Pisticci

All 40 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:People watching & reading on the UWS?10 pts
“Pisticci - killer grapefruit martini and you can sit at the bar and read or grab a table outside”
H2
in:What is the best dessert you've doordashed in NYC while high?6 pts
“Coconut cake from Pisticci”
H2
in:Restaurant recommendation around Harlem/UWS5 pts
“I love Pisticci. Never had a bad meal there, and it’s so cozy.”
H2
in:Restaurant recs for my sad sis3 pts
replying to u/Ill-Raisin-7313: I like Pisticci in Harlem for a no frills (but still delicious) cozy Italian meal and bottle of wine. Hope she feels better soon. Losing a pet is so hard.
“Pisticci is also a solid brunch option -- their lemon ricotta pancakes are very good.”
H2
in:What are some NYC restaurants that are criminally underrated?3 pts
“Pisticci, best garlic bread in the city”
H2
in:What do you think is the best dessert in nyc?3 pts
“The coconut cake at Pisticci is fabulous”
H2
in:UWS Red Sauce Joint?2 pts
“Pisticci in Morningside Heights is pretty good (122nd)! A+ garlic bread”
H2
in:Best spots for tiramisu?1 pts
“I had some really good tiramisu at Pisticci up in morningside”
H2
in:Best spots for tiramisu?1 pts
replying to u/_TakeTheL: I had some really good tiramisu at Pisticci up in morningside
“They had an amazing coconut cake there a few years ago”
H2
in:Best Pasta in NY?1 pts
“Lamb Ragu at Pisticci in Morningsise Heights”
H2
in:Affordable Italian restaurants in NYC1 pts
replying to u/myspicename: For 20-25 dollars a person? Their specials are like twice that.
“Pisticci’s pastas hover around $18-25 and they’re all fantastic.”
H2
in:Best “step-down” restaurants?1 pts
“Cozy atmosphere and good Italian cuisine.”
H2
in:What’s your favorite coconut flavored dessert in the city?1 pts
“Coconut cake at Pisticci in Manhattanville”
H2
in:16th bday restaurant recommendations1 pts
“Pisticci on West 125th St has great pasta and a private area that sits \~25. They have a nice cozy vibe too.”
H2
in:Restaurant recommendation around Harlem/UWS1 pts
“if you wanna do italian i think max soha is better than pisticci!”
H2
in:Birthday dinner next Sunday24 pts
“Try Pisticci, Ci Siamo, Zou Zou, and Kebab Aur Sharab.”
H1
in:Restaurant recs for my sad sis23 pts
“I like Pisticci in Harlem for a no frills (but still delicious) cozy Italian meal and bottle of wine.”
H1
in:Help! Orecchiette With Sausage and Broccoli Rabe6 pts
“Pisticci!”
H1
in:What to eat around City College?6 pts
“classic neighborhood anchor, even if it’s kind of been superseded by other spots.”
H1
in:Best (somewhat affordable) Italian where a reservation is attainable- for proposal evening3 pts
“Pisticci or Max Soha in the UWS -- what is your budget?”
H1
in:I’ve eaten/drank at over 1,100 bars and restaurants in NYC. AMA!2 pts
“Pisticci on LaSalle…went to Columbia over twenty years ago and I still make the trek down there a few times a year.”
H1
in:What is a good Italian restaurant in the Upper West Side that has vegetarian options?2 pts
“Pisticci on La Salle and Broadway is a great spot for a date.”
H1
in:Help! Orecchiette With Sausage and Broccoli Rabe2 pts
replying to u/Vegan_Kirby: Pisticci!
“+1 for Pisticci. I had it there last night.”
H1
in:Good Italian near United Palace Theatre - 4140 Broadway in Washington Heights2 pts
“Great place”
H1
in:Best/good places to eat around 125th in Harlem Manhattan ?2 pts
“Pisticci”
H1
in:What's your "go-to" casual neighborhood spot?1 pts
“Pisticci, upper upper west side!”
H1
in:Affordable Italian restaurants in NYC1 pts
“Pisticci! Right off the 125 1 stop :)”
H1
in:UWS Red Sauce Joint?1 pts
“Pisticci.”
H1
in:What’s your neighborhood spot that is good, maybe just OK, but you love it so much?1 pts
“just homey and reliable.”
H1
in:What’s your neighborhood spot that is good, maybe just OK, but you love it so much?1 pts
replying to u/icancook2: Pisticci in Morningside Heights/West Harlem (its near the border) - just homey and reliable. Station House in Forest Hills - its fine usually, pretty good sometimes.
“Great spot.”
H1
in:What’s your neighborhood spot that is good, maybe just OK, but you love it so much?1 pts
replying to u/thenumbersthenumbers: I miss Pisticci from my grad school days! Great spot.
“Love this place.”
H1
in:Looking for a great Italian spot in NYC that’s not IMPOSSIBLE to get into1 pts
“La Masseria, Masseria Dei Vini, Pisticci”
H1
in:Best Italian That Won’t Break The Bank?1 pts
“pisticci up in Harlem”
H1
in:Best italian spot on the UWS?1 pts
“Also like previously mentioned Pisticci and Salumeria Rosi.”
H1
in:Restaurant recommendation around Harlem/UWS1 pts
“Pisticci average Italian.”
H1
in:I plotted r/FoodNYC's most upvoted restaurants of December on a custom Google Map1 pts
“There's so much better Italian food up here - like at Arco, Accademia, Bosino, Pisticci - and that's just above 96th St.”
H1
in:Is anyone else fed up with restaurants in NYC?0 pts
“Check out Piccola Cucina Estiatorio, Pisticci, or any of the Felice locations for Italian.”
H1
in:Good for group of 10 and kids? 0 pts
“Pisticci”
H1
in:Restaurant recommendation around Harlem/UWS0 pts
replying to u/Round_Pea_5082: I love Pisticci. Never had a bad meal there, and it’s so cozy. Haven’t been to Sottacasa, I like Jin Ramen but imo the vibe is just that much less comfy than Pisticci.
“I second this”
H1
in:Restaurant recommendation around Harlem/UWS0 pts
“Pisticci for the win. Haven’t been in sometime but love the place.”
H1