Pietros

All 49 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What is the single best tasting dish you can eat in the whole city?8 pts
“Veal parmigiana at Pietro’s is up there for me”
H2
in:If you could only order one menu item in all of NYC, what would it be? (Stolen from r/philadelphiaeats5 pts
“Chicken Parm from Pietro's.”
H2
in:What is your go-to spot around Grand Central?4 pts
replying to u/RedNalgene00: Pietros is good old school Italian. Rio grande for Mexican/margaritas. Alidoro for sandwiches. Urban space grand central for a variety of good eats
“The veal parm at Pietros is perfection. Love that spot”
H2
in:Great red gravy Italian in Manhattan?3 pts
replying to u/Unlikely-Guess3775: Pietro's - very old school, and still high quality.
“Came here to recommend Pietro’s get the veal parm! It’s bigger than a small child”
H2
in:Chicken Parm Recs3 pts
“Pietro’s or the Palm West old school Italian where they pound the chicken flat and the portions are twice the size of your head.”
H2
in:Who has the best Caesar salad in the city?2 pts
“Pietros in Midtown actually makes a killer caesar tableside. The rest of their food is.....fine, but the caesar is standout”
H2
in:Looking for lunch/dinner near Bryant Park2 pts
“Best chicken parm”
H2
in:B-day chicken/veal parm2 pts
“Pietro’s for veal parm”
H2
in:What's really quiet romantic dinner place in manhattan?2 pts
replying to u/Anxious-Sheepherder2: One if by Land, Two if by Sea
“Pietro's is a great underrated spot too.”
H2
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?2 pts
replying to u/golyhrail: Currently closed, but Pietro’s is it for me
“The veal parm at Pietro’s 🤌🏼”
H2
in:Midtown East Suggestions-2 pts
replying to u/bittinho: Sakagura, Wollensky’s Grill, Pietro’s, Sparks, Avra, Il Tinello, Alcala
“Pietro's is terrible and overpriced”
H2
in:Red Sauce Italian24 pts
replying to u/nihtastic: John's of 12th St., very kid friendly
“which is in midtown and has better food.”
H1
in:Lunch for 8 people near Grand Central16 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:What is your go-to spot around Grand Central?13 pts
“Pietros is good old school Italian.”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?9 pts
“Currently closed, but Pietro’s is it for me”
H1
in:Great red gravy Italian in Manhattan?8 pts
“Pietro's - very old school, and still high quality.”
H1
in:Good “Classic NYC” Restaurants for Out of Towners?7 pts
“For the true old school vibe I’ll throw in Barney Greengrass, Campagnola, Pietros, Garguilo’s, and Peter Luger.”
H1
in:Great red gravy Italian in Manhattan?5 pts
“Pietros or Mimis”
H1
in:B-day chicken/veal parm4 pts
“Park Side is my pick. Or Pietros. Those are my two faves.”
H1
in:Delicious food in NYC that isn't available in LA?3 pts
“Pietros for old classic red sauce Italian”
H1
in:Best red sauce joint for solo people watching & stuffing my face in the corner3 pts
“Pietros, Patsys of 56 or Mimis”
H1
in:Best red sauce joint for solo people watching & stuffing my face in the corner3 pts
replying to u/CastIronDaddy: Pietros, Patsys of 56 or Mimis
“Seconding Pietros. Love that place.”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?3 pts
replying to u/golyhrail: Currently closed, but Pietro’s is it for me
“This is the right answer”
H1
in:Midtown East Suggestions3 pts
“Pietro’s”
H1
in:Best chicken parmesean in NYC recommendation??????3 pts
“Pietros for the win!”
H1
in:Red Sauce Italian recommendations (Midtown/ East Village)3 pts
“Pietro’s on 47th and 2nd if that counts as midtown.”
H1
in:Best veal parmagiana and wiener schnitzels in New York?2 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:OG steakhouses2 pts
“Also like Pietros.”
H1
in:What is your go-to spot around Grand Central?2 pts
replying to u/RedNalgene00: Pietros is good old school Italian. Rio grande for Mexican/margaritas. Alidoro for sandwiches. Urban space grand central for a variety of good eats
“Second, love this place, like walking through a Time Machine to the early 60s”
H1
in:Quietest Restaurants for lunch around 57th and Madison?2 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:Best Chicken Parm near midtown? 2 pts
“Pietro's !!!”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?2 pts
replying to u/golyhrail: Currently closed, but Pietro’s is it for me
“Strong contender”
H1
in:Red Sauce Italian2 pts
“Pietro's, Il Mulino, Paul and Jimmy's.”
H1
in:Which restaurants in Manhattan are well-regarded for classic spaghetti?2 pts
“Pietro’s”
H1
in:Chicken Parm Recs1 pts
replying to u/bittinho: Pietro’s or the Palm West old school Italian where they pound the chicken flat and the portions are twice the size of your head.
“Pietros so bad now. Riding their now”
H1
in:Chicken Parm Recs1 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:B-day chicken/veal parm1 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:B-day chicken/veal parm1 pts
“Pietros. You won’t be disappointed”
H1
in:Anyone have any weekday diner recommendations in the East 40s or upper 30s? Food must be good!1 pts
“Pietro’s”
H1
in:Italian Restaurants overlooked by Eater NY1 pts
“Pietro’s”
H1
in:Best American-Italian Restaurant located in Manhattan 1 pts
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?1 pts
replying to u/golyhrail: Currently closed, but Pietro’s is it for me
“Came here to say this! Pietro’s- RIP”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?1 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:What are some good Italian restaurants to take 7 midwestern dudes (all in their 60s) who have never been to NYC?1 pts
“Good red sauce Italian on 47/2nd.”
H1
in:Red Sauce Italian1 pts
H1
in:Dinner reservation for bfs 45th!1 pts
“I am a fan of [Pietro's.]”
H1
in:Red Sauce Italian recommendations (Midtown/ East Village)1 pts
“Pietro’s in east midtown or Vincent’s in little Italy”
H1
in:Red Sauce Italian recommendations (Midtown/ East Village)1 pts
“Pietros”
H1
in:Red Sauce Italian recommendations (Midtown/ East Village)0 pts
replying to u/bighen0829: Pietro’s on 47th and 2nd if that counts as midtown.
“10000% came here to say this. A true New Yorker establishment”
H1