DeStefano's Steakhouse

8.3/10American

AI-generated summary

Old school Williamsburg steakhouse that people keep calling slept on. Get the , with the home . Regulars bring up how easy it is to get a table almost as often as the , and several rank it over Peter Luger.

593 Lorimer St, BrooklynWilliamsburg, BrooklynGoogle Maps

What Reddit says41

View all

in:What’s an absolute gem of a place you don’t hear talked about very much in the city? 9 pts
replying to u/PhonyPapi: St Anselm gets thrown around a lot but I'm not sure I'm seen Destefano's mentioned much if at all on this sub and it's a few block away from St Anselm
“It’s so many levels above St. Anselm as far as steak goes.”
H2
in:What’s the deal with Old Homestead? I never see it mentioned much but it seems solid? 3 pts
“I like going there because it's simpler for reservations and the quality is pretty good.”
H2
in:Best place for a rib eye steak? Keens does not have it1 pts
“Destefanos has a solid ribeye.”
H2
in:Best steakhouse in nyc is…1 pts
“Not in any order, but all are worth a try…”
H2
in:What’s the deal with Old Homestead? I never see it mentioned much but it seems solid? 1 pts
replying to u/LeftReflection6620: I just learned about this place today! Def saving. Much appreciated.
“my favorite traditional steakhouse because of how easy it is to get a table, and the steaks are great.”
H2
in:NYC steakhouses1 pts
“DeStefanos in Williamsburg is so under-rated. Their ribeye is fantastic and they got that old school Brooklyn atmosphere, no hipsters.”
H2
in:Places like St. Anselm but better service?1 pts
replying to u/imVengy: alright i'll bite.... i walk past this place a lot (i go to mo's which is just up the street like once a week cuz my wife works there). it's always empty. not sure why. it seems like a great neighborhood spot. what's the order and i'll make sure to check it out soon. thanks.
“Personally, I’m a big fan of the ribeye and the home fries”
H2
in:Smith and wollensky or Benjamin’s0 pts
“I like it better than Keens, Old Homestead, destefanos, and Luger.”
H2
in:Steakhouse suggestions besides the amazing Keens? -2 pts
“I really like DeStefano’s in Williamsburg. Has an old school Italian vibe and is on a nondescript residential block near the Lorimer L.”
H2

See all 41 mentions