Marinara Pizza — FoodNYC

What Reddit says75

View all

postPizza tiers - Roast them, give me new spots71 pts
“**1 Star:** Good pizza, grab if you walk by.”
H2
in:Favorite vodka sauce dish13 pts
“Marinara Pizza has a great MVP slice (Marinara, Vodka, Pesto) which is my favorite casual option.”
H2
postSummer of Slices Pt. 211 pts
“5. Vodka/pesto/marinara from Marinara (East Village)”
H2
in:meatball enthusiasts, where do you recommend?7 pts
“I just had a meatball hero from Marinara last night that hit the spot.”
H2
in:Stuffed crust pizza6 pts
“I tried them recently, but found it to be mid. They had 3 stuffed crust options. I went with the vodka slice. I thought that the cheese and sauce were nice, but I didn't care for the dough.”
H2
in:What neighborhood spot has been absolutely ruined by “food critics”?5 pts
replying to u/sir_topham_biff: Hype always dies down. You can just go buy a cronut now anyway and it's no issue. Want something from Lafayette bakery, now you can go anytime. Prince St pizza was never really a neighborhood spot. But when it first came out it truly raised the bar on square pizza in the city. Now a decade later essentially they serve slop to people but still have a line. It's still decent but the amount of customers they have, they just can't keep the quality consistent. The original pizzaiolo of Prince, Frank Badali went off and created Made in New York pizza. Which itself was good when it first opened on the UWS. But now is literally worse than Prince St. You can't even get a slice that's cooked anymore. Both of these places just hire workers who don't give a shit about the product. Like so many other places. I wish for the day I can have a pepperoni square at Prince that tastes like it did in 2016 or so. Now you get something closer at Jets pizza.
“I happen to love the square slices at marinara tho.”
H2
in:Stuffed crust pizza4 pts
replying to u/pickledplumber: I haven't had it but Marinara pizza does a stuffed crust Sicilian East Village Pizza has some stuffed crust too. I saw a YouTube video on them. They also have a double Decker pizza which may be to your liking. I too like stuffed crust but frankly when I want it I just order from.the chains like pizza hut or little Cesar's.
“Came here to say Marinara sicilian with pepperoni. It's quite good.”
H2
in:NY pizza for one in Manhattan?4 pts
“Marinara Pizza also has a few locations and solid slices.”
H2
in:What are the best by the slice pizzas in New York?3 pts
“I've never had a bad or "old" tasting slice there. The MVP (marinara, vodka, pesto) pizza is one of the best gimmicky slices I've ever had.”
H2
in:Best gluten free pizza in nyc?3 pts
“Marinara on the UES does a decent one”
H2
in:My Top Grandma Slices in NYC. What am I missing out on?3 pts
replying to u/herseyhawkins33: Marinara is excellent, has a few locations in Manhattan
“Came.to say this, better than unregular for me”
H2
in:Recent eats - 6 slices and a hot dog: Paulie Gee's (EV), Cello's, Mazzola, Artistic, Koronet, Union Street, Cynthia3 pts
“very underrated, their grandma slice is amazing”
H2

See all 75 mentions