Peter McManus Cafe

All 67 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Any recs for a good hamburger in Chelsea?27 pts
“Pop Pop. I say this in every thread, best value burger in the city”
H2
in:Favorite solo dining spots to sit at the bar13 pts
“Fav bar in the city and amazing burger and vibes.”
H2
in:Best Burger in Manhattan 11 pts
“go there for a amazing dive bar experience and a great burger”
H2
in:NYC Burger List9 pts
“Peter McManus is the correct Peter imo for a classic burger”
H2
in:Any recs for a good hamburger in Chelsea?9 pts
“Peter McManus for a famous big beefy old school burger”
H2
in:I have 48 hours in NYC coming up. Staying in Chelsea. What should I eat? First time in the city.6 pts
“A burger at McManus.”
H2
in:My Burger Map Updated6 pts
“Please go to Peter McManus and get the PopPop. Please, I'm begging you. Great dive and not pretentious.”
H2
in:4th of July in New York. Where to get a good hot dog and burger?6 pts
“MCMANUS for a burger!”
H2
in:Tavern/pub recs?6 pts
replying to u/Wolf_Parade: Peter McManus
“Fantastic burger and tots”
H2
in:I tried as many burgers as I could whilst visiting New York5 pts
“McManus makes an amazing burger”
H2
in:What are your three favorite bars and restaurants?4 pts
replying to u/Szeth-n-SwordNimi: Restaurants: 1. MADRE (Greenpoint) 2. Mariscos el Submarino (Jackson Heights) 3. Win Son (Williamsburg) Bars: 1. Hotel Delmano (Williamsburg) 2. Royale (East Village) 3. Peter McManus (Chelsea)
“Love me a pint and some attitude at PMM.”
H2
in:Any recs for a good hamburger in Chelsea?4 pts
replying to u/slickmartini: Yes to McManus! 🤤
“the triple decker Reuben is the best sandwich you've never had.”
H2
in:Any recommendations for the best burger spots?4 pts
“The Peter McManus Pop Pop burger is the only way”
H2
in:Bring back big juicy burgers3 pts
“Another thread, Another time to say the McManus Pop Pop 🍔”
H2
in:Best Counter Service Classic Burger (not smashed)?3 pts
“Another list for Peter McManus pop pop burger”
H2
in:What burgers should I eat during a week off from work3 pts
“Peter McManus has an underrated burger no one talks about but it's pretty much like a slightly elevated take on the classic burger.”
H2
in:Best burger without a reservation 2 pts
“PETER MCMANUS CAFE POP POP BURGER!”
H2
in:Pubs with good grub?2 pts
replying to u/donkeydick48: Peter McManus
“Get the tots unless you love steak fries.”
H2
in:New York City’s Best Burgers (Gift Article), 19 places2 pts
“No McManus pop pop, no credibility!”
H2
in:Best burger that’s not on the top of everyone’s best burger list?2 pts
“The pop pop burger from Peter McManus Cafe. Only the best.”
H2
in:I have 48 hours in NYC coming up. Staying in Chelsea. What should I eat? First time in the city.1 pts
replying to u/xlaurenthead: Oh man. Tapas at Txikito. Fish & Chips at A Salt and Battery. A burger at McManus. Bagels at Ess-A-Bagel. A chopped cheese at Olympia Star Deli. Cocktails at Oscar Wilde. Chelsea is great for food
“McManus burger, is the best”
H2
in:Burger Ranking Map1 pts
“McManus makes an amazing hamburger.”
H2
in:Burgers - Best and Worst1 pts
“Peter McManus has a very very good burger especially for the price point”
H2
in:What’s your goto restaurant when you don’t want to plan ahead?1 pts
“The best burger in the city and the vibes rock. It is its own universe.”
H2
in:I'm part of a burger league trying 20+ burgers in NYC. These are my stats so far. Any places we should add?1 pts
“Cozy Royale Peter McManus”
H2
in:Who really has the best burger?🍔 Shake Shack, J.G. Melon, Emily, Smashy’s Personally, I’m torn between Smashy’s crisp edges and Emily.1 pts
“POP POP AT MCManus”
H2
in:Any recommendations for the best burger spots?1 pts
“Honestly it isn't the best burger but my favorite because of the atmosphere and the people. It is a delicious burger and you got to get it with tater tots.”
H2
in:Any recs for a good hamburger in Chelsea?1 pts
“it really was a delicious burger - maybe a little overcooked a bit delicious. Would go again”
H2
in:New York’s top 15 bars — according to the city’s bartenders1 pts
“Love McManus, my fav burger and always a fun crowd there. A true mix of NYC characters and very fun bartenders.”
H2
in:Where would you go as your last meal in NYC1 pts
“Pop Pop burger at McManus with tots and a Miller Lite. Go on Sunday to see Oscar.”
H2
in:Best burger that’s not on the top of everyone’s best burger list?1 pts
replying to u/relaxchilled89: Most of the $30+ burgers in NYC aren't worth the cost. You can get a great dry aged at Luger for $22. I'd say: - Donovan's - Old Town Bar - Joseph Leonard - Dram Shop - Peter McManus
“Don't sleep on the McManus Reuben.”
H2
in:What are your three favorite bars and restaurants?20 pts
“3. Peter McManus (Chelsea)”
H1
in:Best burger that’s not on the top of everyone’s best burger list?19 pts
“I'd say: - Donovan's - Old Town Bar - Joseph Leonard - Dram Shop - Peter McManus”
H1
in:Tavern/pub recs?17 pts
“Peter McManus”
H1
in:Where To Get A Great, No-Fuss Burger In NYC - The Infatuation16 pts
“Two8Two and McManus”
H1
in:Top burger spots not on the typical lists15 pts
“Peter macmanus cafe”
H1
in:Best dive bars below 14th Street in Manhattan15 pts
“Peter McManus. Technically not below 14th but mandatory for any list of Manhattan dive bars”
H1
in:One night only. Best place to grab a burger on a Sunday?8 pts
“Peter McManus or Fanellis.”
H1
in:Any recs for a good hamburger in Chelsea?6 pts
replying to u/mes051: McManus Pop Pop. I say this in every thread, best value burger in the city
“Yes to McManus! 🤤”
H1
in:Best dive bars below 14th Street in Manhattan6 pts
replying to u/gneumatic: Peter McManus. Technically not below 14th but mandatory for any list of Manhattan dive bars
“Wow it really says a lot about me that I think of McManus as a classy affair.”
H1
in:Quick dinner near 18th st. and 8th Av Manhattan6 pts
“Peter McManus at 19/7”
H1
in:Quick dinner near 18th st. and 8th Av Manhattan6 pts
“McManus yes”
H1
in:Pubs with good grub?5 pts
“Peter McManus”
H1
in:Where To Get A Great, No-Fuss Burger In NYC - The Infatuation5 pts
replying to u/bkrunnergirl25: Two8Two and McManus
“Peter McManus for real”
H1
in:Bring back big juicy burgers5 pts
“Peter McManus”
H1
in:Those who've lived in NYC for decades: what are your fav restaurants/bars that endure?4 pts
“Peter McManus Cafe”
H1
in:Restaurants near Madison Square Garden?3 pts
“Peter McManus or Crompton Ale House for solid dives and burgers.”
H1
in:Quick bite options in WV/Chelsea?3 pts
“Peter McManus and Trailer Park Lounge both have good ones that come out quickly.”
H1
in:Quick bite options in WV/Chelsea?3 pts
“Burger - 7th Street burger, Peter McManus”
H1
in:What is your most frequented restaurant?3 pts
“Every Sunday, every post same answer! The best!”
H1