Vito's Slices and Ices

All 84 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?6 pts
“definitely serves up some fantastic classic NY style pizza. Not too greasy, saucy with a nice crispy but still chewy crust.”
H3
post5 nights in New York - lots of tasty adventures132 pts
“pepperoni & white pizza from Vito’s Slices & Ices 9/10”
H2
postCloudy Mondays call for pizza at Vito’s Slices & Ices. 3 of my favorites - Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and classic Margherita.27 pts
“Cloudy Mondays call for pizza at Vito’s Slices & Ices. 3 of my favorites - Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and classic Margherita.”
H2
in:Help a NY Comic Con goer! Where can I get a BEC on my way to Javitz, and a good slice at dinner time?22 pts
“Perhaps a slice from Vito’s or NY Pizza Suprema near Penn Station.”
H2
in:Lunch near Hudson Yards12 pts
“vito’s for pizza!”
H2
in:Best slice pizza in midtown?8 pts
“Vito's Slices and Ices have excellent slices”
H2
in:Single Slice Near Times Square?8 pts
“Vito’s slices and ices”
H2
in:What is the single best restaurant dish you’ve had in 2024?3 pts
“Pizza slice Vito’s”
H2
in:Best square pepperoni pizza in manhattan?3 pts
“Delicious pizza and Italian ice though!”
H2
in:Looking for decent food options near the Javits Center?3 pts
“Vito's Slices and Ices for pizza, Patiala for indian. Also spicy moon in chelsea”
H2
in:Any must-go food places around Penn Station NYC?2 pts
replying to u/Cartadimusica: Pizza Suprema
“Vito’s slices and ices the pepperoni Sicilian and some of their home made ices is also a fantastic move”
H2
in:Any must-go food places around Penn Station NYC?2 pts
replying to u/phunkytime: Vito’s slices and ices the pepperoni Sicilian and some of their home made ices is also a fantastic move
“Underrated”
H2
in:Best slice pizza in midtown?2 pts
replying to u/Sensitive_Sense8823: Zillions on 42nd is great and usually they don't have lines there. Vito's Slices and Ices have excellent slices NY Pizza Suprema is great as well Not a fan of Sacco pizza If you will find yourself on the east side, My Pie Pizzeria Romana on 57th and Lex is super good roman-style pizza
“I second Vito’s slices and ices”
H2
in:Where Do People Grab Lunch in Hudson Yards?2 pts
“one of the best and underrated pizza places in NYC.”
H2
in:Low Food Budget Suggestions2 pts
“I go to Vito's pizza 2x a month I like it alot”
H2
in:Food recommendations near Penn Station?2 pts
“For pizza, I would recommend Vito’s Slices and Ices.”
H2
in:Manhattan’s Best2 pts
replying to u/Low_Association5594: I actually have been there I just totally forgot to put it on my list. I think maybe I got really lucky with my Pop’s slice because it was pre close to Vito’s for me. My online issue with Vito’s was that the pepperoni was so oily but the slice was one of the best I’ve had.
“Vito's is like how pizza used to taste in the 90s.”
H2
in:Cloudy Mondays call for pizza at Vito’s Slices & Ices. 3 of my favorites - Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and classic Margherita.2 pts
“Love Vito’s! Their grandma pie is the best and weighs 10lbs!”
H2
in:Where can I still get great knots (Slice joints, not Radio Bakery or sit-down)2 pts
“Vito’s Slices and Ices has fire knots.”
H2
in:New York Pizza Tier List: The Definitive Subjective Edition1 pts
“their cheese and dough just hits differently, and has become my favorite NYC slice.”
H2
in:Quick bite and a drink near Penn1 pts
“Vito’s Slices and Ices is a good spot for pizza on 36th and 9th.”
H2
in:What are the 3-5 must try pizza places?1 pts
“I loved Vito’s slices and ices last time I was there. No lines, no fussing, just delicious pizza. Grandma slices and garlic knots were awesome.”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
“Vito’s Slices and Ices for their Margherita!”
H2
in:New York pizza1 pts
“For slices I highly recommend Unregular Pizza, Mama's Too, Vito's and NY Pizza Suprema.”
H2
in:Another pizza question…1 pts
“2 very good slice spots are: 1) Vito’s slices and ices (36th/9th);”
H2
in:Looking for Recommendations - Mid/southtown1 pts
“Pizza - Pops, zillions, Vito’s slices and ices”
H2
in:Gino's Italian Ices1 pts
“Vitos slices and ices in the city has the classic italian ices in the paper cups!!”
H2
in:Manhattan’s Best1 pts
replying to u/jamaicanmecrazy1luv: Pops is pretty good! But like a 7.45. You should try Vito's. It's excellent and never mentioned
“the slice was one of the best I’ve had.”
H2
in:Cloudy Mondays call for pizza at Vito’s Slices & Ices. 3 of my favorites - Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and classic Margherita.1 pts
“Love Vito’s pizza”
H2
in:Cloudy Mondays call for pizza at Vito’s Slices & Ices. 3 of my favorites - Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and classic Margherita.1 pts
“Finish off with their Italian ice next time”
H2
in:Recommendations for the best NY Style Pizza in under an hour1 pts
“I find both an accurate nyc slice.”
H2
in:What is the best slice in Manhattan under $5?1 pts
“one of the best slices in the city imo”
H2
in:Bagels, pizza, must try’s1 pts
“Vito’s isn’t too far and their pizza is really good”
H2
in:Hey so I'll be traveling to the Javits center this weekend for an event, I got invited to, what is the best restaurant or fast food place close to Javits?1 pts
replying to u/fergi20020: Vito’s Slices and Ices on 9th and 36th.
“Best pizza place in midtown west”
H2
in:Every picture of food is AI generated in NYC on menus or advertisements1 pts
“Go to Vito’s Slices and Ices just up the street for a gf grandma slice!”
H2
in:Help a NY Comic Con goer! Where can I get a BEC on my way to Javitz, and a good slice at dinner time?0 pts
“for slices I would recommend Vito’s and Joe’s”
H2
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?0 pts
replying to u/TheFourthWonderAgain: Vito’s Slices and Ices not too far from Hudson Yards definitely serves up some fantastic classic NY style pizza. Not too greasy, saucy with a nice crispy but still chewy crust.
“Too salty and greasy”
H2
in:Best slice pizza in midtown?11 pts
“Vito’s on 36th and 9th ave”
H1
in:Best pizza near Columbus circle?10 pts
“Vito’s slices and ices which feels like a classic.”
H1
in:Recommendations for the best NY Style Pizza in under an hour9 pts
“Midtown: NY Pizza Suprema, Patsy’s, Joe’s, Upside, Pop’s, Angelo’s, vitos slices and ices”
H1
in:Best pizza in midtown?7 pts
replying to u/BaetrixReloaded: NY Pizza Suprema & Vito’s. i really like La Vista & Claudio’s in Hell’s kitchen as well but i have a bit of bias since those are my local spots
“VITO’S!!!”
H1
in:Hey so I'll be traveling to the Javits center this weekend for an event, I got invited to, what is the best restaurant or fast food place close to Javits?6 pts
“Vito’s Slices and Ices on 9th and 36th.”
H1
in:Pizza slice recommendation by US Intrepid?6 pts
“Vito's Slices and Ices, Zillions”
H1
in:Best pizza in midtown?5 pts
“NY Pizza Suprema & Vito’s.”
H1
in:Cloudy Mondays call for pizza at Vito’s Slices & Ices. 3 of my favorites - Grandma, Upside Down Sicilian, and classic Margherita.5 pts
“I came across this place and randomly went in and I'm so glad I did.”
H1
in:NYC Pizza Tour - NY Pizza Suprema! 🍕✨5 pts
replying to u/TheClownKid: Best true slice spot in that area of the city.
“From the nearby options only vitos comes „close“”
H1
in:Quick lunch Hudson Yards4 pts
“Shahs and Vito’s 9th ave”
H1
in:Help me dial down my list for my trip!4 pts
“Check out Vito’s Slices and Ices in Hell’s Kitchen”
H1
in:Where to eat near Penn Station right now?3 pts
“I'd take Vito's at 9th and 36th”
H1
in:Best slice pizza in midtown?3 pts
“Suprema and Vito’s”
H1