Sugar Hill Creamery — all mentions

in:VC and private equity owned spots32 pts
replying to u/VeryPuffin: I’ll say, nobody has a bigger and better vegan/non dairy options than VLW. If there is, that aren’t just sorbets at gelato spots, I’m all ears!
“Sugar Hill Creamery has excellent vegan flavors.”
H2
in:Food in Washington heights / Hamilton heights. 30 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery for ice cream.”
H2
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?23 pts
“Blueberry cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery”
H2
in:How is caffe panna so good?13 pts
replying to u/Mysterious-Sir-5837: So funny you say this. I've lived in NYC for 4 years and have never tried it. Love ice cream. I decided to go today. I got the Oreo PB fluff - so up my alley. It had almost 0 mix-in. I had to grab extra PB from my pantry because there was not close to enough in the ice cream. Barely any Oreo. It was good (because all ice cream is good in my opinion - no way to screw it up unless you REALLY screw it up) but not even close to the best ice cream I've ever had. So disappointing for what I was expecting (again, not bad). I would take Jeni's and even the PB honeycomb from Van Leeuwen over it (most similar flavor comparison). I would take B&J's over it. Maybe I just got a bad batch or something. Also, I judge ice cream much more on flavors/mix-ins and almost barely on quality so that may be it as I know CP is known for quality. I don't really care about the "quality" of the ice cream as long as the final product as good. I really wanted to love it and will have to try again but won't go out of my way necessarily.
“On the upside, this weekend I had the Tuma Buna flavor at Sugar Hill Creamery and it is possibly the best ice cream flavor I have ever had in my life.”
H2
in:I need Hot Chocolate reccs for the winter.8 pts
“Best I’ve had lately is from Sugar Hill Creamery. It’s rich and dark and topped with torched marshmallow fluff.”
H2
in:I need Hot Chocolate reccs for the winter.6 pts
replying to u/legaljellybean: Best I’ve had lately is from Sugar Hill Creamery. It’s rich and dark and topped with torched marshmallow fluff.
“I think they make it with ice cream instead of milk which is amazing. The marshmallow is also homemade”
H2
in:Are there any good ice cream spots that have a lot of unique and inventive flavors (not just a few)?6 pts
replying to u/icecream7: Sugar Hill Creamery is the answer!
“I love their blueberry cheesecake (Chairman of the Board) and raspberry jam and cake flavors (George Costanza, seasonal). They have flavors like Haitian hot chocolate, Habichuelas con Dulce, Senegalese spiced coffee etc. I’m a big fan.”
H2
in:Which ice cream places have the best, top tier vanilla that would turn a skeptic into a believer?5 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery's vanilla is terrific.”
H2
in:Where Are the Best Milkshakes in NYC Right Now? -Summer 20265 pts
replying to u/Kennected: Harlem Shake Sugar Hill Creamery
“Ya sugar hill malted milkshakes when i was pregnant 👌”
H2
in:Food in Washington heights / Hamilton heights. 4 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery - ice cream & the best hot chocolate”
H2
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?4 pts
replying to u/pookiecake: Blueberry cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery
“Sweet Socialism (it's a flavor I swear) is amazing”
H2
in:Which ice cream places have the best, top tier vanilla that would turn a skeptic into a believer?3 pts
replying to u/Kennected: Sugar Hill Creamery is my go too Ice Cream Parlor. Check their menu.
“Agree completely, strong and complex vanilla flavor.”
H2
in:Where can I find anything guanabana or soursop?3 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery makes a great soursop ice cream”
H2
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?3 pts
replying to u/pookiecake: Blueberry cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery
“The Tuma Buna is the best ice cream flavor I’ve ever had, period, end of story.”
H2
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?2 pts
replying to u/pookiecake: Blueberry cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery
“I’d say avoid the blueberry cheesecake. I’ve gotten it multiple times over the years, and every time, it’s had a grainy texture, likely from ice crystals.”
H2
in:Dairy free soft serve in the UES?1 pts
“has an awesome rice pudding mango sweet plantain flavor”
H2
in:Best Hot Chocolate in each borough?1 pts
“I like sugar hill creamery’s hot chocolate. It’s made out of ice cream and they add torched marshmallow fluff on top.”
H2
in:Help my food crawl1 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery for ice cream”
H2
in:Are there any good ice cream spots that have a lot of unique and inventive flavors (not just a few)?1 pts
“I had their haitian hot chocolate ice cream and was like wow,,, for a non-haitian spot they really nailed the flavors”
H2
in:Food highlights in Harlem area 1 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery has absolutely wonderful ice cream. I come from Wisconsin and SH beats any ice cream I had there!”
H2
in:I love Caffe Panna ice cream, but it’s a frustrating business1 pts
“Really great ice cream!”
H2
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/pookiecake: Blueberry cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery
“Both great flavors but I live for their orange blossom pistachio (may also be seasonal)”
H2
in:Bang-bang recommendations for parents' night out - Manhattan edition46 pts
“Lalibela Ethiopian and Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?39 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery if you’re uptown”
H1
in:Best soft serve in Manhattan?🍦37 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:Where Are the Best Milkshakes in NYC Right Now? -Summer 202636 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery !! there's 3 locations all over upper Manhattan”
H1
in:Are there any good ice cream spots that have a lot of unique and inventive flavors (not just a few)?33 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:What are your favorite places for Ice Cream or Milkshakes in Manhattan?17 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:Which ice cream places have the best, top tier vanilla that would turn a skeptic into a believer?17 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery is my go too Ice Cream Parlor.”
H1
in:Are there any good ice cream spots that have a lot of unique and inventive flavors (not just a few)?12 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery is the answer!”
H1
in:Ice cream cake in nyc9 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:any recommendations for interesting flavored ice cream / soft serve?6 pts
“[Sugar Hill Creamery](https://www.sugarhillcreamery.com) has really cool flavors. Their vegan options are particularly fun imo.”
H1
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?6 pts
replying to u/pookiecake: Blueberry cheesecake at Sugar Hill Creamery
“everyone i've ever brought there, from out of town or from the city, vegan or regular ice cream, has said it's the best they've ever had.”
H1
in:Are there any good ice cream spots that have a lot of unique and inventive flavors (not just a few)?5 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:I love Caffe Panna ice cream, but it’s a frustrating business5 pts
replying to u/pastypatissiere: 90% as good isn't as good. What spots are are better than cafe panna iyo?
“Sugar Hill Creamery is fantastic imo.”
H1
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?5 pts
replying to u/KoalaOnABuilding: i was just gonna say this is a low-key cut and was gonna make this post, but everyone i've ever brought there, from out of town or from the city, vegan or regular ice cream, has said it's the best they've ever had. big plus that the kids that work there are always stoned out of their mind lol
“I've also gotten multiple people obsessed.”
H1
in:Ice cream cake4 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:Malcolm X and 125st3 pts
“I recommend sugar hill creamery and lee lee’s baked goods”
H1
in:Are there any good ice cream spots that have a lot of unique and inventive flavors (not just a few)?3 pts
replying to u/jaded_toast: Which location do you usually go to? I've gotten them in Dumbo, but I think they mainly had the "classic" flavors. I'm wondering if their Harlem locations might have a wider selection.
“their two Harlem locations have amazing selections of unique flavors.”
H1
in:Favorite places to buy ice cream pints in Manhattan?3 pts
“That's it. That's the answer.”
H1
in:Looking for a good milkshake2 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:What are your favorite places for Ice Cream or Milkshakes in Manhattan?2 pts
“Hands down favorite in the city after 13years here”
H1
in:NYC Food Itinerary2 pts
replying to u/sublimesam: Also Sugar Hill Creamery if you're uptown
“They’re awesome. Good addition.”
H1
in:NYC Food Itinerary2 pts
“Meh I prefer Caffe Panna or Sugar Hill Creamery over Salt and Straw”
H1
in:Apollo Theater Recommendations 2 pts
“Red Rooster, the handpulled noodle, sugar hill creamery”
H1
in:Best ice cream in the city ( not gelato)2 pts
“caffe panna, salt & straw, and sugar hill creamery are my favorites.”
H1
in:How is caffe panna so good?2 pts
replying to u/Siouxsie24: I also do not get the Cafe Panna hype. It tastes too fatty to me, I don’t even get the whipped cream anymore and my tongue still feels coated with fat. I have taken the ice cream course at Penn State mentioned in other comments and even tried to open my own ice cream shop years ago (lesson learned: commercial real estate is an icky business). Also - always being sold out of half your flavors is a bummer. It’s like they sell disappointment. On the upside, this weekend I had the Tuma Buna flavor at Sugar Hill Creamery and it is possibly the best ice cream flavor I have ever had in my life.
“Sugar Hill Creamery FTW!”
H1
in:What to eat around City College?2 pts
“I like Oso and Sugar Hill Creamery”
H1
in:BEST NYC ICE CREAM CAKE?2 pts
“Sugar Hill Creamery or Morgernstern’s”
H1
in:Went about trying the so called best ice creams in NYC ! Cafe Panna , Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream , they were pretty average compared to the local shops in NJ ! Where do you get the best ice cream in NYC ?2 pts
“sugar hill creamery is the best in nyc”
H1