Colonie

All 56 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Recommendation in Brooklyn?12 pts
“Colonie in Brooklyn Heights is new American, while still being pretty safe and straight forward but not as monotonous as steakhouses tend to be”
H2
in:Having a very sudden craving for sticky toffee pudding. What are your favorite places and favorite desserts that have that same sticky and dense but moist texture, sticky toffee pudding include but not exclusively?10 pts
“Colonie in Brooklyn has a good sticky date cake”
H2
in:What do you think is the best dessert in nyc?10 pts
“Sticky date cake at Colonie in Brooklyn Heights. Chef’s. Kiss. Clap. Clap.”
H2
in:Favorite restaurants to get just desserts in Brooklyn?9 pts
“I love the STICKY DATE CAKE at Colonie 🤌🏻”
H2
in:Post Brooklyn Borough Hall Civil Wedding Dinner Ideas6 pts
“[Colonie](https://www.colonienyc.com/) is farm to table, changing menu, great cocktails and wine but may be tricky if you have a large party.”
H2
in:What disappointed you recently?6 pts
“The pasta for my main was smothered in too much cheese.”
H2
in:What Brooklyn restaurant “wow’d” you recently?6 pts
replying to u/Late-Log-8620: Can’t believe not a single person mentioned Colonie. Feel like I’ve been to every restaurant here and Colonie is the best by far
“Colonie is stellar. I ate there 19 times in the first 8 months they were open. And probably 50 times since. It’s stayed consistently excellent for 14 years straight”
H2
in:“Standing on the Corner, Tik Tok in my hand”5 pts
“Turkish eggs and sticky date cake. Worth it.”
H2
in:What are some restaurants that definitely *don't* skimp on the portion sizes?4 pts
“the portions aren't massive but it's not that precious and damn good.”
H2
in:Good breakfast spots3 pts
“Colonie on Atlantic also has a very very good brunch—the Turkish eggs are a neighborhood staple.”
H2
in:What’s the best thing you’ve ate recently3 pts
“the sticky date cake from colonie”
H2
in:Good place for sticky toffee pudding in nyc. Help me please3 pts
“Colonie’s sticky date cake!”
H2
in:What is the best dessert dish you've had so far this year?2 pts
“the date cake at Colonie on Atlantic Avenue is crazy amazing”
H2
in:If you could only ever eat one pasta dish forever, in nyc, what would you choose? 1 pts
“Rigatoni from Colonie”
H2
in:NYC for 4 days family of 4 with kids ages 11 and 91 pts
“One of the best most consistent places in the city. I’ll put their pastas against any on the city.”
H2
in:Weekday brunch spot within walking distance of the Transit Museum?1 pts
“their Turkish Eggs would be a part of my dying meal.”
H2
in:help choosing birthday dinner spots in wburg or bk heights0 pts
“Colonie is good though it has never been the same since Jared Braithwaite left.”
H2
in:List of great restaurants with no michelin stars25 pts
“Evelina, Loreto, Colonia Verde, Olmsted, Sofreh, Gage & Tolner, Birds of a Feather, Shalom Japan, Fausto, Convivium, Bricolage, Boutros, Colonie”
H1
in:Can yall weigh in on the list I made for restaurants to eat at during my visit in July?18 pts
“My fav in Brooklyn is Colonie.”
H1
in:List of great restaurants with no michelin stars14 pts
“* Colonie”
H1
in:What Brooklyn restaurant “wow’d” you recently?14 pts
“Colonie is the best by far”
H1
in:Best Turkish Eggs?7 pts
“colonie in BK Heights!”
H1
in:What are a few of your fav restaurants/eateries that have permanently closed?7 pts
“Colonie”
H1
in:Best restaurants to try in Brooklyn / Queens (including fine dining, no budget necessary)3 pts
“Place des Fetes, Colonie, Bar Bete.”
H1
in:Best Turkish Eggs?3 pts
“Colonie”
H1
in:If you could bring back one closed restaurant, what would it be?3 pts
“Colonie in Brooklyn. Just closed down last month and I’m grieving.”
H1
in:What are a few of your fav restaurants/eateries that have permanently closed?3 pts
“Colonie in Brooklyn”
H1
in:What's the best Restaurant dessert (of any kind) in NYC?2 pts
replying to u/404random: sticky toffee pudding at crown shy is literally a slice of heaven
“Still stellar 13 years later.”
H1
in:Restaurants with best vegetable dishes. Wife loves vegetables but is not vegetarian. What are your restaurant and order recs?2 pts
“Colonie”
H1
in:I've got $250 burning a hole in my pocket and wanna spend it all on a dinner for two in Brooklyn tonight. What's the coolest place I could bring my wife?2 pts
“I like **Colonie**, in Atlantic Av. in Brooklyn Heights.”
H1
in:What do you think is a top restaurant, but doesn’t get enough love/credit?2 pts
“BK: Bar Mario, Big Tiny, Popina, Colonie, Nabila”
H1
in:Lunch after wedding in BK2 pts
“I'll throw in for Gage & Tollner and Colonie for lunch spots.”
H1
in:Thanksgiving dinner at Ardens2 pts
“What a perfect rec—just in time to fill the Colonie-shaped whole in my heart.”
H1
in:Good American style recommendations?1 pts
“Gramercy Tavern, Manhatta, Colonie, Otway, Oxalis, Esme”
H1
in:Fun, nice (but not too nice) restaurants for a birthday in Brooklyn?1 pts
“Check out Colonie on Atlantic ave”
H1
in:Brooklyn Bridge Dinner1 pts
“I’d also add: - Colonie (American)”
H1
in:Popular/highly rated restaurants you’ve been disappointed by?1 pts
replying to u/anotherdamnsong: love to hear the critique of Marea if you're up for it...
“I have been really impressed with most dishes at Boutrous and Colonie, Llama Inn (3 of 4 meals) in Brooklyn and Gagini in Italy.”
H1
in:What are some restaurants that definitely *don't* skimp on the portion sizes?1 pts
replying to u/sickbabe: colonie on atlantic. the portions aren't massive but it's not that precious and damn good. only thing is the drinks get expensive.
“it is my favorite restaurant in the area, especially to treat out-of-towners to!”
H1
in:What are the best restaurants in NYC that are not fine dining or super expensive?1 pts
“Colonie (Brooklyn Heights - American)”
H1
in:an NYC restaurant that is so good and yet still relatively easy to get into?1 pts
“Tuome, Ciccio, Colonie, Otis”
H1
in:What's the worst food you've had in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/PresentBasic3279: Colonie was pretty damn bad. Went about a year ago.
“Colonie is absolutely delicious lol”
H1
in:What's the worst food you've had in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/PresentBasic3279: Colonie was pretty damn bad. Went about a year ago.
“Colonie is fantastic. I can’t believe what you said”
H1
in:Post Brooklyn Borough Hall Civil Wedding Dinner Ideas1 pts
“Colonie!”
H1
in:Post Brooklyn Borough Hall Civil Wedding Dinner Ideas1 pts
“is great particularly if they could reserve you the back area where the chefs counter is”
H1
in:Recommendation for large group dinner1 pts
“Done it a few times. Great food.”
H1
in:Where to take visitors from SF?1 pts
“Sailor and Colonie are my two favorite restaurants in Brooklyn if you’re looking for Americanish.”
H1
in:What Brooklyn restaurant “wow’d” you recently?1 pts
“Colonie. consistently amazing.”
H1
in:What do you think is the best dessert in nyc?1 pts
replying to u/theromeoshow: Sticky date cake at Colonie in Brooklyn Heights. Chef’s. Kiss. Clap. Clap.
“This is the correct answer”
H1
in:What do you think is the best dessert in nyc?1 pts
replying to u/theromeoshow: Sticky date cake at Colonie in Brooklyn Heights. Chef’s. Kiss. Clap. Clap.
“Came here to say this.”
H1
in:Pick an impulse anniversary dinner spot for my wife and I1 pts
“Colonie”
H1