“But they've got the texture right, and they give you more topping than ice cream (nearly), so it is a giant molten pool of chocolate sludge to work through.”
H3
All 58 rated mentions, most helpful first
“But they've got the texture right, and they give you more topping than ice cream (nearly), so it is a giant molten pool of chocolate sludge to work through.”
H3
“Eddies Sweet Shop if you’re willing to travel to Queens”
H2
“For another traditional milkshake, would also recommend Eddie’s Sweet Shop.”
H2
“Eddie’s Sweet Shop isn’t super close, but might be what you’re looking for”
H2
“Eddie’s Sweet Shop”
H2
“Eddie's Sweet Shop”
H2
“For authentic soda shop feel I prefer Eddie’s Sweet Shop in Forest Hills to Brooklyn Farmacy”
H2
“I've never had their milkshakes because their ice creams are fantastic”
H2
“I could truly just eat a bowl of their hot fudge and whipped cream. Don’t even need the ice cream haha!”
H2
“Eddie's Sweet Shop on Metropolitan Avenue in Forest Hills is a must.”
H2
“Comfortland’s bread pudding and the topping at Eddie’s Sweet Shop and Keens hit the mark.”
H2
“Their hot fudge is A+.”
H2
“Eddie's Sweet Shop”
H2
“Eddie's Sweet Shop is a legit old school ice cream shop, with much of their stuff being made in house.”
H2
“Eddie's Sweet Shop”
H2
“butterscotch is the best, fight me”
H2
“- Eddie’s Sweet Shop”
H2
“Best old fashion thick, or thin, or between milkshakes, and malts too.”
H2
“Eddie’s Sweet Shop”
H2
“If you like olde-tymey, [Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills](https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/25/t-magazine/eddies-sweet-shop-queens.html) is well worth a visit.”
H2
“Queens - Eddie’s Sweet Shop”
H2
“Their mint chip is fine, but it's way better once drowned in hot fudge and a mountain of whipped cream.”
H2
“Eddie’s Sweet Shop”
H2
“Eddie's is the gold standard for hot fudge viscosity - it's like watching a high-return investment slowly compound.”
H2
“Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills? Love that place. My arteries don't lol.”
H2
“Not insta worthy but seriously good ice cream, another vote for Eddie’s in Forest Hills.”
H2
“Eddies sweet shop”
H2
“I'd just get a coffee or espresso milkshake and have them toss in some caramel. Eddie's Sweet Shop or Amorino Gelato.”
H2
“i highly recommend Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills. It's been open for over 100 years and they definitely have malt milkshakes.”
H2
“Eddies sweet shop in forest hills!!”
H2
“These are my favorite pickles”
H2
“Eddies Sweet Shop in Queens.”
H2
“Queens: Eddie's Sweet Shop”
H2
“Eddie’s Sweet Shop”
H2
“- Eddie's Sweet Shop”
H2
“Eddie's is the best option, who doesn't want nearly equal portions topping to ice cream?”
H2
“Banana split from eddies sweet shop”
H2
“it's worth it”
H2
“It was delicious.”
H1
“If you want schtick and nostalgia Eddies Sweet Shop and Brooklyn Farmacy are kitschy and fun.”
H1
“Yeah also a good one, far out there in Forest Hills but fun”
H1
“Davey's, Ralph's, Uncle Louie G's, Ray's Candy, Marvel Frozen Dairy, Brooklyn Farmacy, Eddie's, The Social (some fancy flavors but they also have simple flavors), good ol' Carvel”
H1
“Highly recommend.”
H1
“Seconding Eddie's. It's not a terribly far walk from the E train station at 71st-Continental. Completely worth it.”
H1
“Seconding Eddies”
H1
“As long as Eddie's survives in Queens, I can continue to breathe deeply.”
H1
“they hand whip the whipped cream, it’s heavenly 🤌🏼”
H1
“Eddie’s is the best for this”
H1
“Check out a concert at Forest Hills Stadium, eat Burmese food at Asian Bowl and dessert at Eddie's Sweet Shop, an old-fashioned ice cream parlor.”
H1
“If you are willing to go to Queens, Eddie’s Sweet Shop is an historic ice cream counter.”
H1