postManhattan’s Best81 pts
“Personally Pop’s on 57th is one of my faves rn I never hear people talk about it but I thought their margherita was just perfection - amazing crust and super fresh sauce.”
8.7/10
AI-generated summary
A slice shop on 57th and 8th where the runs about $3. People praise the crust and the sauce, which is on the sweet side, and the pepperoni gets called perfectly crisp. A few regulars say the pies have gotten underdone since it got popular. It's open until midnight.
“Personally Pop’s on 57th is one of my faves rn I never hear people talk about it but I thought their margherita was just perfection - amazing crust and super fresh sauce.”
“**3 Star:** Exceptional, worth a trip to another neighborhood.”
“Pop's Pizza has a solid slice.”
“still think pops pizza on w 57 is best slice”
“Best Pizza Slice - Pops Pizza”
“Pizza suprema and pops are solids slices.”
“Pops Pizza - $3 cheese slices”
“Pop’s Pizza on 8th and 57th is the best pizza in that area, I think.”
“skip Pop’s pizza (which kinda gross)”
“Live a block away and it’s by far the best slice I’ve found nearby”
“Pop's is mind-blowingly good. Their pepperoni is the perfect crispiness”
“Pop’s has a great pepperoni slice.”