Mark's Off Madison

All 61 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What's the best thing you've eaten in NYC 2023?91 pts
“Cookie Platter @ Mark’s Off Madison”
H2
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?35 pts
“Food was also bland and uninspired”
H2
in:Best Appletini's in NYC?5 pts
“my friend just had a pear-tini at marks off Madison it was very good”
H2
in:Best club sandwich in NYC?4 pts
“Turkey club at Marks off Madison if phenomenal. I go once a quarter for it.”
H2
in:Best Lasagna in NYC especially if you're focused on takeout?3 pts
replying to u/augsav: I’ve heard Marks off Madison is good. I’ve never tried it though.
“Tried it with my wife, best lasagna I've ever had.”
H2
in:Lasagna - Manhattan2 pts
“Mark’s Off Madison has a great lasagna. Huge fan of their grilled calamari too”
H2
in:Can someone suggest a good spot for 3 people maybe with some outdoor for a business lunch on a friday near the 28th st or 34th st NR2 pts
“food is solid, nice outdoor area seating, open for lunch on Fridays, close to the NR on 28th street”
H2
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?2 pts
replying to u/Appropriate-Knee9169: Marks off madison. Place was empty but was sat at the worst table because we didnt make a reservation. The host at one of the most elitist attitudes ive encountered. Food was also bland and uninspired
“The food is fine, but the service is so lazy & careless.”
H2
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?2 pts
replying to u/Appropriate-Knee9169: Marks off madison. Place was empty but was sat at the worst table because we didnt make a reservation. The host at one of the most elitist attitudes ive encountered. Food was also bland and uninspired
“We liked the food, but the service definitely sucked.”
H2
in:Where to find shoestring onion fries?2 pts
“Great burger, too.”
H2
in:Jewish Food crawl2 pts
replying to u/Dry_Career_5817: Sarge's, Bubby's, Veselka (not jewish but overlap)
“because its not good? its mostly weird diner food with mediocre service”
H2
in:What's Your Favorite Dinner Spot near Madison Square Park / Flatiron1 pts
“Marks off madison for the lasagna!”
H2
in:What's the best thing you've eaten in NYC 2023?1 pts
“I want to shoutout the **Cookie Platter** at *Mark’s Off Madison.*”
H2
in:B-day chicken/veal parm1 pts
“Marks off Madison makes a good chicken parm.”
H2
in:Best lasagna in NYC1 pts
“Best I’ve had so far is Mark’s Off Madison”
H2
in:Pete Wells' 100 Best Restaurants in New York City in 20241 pts
replying to u/Party-Veterinarian60: I guess there's no way to say this without sounding like a hater, but Mark's Off Madison has zero business being on this list
“Its _fine_ but in no way special or unique in any way. And the service has gone down hill a lot, especially since the pandemic.”
H2
in:Let’s talk about French Fries1 pts
“Either the plain or truffle fries are easily the best in NY, especially when well done.”
H2
in:If you could only ever eat one pasta dish forever, in nyc, what would you choose? 1 pts
“Lasagna from Mark’s Off Madison!”
H2
in:Best lunch in NYC for ~35$ for meal + tips1 pts
“Best turkey club in the city.”
H2
in:Birthday Dinner to dress up1 pts
“delish food (try the lasagna) & dark romantic vibes”
H2
in:Lunch for foodies1 pts
“Quirky and fun, especially if you’re into Jewish deli vibes with a modern twist. The babka bread pudding is a must.”
H2
in:Best sandwich in New York1 pts
“Marks Off Madison has some amazing sandwiches. Jewish Boy From Queens is delicious turkey sandwich. They make everything in house from the bread to the chips. There is also an incredible Rueben sandwich too!”
H2
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/Appropriate-Knee9169: Marks off madison. Place was empty but was sat at the worst table because we didnt make a reservation. The host at one of the most elitist attitudes ive encountered. Food was also bland and uninspired
“I've never had bad service there, always walk in, but yeah I get annoyed with arrogant elitist attitudes from hosts at casual neighborhood restaurants.”
H2
in:Pete Wells' 100 Best Restaurants in New York City in 202416 pts
“Mark's Off Madison has zero business being on this list”
H1
in:Gramercy Park13 pts
“Marks off Madison”
H1
in:Salad , fries , glass of white wine8 pts
“Marks off Madison; Flex Mussels; Boucherie; RH; and of course the usuals like Pastis and Balthazar”
H1
in:Lunch before biopsy result 8 pts
“I’d recommend Mark’s Off Madison, very nice place, great food.”
H1
in:What other restaurants have chips/fries like Lord's?7 pts
“Mark’s off Madison”
H1
in:Great breakfast places6 pts
“Mark's Off Madison (but it's more brunch than breakfast).”
H1
in:Best lasagna in NYC/ Brooklyn?6 pts
“Mark’s Off Madison in the city.”
H1
in:Lasagna - Manhattan6 pts
“Marks off Madison is very heavy but good!”
H1
in:Best Lasagna in NYC especially if you're focused on takeout?6 pts
“Mark’s Off Madison”
H1
in:Dinner after Broadway show5 pts
“Casa Mono, Gramercy Tavern, Gogyo Ramen, Stretch Pizza, Marks Off Madison, Time Out Market Union Square, Old Town Bar, Mollys, La Dong, Danny’s, Rezdora, lots of diff options and diff types of cuisine”
H1
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?4 pts
replying to u/Appropriate-Knee9169: Marks off madison. Place was empty but was sat at the worst table because we didnt make a reservation. The host at one of the most elitist attitudes ive encountered. Food was also bland and uninspired
“Had this same experience”
H1
postGreat, chill high end plafe3 pts
“Marks off Madison is another place I love lately.”
H1
in:If you could only pick one restaurant in Manhattan to visit and one to definitely avoid, what would they be?3 pts
“avoid: marks off madison”
H1
in:Best lasagna?2 pts
“Mark’s off Madison I would check out too”
H1
in:Best lasagna in NYC/ Brooklyn?2 pts
replying to u/the-pleasures-mine: Mark’s Off Madison in the city.
“GREAT call here”
H1
in:Best Chicken Parm near midtown? 2 pts
“Mark's Off Madison”
H1
in:Best sandwich in New York2 pts
replying to u/pielady10: Marks Off Madison has some amazing sandwiches. Jewish Boy From Queens is delicious turkey sandwich. They make everything in house from the bread to the chips. There is also an incredible Rueben sandwich too!
“Marks in general is terrific.”
H1
in:Favourite restaurant in NYC?1 pts
“Marks Off Madison”
H1
in:Where can I get the BEST Reuben sandwich in NYC?1 pts
“I loved Marks off Madison though I think it’s pricier compared to the other option listed.”
H1
in:B&H vs. Russ and Daughters for sit-down latkes?1 pts
“Marks Off Madison”
H1
in:Help! Need a Manhattan lunch rec1 pts
“Mark’s off Madison”
H1
in:Team Dinner - Union Square/West Village/Chelsea/Madison Square Park1 pts
“Mark's off Madison, 26& Madison”
H1
in:Super casual lunch rec near Friends experience 1 pts
“Stretch Pizza, Marks off Madison”
H1
in:Manhattan Mid Range bring your picky family restaurants1 pts
“Marks off Madison easily for me”
H1
in:Work dinner near Herald Square recs?1 pts
“Marks off Madison”
H1
in:Best bread and butter in NYC?1 pts
“Marks off Madison!!!”
H1
in:Best Chicken Parm near midtown? 1 pts
“Marks off Madison or Campagnola”
H1