All 62 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The rest of the food that I ordered like the rum spudlets (tater tots seasoned), dumplings and the Nashville Hot Jerk Chicken Tenders which were not spicy and tasted like regular chicken tenders was just okay and kinda pricey for what it was. However, the cocktails and even a mocktail I tried were amazing in my opinion.”
H3
“Best cocktails is a tie between Paradise Lost and Double Chicken Please.”
H2
“Sunken Harbor has the best drinks with Paradise Lost right behind.”
H2
“I highly recommend the full experience, which includes the drink that has a fire show :) In general, though, it's a fun atmosphere with tasty drinks and (small) apps.”
H2
“Agreed on the food being fine but the drinks and ambiance A1. Went on a cold rainy night back in January and felt transported. Cool place and appreciate their dedication to the details”
H2
“Such a good spot! Some occasional misses on their cocktail menu but their highs are as good as Smuggler’s Cove.”
H2
“paradise lost for strong cocktails and weirdness vibe.”
H2
“It’s very much worth it imo. For me, I’d much rather pay $25 for a great Mai Tai with a great atmosphere at Paradise Lost than $15 for a mediocre Mai Tai at a mediocre bar.”
H2
“I wish the kitchen lived up to the bar at Paradise Lost but aside from the popcorn I haven't really liked anything I've had there.”
H2
“the flashier cocktails are definitely worth the admission price.”
H2
“I do love the vibe and the drinks are great so it’s worth it imo”
H2
“Paradise Lost slaps. I was put off by the high price tag, but honestly the ambience is dope, and the drinks I had were strong.”
H2
“Paradise Lost is also great tho esp if you love rum, they have a huge list to try.”
H2
“the Greenfuz is my go-to”
H2
“Paradise Lost has a terrific cocktail with pandan in it called the Beelz’s Road Soda”
H2
“Paradise Lost is really good, but expensive”
H2
“Very creative tiki drinks. Totally on point.”
H2
“Paradise Lost is a tiki bar that does a few fun large format drinks (some with fire & theatrics)”
H2
“Paradise Lost and it's not close. I love Sunken Harbor but Paradise Lost is such a blast it FELT like being on vacation.”
H1
“For drinks try Attavoy, Bar Goto, Bar Contra, Chinato, Martiny’s, Bemmelman’s, Paradise Lost, Dante, Angel’s Share, Dutch Kills, Clemente Bar, Superbueno, Mace, Dead Rabbit, Overstory, Manhatta, Please Don’t Tell, Clover Club, Sunken Harbor, Milady’s, Experimental Cocktail Club, Maison Premiere, Tigre uhhhhhh”
H1
“We also went to Paradise Lost and had a great experience there. The bartenders were so friendly, the food and drinks were great and of course the decor/vibe was super fun!”
H1
“- Paradise Lost”
H1
“Paradise Lost”
H1
“I also like Paradise Lost”
H1
“Paradise Lost is also very cool (sorry, adding some more) and the tiki is done very well if you’re looking for something different.”
H1
“Paradise Lost”
H1
“I’d add in Bar Clemente, the new one from the Eleven Madison Park team, Superbueno, and Paradise Lost.”
H1
“PDT or Paradise Lost for something different and memorable…”
H1
“Second that, and also recommend paradise lost for tiki”
H1
“you have a very clear winner for the highest concentration of major innovators in the cocktail scene on earth right there.”
H1
“Paradise Lost”
H1
“For real deal tiki go to Paradise Lost”
H1
“Paradise Lost would be fun I think”
H1
“Go to paradise lost if you like tiki. I preferred it over all the others.”
H1
“I would skip superbueno to go to Paradise Lost or Attaboy”
H1
“Manhattan- Bar kabawa, rum house, paradise lost”
H1
“Paradise lost is always a good time and great drinks”
H1
“Not food but take her to Sunken Harbor Club or Paradise Lost. These bars will transport you to far away places…”
H1
“Recently tried both and love both ! But I do like rum drinks as opposed to gin or vodka”
H1
“Some personal favs:”
H1
“check out Paradise Lost, their rum list is really awesome”
H1
“miraculously not regretting it because it was the best night out I've had in ages because everything about it was so great.”
H1
“Paradise Lost is nearby and does a great tiki thing.”
H1
“Paradise Lost”
H1
“I was surprised by how much I liked Paradise Lost, considering the *Rainforest Café* of it all. I've been back quite a few times.”
H1
“Go to Paradise Lost it’s close to you”
H1
“For bars I would do add either sunken harbor, paradise lost, or (different vibe) George bang bang. These have also been recent faves”
H1
“paradise lost is cool esp when I don't want to trek to Brooklyn”
H1
“add Bateman’s and Paradise Lost to your list.”
H1
“Paradise Lost is a great addition to the neighborhood”
H1