a bagel from Tal’s and the whitefish salad from Sable’s. 10/10.”
H2
in:Best bagel and lox I had so far (Apollo Bagels in Williamsburg). Feel free to recommend any others if any in the same caliber as I haven't found any others in NYC.4 pts
replying to u/Electrical-Sense-156: The best is buying all of your fish at an appetizing store like Russ and Daughters or Sables or a good counter like at Zabars. Then you go to a bagel shop that bakes on premises. Buy fresh bagels. Go home and assemble your open faced bagel sandwiches.
“Sables is run by the best fishcutters in the City who opened up their own shop after defecting from Zabars”
H2
in:Pick-A-Bagel on 23rd and 3rd: Sable on everything with onions, tomatoes, and capers with jalapeño cream cheese3 pts
“Sables is awesome. Their smoked salmon is the best in NYC.”
H2
in:You’re putting together a good NYC food gift basket; what to include?3 pts
“Lox from Sable’s”
H2
in:Urgently need the best Lox and Cream Cheese bagel spot in NYC for lunch today!3 pts
“Nova Lox from Sables - both on the upper east side”
H2
in:I want to show my friend distinctly American foods in NYC. Where should I bring them?3 pts
“Bagel n Lox from Sable’s”
H2
in:Best bagel and lox I had so far (Apollo Bagels in Williamsburg). Feel free to recommend any others if any in the same caliber as I haven't found any others in NYC.3 pts
replying to u/Bigdaddyhef-365: Sables is run by the best fishcutters in the City who opened up their own shop after defecting from Zabars Their bagels come from NY Jumbo Bagels and are excellent and perfectly sized
“Yeah Sables is excellent and as you said great cutters.”
H2
in:Pick-A-Bagel on 23rd and 3rd: Sable on everything with onions, tomatoes, and capers with jalapeño cream cheese2 pts
“whitefish salad plus Scottish smoked salmon from Sables. Skip the cream cheese.”
H2
in:Best matzo ball soup that will deliver to Memorial Sloan Kettering? And, best espresso martini?2 pts
replying to u/reddispaghetti: Sables
“Sable’s also has one of the best shrimp wonton soups I have ever had. And oh my goodness the Lobster salad. And yes all the fish is top tier.”
H2
in:Chocolate Babka2 pts
“Great babka Jewish Oneg, in Hasidic Williamsburg Sables Manhattan”
H2
in:Pick-A-Bagel on 23rd and 3rd: Sable on everything with onions, tomatoes, and capers with jalapeño cream cheese1 pts
replying to u/MIKE_THE_KILLER: Sables is awesome. Their smoked salmon is the best in NYC.
“Agree. And whitefish salad.”
H2
in:Moving to the UES - looking for your favorite restaurants, delivery/takeout spots, cafes etc.1 pts
“Sables has amazing fish salads and smoked fish”
H2
in:Moving to the UES - looking for your favorite restaurants, delivery/takeout spots, cafes etc.1 pts
“Bagels: Tals (in spite of their terrible service) + Sables for fish.”
H2
in:What's the best thing you've eaten in NYC 2023?1 pts
“Smoked sable and cream cheese on a sesame bagel from Sables (UES)”
H2
in:LF Russ & Daughters alternative1 pts
“I get my bagels from Tal and my fish from Sables now.”
H2
in:Alright, BEST bagel in 2024 (also best lox, best whitefish, best BEC)?1 pts
“Sables for Scottish smoked salmon.”
H2
in:Is there a better babka than the one from Oneg Bakery?1 pts
“sables is a very close second for me.”
H2
in:Heading to NYC next weekend, is there a food item that I can pick up and freez for me folks when they visit me 3 months from now?1 pts
“Sables lox. Order from gold belly”
H2
in:Bagels near the Met1 pts
“New Yorks Top Appetizing is at Sables. Walking distance from the Met. Belly Lox, sturgeon, ehitefish and baked salmon salad, fresh bagels, awesome chocolate babka”
H2
in:What lox bagel shop gives a generous portion of lox?26 pts
“The correct answer is to buy your appetizing at one of the good places like Zabars, Sables or Russ and Daughters.”
H1
in:Best bagel and lox I had so far (Apollo Bagels in Williamsburg). Feel free to recommend any others if any in the same caliber as I haven't found any others in NYC.18 pts
“The best is buying all of your fish at an appetizing store like Russ and Daughters or Sables or a good counter like at Zabars.”
H1
in:What's your most controvertial nyc food scene opinion?14 pts
“You buy your appetizing (cured and smoked fish) at a place like Zabars, Sables or Russ and Daughters.”
H1
in:Chopped lover6 pts
“Sables is definitely solid”
H1
in:Recommendations for Chocolate Babka5 pts
“Zabars, sables, and orwashers are all great.”
H1
in:best whitefish bagel in nyc?5 pts
“Sables has the best”
H1
in:New in NYC3 pts
“Seconding and thirding the Jewish appetizing places: Zabars, Sables, Murray’s Sturgeon Shop, Barney Greengrass.”
H1
in:Recommendations for Chocolate Babka3 pts
“Sables”
H1
in:Babka review!3 pts
“Top Tier”
H1
in:Bagel w/ Lox on the UES2 pts
“Sable's is the best”
H1
in:Where are the best bagels to pair with a spread from Russ and Daughters? Also best bagels in Lower Manhattan in general?2 pts
“Sables, Barney Greengrass and Russ and Daughter are New Yorks best Appetizing Stores.”
H1
in:Pick-A-Bagel on 23rd and 3rd: Sable on everything with onions, tomatoes, and capers with jalapeño cream cheese1 pts
replying to u/tartarus2: Are you saying Sables the store is awesome, or OP's sable sandwich is awsome?
“Both? Both. Both are good.”
H1
in:What should we look for next as “the best in NYC”??1 pts
“Correct answers to the above are roll n roaster or Brennan and Carr (both sheepshead bay), sables (UES), and caravan chicken (Astoria)”
H1
in:best whitefish bagel in nyc?1 pts
“Sables ! Not even close. Try before you buy”
H1
in:Best matzo ball soup that will deliver to Memorial Sloan Kettering? And, best espresso martini?1 pts
“Sables”
H1
in:What bagel places have stuffed bagels like Saddle’s? But travels well1 pts
“Sable?”
H1
in:Smoked Whitefish & Lox in Manhattan (packaged)1 pts
“Sables”
H1
in:Where are the best bagels to pair with a spread from Russ and Daughters? Also best bagels in Lower Manhattan in general?1 pts
replying to u/Bigdaddyhef-365: Sables, Barney Greengrass and Russ and Daughter are New Yorks best Appetizing Stores. Sables uses NY Jumbo Bagels, 1070 2nd avenue. The other two use their own.
“These stores specialize in this type of food and get better stuff then your local bagel shop would.”
H1
in:Where are the best bagels to pair with a spread from Russ and Daughters? Also best bagels in Lower Manhattan in general?1 pts
“These stores specialize in this type of food and get better stuff then your local bagel shop would.”
H1
in:Best Bagel on the UES?!0 pts
“Sable’s”
H1
in:Russ & Daughters-3 pts
“Sables on the UES”
H1