Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

All 53 rated mentions, most helpful first

postI'm not a fan of third wave pizza, what are some classic spots people like?82 pts
“hellboy so fucking good”
H2
postPizza tiers - Roast them, give me new spots71 pts
“**3 Star:** Exceptional, worth a trip to another neighborhood.”
H2
in:L’industrie + Esse double header15 pts
“I love a Paulie Gee’s slice”
H2
postWhite pizza8 pts
“I’ve really enjoyed Paulie Gees slice shop’s Mootz slice”
H2
in:What are the best by the slice pizzas in New York?7 pts
“Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop for their Hellboy”
H2
in:My Top Grandma Slices in NYC. What am I missing out on?7 pts
“Freddie Prinze Paulie Gee’s slice shop”
H2
in:Restaurants in Greenpoint 7 pts
“Paulie Gee's Slice Shop / Upside Pizza - for a slice of pizza”
H2
in:L’industrie + Esse double header6 pts
“L’industrie is so so much better than Paulie Gee’s lmfao”
H2
in:Am I missing any essential NYC eats as a tourist?6 pts
replying to u/petrescu: If they’re going to laserwolf then they should just spend the day in Williamsburg/Greenpoint and hit up Taco Ramirez for lunch.
“Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, Joe's, L'industrie for Pizza.”
H2
in:What are the 3-5 must try pizza places?5 pts
“They are sorta incompetent here and have quality control issues. When its fire its fire though.”
H2
in:What are the 3-5 must try pizza places?5 pts
replying to u/the_chonkist: Some controversial takes. L'industrie and Scarrs are overrated, by a lot. My issue with L'industrie is they don't put enough cheese on the margherita slice. I feel bad writing this because they know me by name there (its the closest pizza place to me). The pizza game in NYC is so competitive now that you can find a great slice without waiting in an hour long line. These takes aren't "the best in nyc" but go here if you're close. Paulie Gee's Slice Shop - Hellboy slice .... they sometimes will give you a cold slice of pizza. They are sorta incompetent here and have quality control issues. When its fire its fire though. Upside Pizza - Really consistent, solid stuff. Joes Pizza - \^\^ Ace's Pizza - My fav detroit style, the supreme / hamburger / pepper trio are all great. Prince Street Pizza - my favorite square slice
“The hellboy is my favorite pie”
H2
in:Who is your go to pizza place in nyc?2 pts
“Paulie Gee slice shop Greenpoint area for their Hellboy Sicilian or slice, they also have a restaurant couple blocks away.”
H2
in:My Top Grandma Slices in NYC. What am I missing out on?2 pts
“the Freddie Prinze slice at Paulie Gees slice shop I really enjoy because of the sesame seeds on the bottom”
H2
in:Are there any Dairy-Free pizza places you could recommend?2 pts
“Paulie Gee’s slice shop makes a pretty good non-dairy pie”
H2
in:Pizza Ratings from a first timer in NYC (2024)2 pts
replying to u/killerasp: Lucia Pizza of Soho Best Pizza L&B Spumoni Gardens Roberta's Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop Upside Pizza Speedy Romeo's Rubirosa
“Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop takes the cake for most overrated in the city imo Went there and got two slices, both hot and fresh, both totally unremarkable to me”
H2
in:Who is your go to pizza place in nyc?1 pts
“other ny style slices I love: Paulie gee's slice shop”
H2
in:Who is your go to pizza place in nyc?1 pts
“I have traveled by subway for Paulie Gee's slice shop (I can't get enough of their Hellboy squared pizza)”
H2
in:My Top Grandma Slices in NYC. What am I missing out on?1 pts
“Paulie Gees slice shop in Greenpoint has a really good grandma slice”
H2
in:LAST MINUTE ADVICE: give me one more pizza spot!1 pts
“If you want some thick squares, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop or Mama's Too.”
H2
in:NYC Pizza: 2023 Recap1 pts
replying to u/tilmydaysrdone: 1. Upside Pizza (Greenpoint) 2. L’Industrie (Williamsburg) 3. Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop (Greenpoint) 4. Little Charli (West Village) 5. Motorino (East Village) 6. Fini (Williamsburg) 7. Marinara Pizza (East Village) 8. Sotto Le Stelle (Long Island City) 9. Brunetti Pizza (West Village) 10. Gran Torino (Williamsburg)
“Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop: 8.2/10 (Hellboy)”
H2
in:Looking to impress my tattooed, millennial sister visiting from Portland, ME. Williamsburg/Greenpoint … something uniquely of the area. Price/genre not important, just vibe. I’m older and out of touch.1 pts
“take some slices from Paul’s gees slice shop”
H2
postJust did a short slice tour. Classic cheese slice only. Was... underwhelmed.0 pts
“Paulie Gee's: whatever. Generic in every single way. Under seasoned crust and sauce. Nothing distinguishable about it.”
H2
in:Last month in NYC: pls help with bucket list0 pts
replying to u/jaded_toast: I might get a lot of hate for saying this, but Prince St. are bigots, and I personally wasn't a fan of Di Fara the one time I tried them. I really disliked it enough to write it off instead of giving it another shot, and what I've seen in this sub is that it seems like while there are still fans, the consensus seems to be that the quality and consistency has gone downhill since the original owner first stepped down. I'm really surprised that you haven't been to a Joe's yet. I personally think that people often set the wrong expectation when they go there. I don't think that they're the best slice, but I do feel like they are the quintessential NY slice.
“Add Paulie Gee's Slice Shop for their square Hellboy with hot honey, too. That's my top slice in the city.”
H2
postPlaces You Think Are Over-hyped & Where You Would Recommend Going Instead103 pts
“Excellent slices can be had at Jonny's, Philomena's, Best, Diamond Slice, F&F, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, SliceHaus, Fermento, or Patsy's in East Harlem.”
H1
in:You have to leave NYC and move to LA, you have 48 hours left to eat, where are you going?103 pts
“Paulie Gees Slice shop”
H1
in:NYC Pizza: 2023 Recap44 pts
“3. Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop (Greenpoint) ”
H1
postL’industrie + Esse double header29 pts
“I would choose Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop and Ramirez over these two any day. Not even close IMO.”
H1
in:Day Off - Crowded Spots Must Haves?19 pts
“Paulie Gee's Slice Shop”
H1
in:Greenpoint must visits besides the obvious.16 pts
“All of these are good options. Enjoy!!”
H1
postFood reviews from a month in NYC - Restaurants, Pizza, and Bagels [April 2024]14 pts
H1
in:Best 3-Spot Pizza Walk Recs?12 pts
“Could also add in Paulie Gee's slice shop nearby in Greenpoint”
H1
in:Pizza Recommendations -Downtown10 pts
replying to u/heepofsheep: Joes is pretty much like any decent slice you can get in region. If you live in an area with terrible pizza then yeah it’ll be great but if you’re coming from NJ, CT, PA, etc it won’t be anything special.
“IMO Joe's is a step down from the elites including L'Industrie, Funzi's, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop.”
H1
in:Do you have to wait in line out the door for a good slice in manhattan?9 pts
“Mama's Too, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop are my two faves.”
H1
in:Best pizza slices in Brooklyn outside Williamsburg?7 pts
“Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop, and Best Pizza are two of my favs in Brooklyn.”
H1
in:Do any of the "top"pizza places do delivery?5 pts
“Those are a whole bunch of different styles but all delicious in their own way.”
H1
in:NYC Pizza: 2023 Recap5 pts
“For slices, Fini and Paulie Gee’s slice shop were both standout and fair for the price.”
H1
in:Need Help with Divey Pizza Place5 pts
“Paulie Gee’s Slice shop.”
H1
in:What is your favorite delivery restaurant/meal? 5 pts
“**Paulie Gee's Slice Shop** - they are in Greenpoint and deliver via DoorDash. I really love their pizza.”
H1
in:You have to leave NYC and move to LA, you have 48 hours left to eat, where are you going?4 pts
replying to u/GotPizzaMouth: Xian famous foods, l’industrie, fini, Paulie Gees Slice shop, shelskys for a “member of the tribe” on a bialy, Bonnie’s, radio bakery, chicharonnes from Muncan food Corp (astoria) and anything from comfortland.
“Last week I picked up a full pie from Pauli’s gees slice shop before a trivia night and fuck me it was perfect.”
H1
in:Your favourite spots? 3 days in NYC. 3 pts
“they’re truly like great expressions of both”
H1
in:Realistic Recommendations3 pts
“Pizza (slices): Mamas too, L Industrie, Fini, pauli Gees slice shop, pizza suprema, Joes, Scarrs”
H1
in:Best slices of pizza in Brooklyn plus other can’t miss eats.3 pts
“Pauli gees slice shop”
H1
in:Greenpoint must visits besides the obvious.2 pts
“Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop”
H1
in:Pizza Ratings from a first timer in NYC (2024)2 pts
“Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop”
H1
in:What are the best by the slice pizzas in New York?1 pts
replying to u/pumper911: L’Industrie is my number 1 overall for slices, specifically their burrata and fig jam and bacon Best Pizza for their Grandma Prince Street for their square pepperoni Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop for their Hellboy
“Otherwise I'm also on board with all your recommendations.”
H1
in:Must-go places in 20241 pts
replying to u/No-Ad-353: Paulie Gee’s was ok when I went. I heard the slice shop is better though.
“I think the slice shop is wayyy better”
H1
in:Let’s argue about The Infatuation’s best pizza list1 pts
“I do really enjoy Paulie Gee's Slice Shop”
H1
in:Need Help with Divey Pizza Place1 pts
replying to u/cutratestuntman: Paulie Gee’s Slice shop.
“Great pizza, but I’ve been avoiding to place for years now with so many other great options in NYC.”
H1
in:Keens for lunch? Recommendations for nomad?1 pts
“Taqueria Ramirez, Taku Sando, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, El Pengüino for food.”
H1
in:Dinner recommendations (Italian, Burger, Steak)1 pts
“I like l Industrie, Fini, Diamond slice, Paulie gees slice shop, best pizza, ceres”
H1