Carnegie Deli — all mentions

in:Food at Madison Square Garden?1 pts
“Inside MSG - Carnegie deli pastrami, Daily Burger, roast beef sandwich on the 100 concourse are all legit good.”
H3
in:NYC restaurant archives (2002 - 2008)10 pts
“I came here during their last week of service expecting to be blown away, but it was half empty and the sandwich was average.”
H2
in:Hot take: Katz is worth it and more3 pts
“I am a fan of the thinner slicing method I used to get at Carnegie Deli.”
H2
in:Which place will internally break you if they announced they were closing doors permanently?0 pts
replying to u/machphantom: Carnegie Deli already did this to me
“It was insane, absolutely huge but so good. Matzah balls were so delish too, my first time ever having them.”
H2
in:You can revive one NYC restaurant, what are you bringing back?13 pts
“Carnegie Deli.”
H1
in:Real talk, do the people who linger in this sub even like food?7 pts
replying to u/TomatoClown24: The one thing we can all agree on is that many tourist traps run on legacy instead of food quality. Katz and Halal guys are good examples of the two. $30 for a pastrami sandwich? hell no.
“My mom was team Katz and my dad was team Carnegie. Obviously mom won that matchup”
H1
in:What is your favorite restaurant that closed with no good replacement?6 pts
“Carnegie deli”
H1
in:What's a restaurant that didn't make it to the year 2000 that you miss?6 pts
replying to u/Agreeable-Lawyer6170: Louise Jr.’s, Carnegie Deli
“I also mourn the loss of Carnegie deli”
H1
postLooking to purchase authentic THICK New York Cheesecake5 pts
“Carnegie (they still do orders online/work with retail stores) do not suffice.”
H1
in:(Decently accessible) restaurants near Madison Square Garden?5 pts
“Options aren't stadium food horrible (Carnegie Deli outpost, Fuku outpost, ect)”
H1
in:Places near MSG4 pts
“MSG actually has some great food options (for arena food). Carnegie Deli, Fuku, Mighty Quinns, Veselka, etc”
H1
in:You can revive one NYC restaurant, what are you bringing back?3 pts
“Carnegie Deli”
H1
in:looking for cheesecake recommendation (nationwide delivery)3 pts
“Juniors, s&s, Carnegie deli are the classics. Thick texture.”
H1
in:You can revive one NYC restaurant, what are you bringing back?2 pts
“Carnegie Deli”
H1
in:What is an over-popular or even touristy spot that surprised you with how good it actually held up to be? 2 pts
replying to u/halermine: RIP Carnegie Deli
“The Carnegie Deli stand in Madison Square Garden is my go-to meal at hockey games.”
H1
in:The best pastrami in NYC1 pts
“My go to whenever I’m at the Garden to see the Rangers.”
H1
in:What is your favorite restaurant that closed with no good replacement?1 pts
“Carnegie Deli”
H1
in:Can yall weigh in on the list I made for restaurants to eat at during my visit in July?1 pts
“I’d add in Junior’s (Brooklyn), Carnegie Deli”
H1
in:If you could bring back one closed restaurant, what would it be?1 pts
“Carnegie deli”
H1
in:If you could bring back one closed restaurant, what would it be?1 pts
“Carnigie deli and Le Cote Basque.”
H1