“The sauce is so fresh and bright, the coal oven char, you don't mind the fact that you just incinerated the top of your mouth.”
H3
All 60 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The sauce is so fresh and bright, the coal oven char, you don't mind the fact that you just incinerated the top of your mouth.”
H3
“Pepe's is wildly overrated in this Nutmegger's opinion. probably my last pick of New haven style. Torch me, I ain't paying for watery, drippy, limpdick slices of scorched cracker a third time.”
H3
“Waited on a long line just to get a pizza destroyed by parmesan sprinkled on it, without asking me. That smelled bad. Could not eat more than a bite”
H3
“i have always thought the only good pepe's is the new haven original, especially for the clam pizza. my ex had family who lived near the one in west hartford and it was not good.”
H2
“Frank Pepe’s pizza in New Haven 🫠”
H2
“It’s not even close to the original. Not worth it.”
H2
“Strongly reccomend: Frank PePe (apizza)”
H2
“new haven pizza or apizza is something else.”
H2
“Hated the one in Yonkers, crazy for the clam pie in New Haven.”
H2
“Sally's, Frank Pepe's, and Modern are all considered some of the best pizza in America.”
H2
“Try Connecticut pizza. Put some respect on the name Frank Pepe”
H2
“great pizza from New Haven”
H2
“Option #2, closet to Trenton T-pie is Frank Pepe’s New Heaven style T-pie.”
H2
“Those 3 places are all incredible and worth the trip.”
H2
“Pepe’s, Sally’s, Modern. Best pizza in USA.”
H2
“Clam pie is amazing I had it recently seems like you just had bad luck”
H2
“The vegetables at Pepe’s are stellar because they’re sautéed.”
H2
“I had the clam pie with bacon the other week at the Yonkers location and have zero complaints”
H2
“Pepe’s is an all time fave of mine. That smoky coal dust on the bottom.”
H2
“Same, and in Bridgeport as well. The vibe is definitely different though.”
H2
“The spinach, mushroom, gorgonzola is the move at Pepes.”
H2
“the Pepe meatball ricotta is great . Very rich though .”
H2
“I think a top 10 NYC area pizza is Pepe's in Yonkers”
H2
“The Yonkers one is the only expansion location worth going to”
H2
“Their clam pie was terribly salty and I feel like they have gone downhill very badly since the pandemic.”
H2
“I got clam pizza there once and digestively it was an utter disaster for all of us who ate it”
H2
“Don't get the clam pie. It's salty AF no matter where you get it.”
H2
“Pepe's as the best pizza in New Haven? GTFOH”
H2
“the franchise locations for Pepe's and Sally's are trash, don't go to Yonkers or Stamford and think you're getting traditional Apizza.”
H1
“Cracker Barrel, Frank Pepe’s, Sweetgreen”
H1
“Im a Pepe's guy”
H1
“Frank Pepes in Yonkers”
H1
“I grew up going to Pepe's in New Haven and have gone recently. And the Yonkers location is excellent.”
H1
“New Haven CT is pizza capital of the world so if it’s close to your destination I would go check out Modern Apizza, Sally’s, or Frank Pepe’s in that order!!”
H1
“I like the Fairfield location a lot”
H1
“I thought the Pepe in Yonkers was pretty comparable.”
H1
“Gino’s over Frank Pepe’s is criminal.”
H1
“The one in Yonkers has never screened well. Go to the ones in CT for the real experience.”
H1
“It's quite good if that's your thing.”
H1
“Seconded! Frank Pepe Modern Sally's Hit em all!”
H1
“the satellites of Pepe’s and Sally’s in Yonkers/Stamford suck.”
H1
“In my opinion, this is where coal fire (like Frank Pepe's) really gets the edge.”
H1
“but I’d prioritize Modern then Pepe’s”
H1
“they are my all time favorite (& Sally’s)”
H1
“Modern Apizza is frankly better.”
H1
“Went to the one in New Haven. Wasn’t impressed.”
H1
“It's got nothing on Frank Pepe and Sallies in New Haven.”
H1
“if you’re getting on metro north go to New Haven and get Modern or Pepe’s”
H1
“Frank Pepe also has an excellent version.”
H1
“frank Pepe”
H1