Fairway MarketCHAIN

5.4/10

AI-generated summary

It's a grocery store, and the thing people buy is the rotisserie chicken. The Latin style and the herb roasted get named as the best store bought chicken under $10. Regulars also like the chopped liver and the lox counter upstairs on the UWS. A lot of people say the store has fallen off from what it was, and the bagels get panned.

2131 Broadway, New YorkUpper West Side, Manhattan4 NYC locations mappedGoogle Maps

What Reddit says47

View all
  • Fairway semolina baguette is surprisingly good. Baked in-house, better than baguettes from more famous bakeries that have been sitting around.

    H3

  • replying to u/WinterFilmAwards: Check out johnny.novo on Instagram. He's reviewed every supermarket rotisserie chicken in NYC (and is very charming). He says Fairway's is the best. Here's his full rankings --> [https://www.johnnynovo.com/rankings/3c7feb19-b0b8-4236-af75-484a5e1130c5](https://www.johnnynovo.com/rankings/3c7feb19-b0b8-4236-af75-484a5e1130c5)

    The Latin rotisserie at Fairway is hands down the best store-bought rotisserie you can find for less than $10.

    H2

  • replying to u/Schmeep01: Fairway is tons better than Whole Foods.

    It’s an absolute shithole with staff who are upset by your presence

    H2

  • replying to u/thansal: Does fairway still have the olive bar? Obviously not a restaurant, but a good way to get a selection...

    The UES Fairway's olive bar is amazing

    H2