“It was so bad that it was inedible. The cake tasted as if it was soaked in nail polish remover.”
H3
All 59 rated mentions, most helpful first
“It was so bad that it was inedible. The cake tasted as if it was soaked in nail polish remover.”
H3
“Billy’s (cupcakes)”
H2
“if you’re looking for a vanilla flavor bomb, Billy’s bakery is my wife’s favorite”
H2
“Sugar Sweet Sunshine and Billy's both have this type of frosting on their cakes.”
H2
“Magnolia and Billy's Bakery are overrated”
H2
“For a cupcake in Chelsea I really like Billy’s.”
H2
“Billy's Bakery makes some great cupcakes.”
H2
“Billy’s Bakery in Tribeca is my go-to birthday cake spot”
H2
“Strong agree on Billy's. All the cake I've had there has been good, but that banana slice with the light cream cheese frosting is divine.”
H2
“The one at Billy’s is really nice, but I don’t know whether it’s cheaper than milk bar (it’s still pretty pricey) - it’s tastier though!”
H2
“Billy’s bakery on 9th near high line”
H2
“Billy's Bakery, banana layer cake with cream cheese buttercream”
H2
“Billy's peanut butter pie is one of my favorite desserts in town.”
H2
“Billy’s has such a good carrot cake”
H2
“makes amazing cakes”
H2
“For classic ones I like Sugar Sweet Sunshine, Empire Cake, and Billy's!”
H2
“The banana layer cake is so good!!!”
H2
“I love their chocolate with vanilla buttercream frosting. I buy myself a slice every year.”
H2
“My favorite is the banana cake from Billy’s Bakery”
H2
“I’ve had good red velvet from Billy’s”
H2
“honestly if you're smart about ordering, billy's bakery can be not so sweet (i hate overly sweet stuff) -- their vanilla buttercream isn't too crazy.”
H2
“I like Billy’s carrot cake . Everything thing else is just too sweet”
H2
“I like Billy’s chocolate cake a lot.”
H2
“Billy's Bakery makes excellent chocolate cakes, depending on your taste for an outrageous blast of sugar.”
H2
“I’ve always loved Billy’s chocolate cake with vanilla frosting.”
H2
“I've never had a stale slice, btw.”
H2
“we ignored the recent reviews about Billy’s (which I used to love) and ended up throwing away 2/3 of my birthday cake this year…it was terrible.”
H1
“Billy's Bakery”
H1
“Billy's bakery, red gate”
H1
“Billy's bakery”
H1
“Billy’s”
H1
“Always stale”
H1
“Billy’s Bakery”
H1
“Billy’s, Amy’s.”
H1
“Billy’s Bakery”
H1
“Billy’s Bakery”
H1
“Billy’s”
H1
“We have been pleased with Billy's Bakery.”
H1
“Billy’s Bakery”
H1
“I never quite get why Billy’s is highly rated. I guess it’s because I don’t eat cup cakes, and everything else has been meh to me.”
H1
“Billy's Bakery”
H1
“Little Cupcake, Magnolia and Billy’s if you’re in Manhattan.”
H1
“I love Billy’s as well and had a wonderful cake from there for a recent birthday!”
H1
“Love Billy’s!”
H1
“Billy’s is where it’s at.”
H1
“Billy’s Bakery in Tribeca is great”
H1
“Billy’s, magnolia, Tim building- anywhere but Martha’s”
H1
H1
“Billy's in Tribeca probably your best bet.”
H1
“I like Posh pop or Billy's.”
H1