“The crust was light, crispy, and airy, but the sauce was not how I like it. Tasted mostly of tomato paste and dried herbs. It was also a but sweet, which isn't my favorite, either.”
H3
All 55 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The crust was light, crispy, and airy, but the sauce was not how I like it. Tasted mostly of tomato paste and dried herbs. It was also a but sweet, which isn't my favorite, either.”
H3
“The pizza was indeed very good. The crust was crispy and the sauce was a bit acidic in a good way.”
H3
“I would skip the Unregular on 37th, feels understaffed and desolate, and thus seems like their already thick and bready slices stay out so long as to be almost stale”
H3
“Unregular Pizza is a newcomer with owners from Rome who make an outstanding Roman pizza with the scoop of Burrata twist. Maybe they've adjusted the recipe to suit my American tastes, but they are honestly better than most of the actual Roman pizzas I had in Italy.”
H2
“**1 Star:** Good pizza, grab if you walk by.”
H2
“Fried Cacio e Pepe Pasta w a side of purposely cold (I was surprised too) vodka sauce. @ Unregular Pizza.”
H2
“Unregular pizza near Union square has a Stromboli that is life changing”
H2
“Unregular Pizza is a highlight but there are lots of options”
H2
“they do have good vegan slices.”
H2
“Just go to Unregular Pizza instead. They have crispy mini pepperonis on a square slice.”
H2
“Came.to say this, better than unregular for me”
H2
“the pizzas at Unregular Pizza are great and in my opinion, quite under the radar.”
H2
“Pizza - mamas too, unregular pizza are my favorites”
H2
“Unregular Pizza. Offers a good sandwich. Longish wait”
H2
“unregular pizza has some of the best and weirdest slices in the city.”
H2
“Unregular is solid for a slice/takeout spot”
H2
“I took two bites of my pizza and threw it out it was so bad. Super salty and overall flavorless I thought”
H2
“For pizza, I like Unregular and Village Square.”
H2
“I love the variety and uniqueness of their pizzas. Fun and different!”
H2
“Hit Unregular Pizza and it was pretty good”
H2
“For slices I highly recommend Unregular Pizza, Mama's Too, Vito's and NY Pizza Suprema.”
H2
“Upside, Vito’s, Pizza Suprema (best option), Joe’s, Unregular, they’re all good”
H2
“Cacio e Pepe slice and fried pasta from unregular pizza.”
H2
“Unregular pizza is good too.”
H2
“Unregular near Union Square is pretty good … they have really great non-dairy slices”
H2
“unregular pizza has something similar. Not as greasy, Roman style pizza with interesting toppings.”
H2
“Unregular Pizza off Union Square does beautiful al taglio.”
H2
“I absolutely love the ones with the big burrata balls on them. I’ll pay for them!”
H2
“Unregular has a good vegan chicken parm hero”
H2
“* unregular pizza (more modern take)”
H1
“Unregular Pizza is also quite good.”
H1
“East Village/LES: Cello’s, village square, pop’s, east village pizza, andreas, Jonny’s, scarrs, unregular”
H1
“Peppino’s in Bay Ridge, Julianna’s, John’s of Bleecker Street, L&B, Bleecker Street, Scarr’s, Unregular and Joe’s (which is absolutely top-tier)”
H1
“go to any of the following •Village Square •Bleeker St. Pizza (line) •Slicehaus •Scarr’s •Upside •Grand Street •Cello’s •NY Pizza Suprema •Unregular •Marinara”
H1
“I recently tried Unregular, and enjoyed it a lot.”
H1
“Unregular pizza”
H1
“Unregular Pizza”
H1
“stretch, song e napule, unregular pizza, lions & tigers, aces.”
H1
“Scarrs/ ny pizza suprema/ unregular pizza”
H1
“I highly recommend you pay them a visit. I think they're very much slept on, and love their crust style.”
H1
“Unregular pizza”
H1
“My favorite slices in NYC currently”
H1
“Unregular pizza in EV”
H1
“I got it once and, like I said, it was awful.”
H1
“I like Unregular Pizza near Union Square and never had to wait more than a few minutes to get a slice.”
H1
“Unregular, emmy squared, and Williamsburg pizza are decent as well.”
H1
“NYC: Artichoke Basille’s Pizza and Unregular Pizza”
H1
“It was delicious”
H1
“Suggest adding Mamoun’s Falafel, Taim, Koronet Pizza, Don Filippo, Unregular pizza - all a few blocks’ walk on Lex but relatively inexpensive.”
H1
“I *loved* it. I’d put it on par with Bleecker Street pizza and above John’s, for my tastes.”
H1