“And even though Old John’s is a diner, it’s spiffed up and ever-popular with the older UWS locals.”
H2
All 66 rated mentions, most helpful first
“And even though Old John’s is a diner, it’s spiffed up and ever-popular with the older UWS locals.”
H2
“Our family’s favorite spot is Old John’s Diner on W 67 St. They have something for everyone, and the prices are reasonable.”
H2
“PJ Clarke’s or Old John’s if you like burgers and diner fare.”
H2
“Delicious, reasonably priced, and the diner vibes are on point.”
H2
“Ooh really love the one at Old John’s Luncheonette”
H2
“Avoid Old John's. It's a hipster approximation of a diner... A place where people take pictures of their food.”
H2
“S&P and Old John's both make pretty good egg creams”
H2
“Old John’s luncheonette has a very good one!”
H2
“I went a couple of months ago and found it remodeled, menu changed, and the service very lackluster.”
H2
“Just had a great tuna melt at Old John’s Diner.”
H2
“I also love Old John’s Luncheonette which is SLIGHTLY out of your way but just slightly - it has a good NYC diner feel but the food is a little more upscale.”
H2
“i was there last in early march and we both enjoyed our food and the service - it was a weekday around 1pm and pretty crowded (we waited about 10 minutes for a table) and overall it was a positive experience”
H2
“Old John's luncheonette is a decent diner around there.”
H1
“Old John's Luncheonette”
H1
“Old John's is the answer.”
H1
“Old John's Diner.”
H1
“Old John’s Diner. It’s very popular and takes reservations.”
H1
“Old John’s luncheonette is always solid.”
H1
“Old John's Luncheonette - a few blocks from Lincoln Center”
H1
“i love Old John’s Luncheonette near lincoln center”
H1
“Old John’s Luncheonette”
H1
“Old John’s has always been good for me if you can get in”
H1
“Applejack Diner, The Smith, Flame Diner, Maman, Old John’s luncheonette”
H1
“Old John’s luncheonette is low key and pretty solid”
H1
“Old John's Diner. There won't be inappropriate things said by drunk people.”
H1
“Old John's Luncheonette. 66th st between Bway & Amsterdam”
H1
“or old John's”
H1
“Old John’s upper west side.”
H1
“Old John’s is the best!!”
H1
“I’d also definitely add in a diner breakfast. Three Decker, S&P, B&H, Old John’s, etc…”
H1
“Old John's on 67th (upscale diner)”
H1
“My kids loved having breakfast-for-lunch there.”
H1
“an elevated diner that hits the spot and is perfect for the non adventurous eater.”
H1
“Old John's is your best choice.”
H1
“Old Johns!!”
H1
“I've been to Old John's and liked it.”
H1
“Old John’s Luncheonette”
H1
“old john's diner”
H1
“with way better food than your average diner.”
H1
“Old John's Luncheonette in Lincoln Square has them-great food too”
H1
“Old John’s Luncheonette, Jacob’s Pickles”
H1
“Old John's (diner; better, but a bit farther away, than Viand)”
H1
“Old John's Luncheonette is a great diner with a neighborhood feel. They do all the classics well. Good drinks too.”
H1
“A few solid places we like that serve more "basic" food that your mom may like are Cafe Luxembourg (can be bustling and noisy unless you sit outside), French Roast, Old John's Luncheonette.”
H1
“Chez nick, pj Clarke, old johns luncheonette”
H1
“Me too. This is the right answer.”
H1
“Old John’s is a cut above a regular diner, but still so cute and quintessential inside!”
H1
“Old John’s Luncheonette”
H1
“I would recommend you go to Old John’s Luncheonette which is a bit north of Hell’s Kitchen but is less touristy and has better food than the better known diners in Midtown and Hell’s Kitchen.”
H1
“Old John’s diner”
H1