“Zabars sells S&S and you can get it delivered but it tasted nothing like the slices you get at Peter Lugers (they sell S&S by the slice). Do not buy it from Zabars. It was overbaked and a small 8" size.”
All 66 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Zabars sells S&S and you can get it delivered but it tasted nothing like the slices you get at Peter Lugers (they sell S&S by the slice). Do not buy it from Zabars. It was overbaked and a small 8" size.”
“S and s cheesecake is the best”
“S&S Cheesecake is the best.”
“Also S&S cheesecake!”
“S&S Cheesecake > all others.”
“Its the only cheesecake in NYC worth it!”
“While S&S is still very good. It's nowhere near as good as it used to be. When the old man owned it, everything was done on point.”
“S&S cheesecakes are fair at best.”
“You’re going to end up wanting a whole cake.”
“S&S Cheesecake or Lloyd's Carrot Cake for the Bronx.”
“this is the best cheesecake in the ny area, hands down, no question”
“s&s cheesecake. to go only though :O”
“Go to Zabars and buy an S&S cheesecake”
“The commercial S&S cakes are some of the best ones. They can't screw over their restaurant customers.”
“s&s cheesecake. To-go only though, and by the pie. Still worth it.”
“S&s but you have to buy the large. The small doesn't have the same crust.”
“If your at Peter Luger’s get a slice of S&S cheesecake.”
“100%. the chocolate mousse cheesecake is worth the trip!”
“For NY style, S&S is the crown jewel”
“for me, it's the best pure rich NY cheesecake in the game.”
“The ones not on your list that might suit your tastes: S&S (supplies Peter Luger), Ernesto's (Basque perfection), Kuih Cafe (pandan Basque) and Keki Modern Cakes (original and ube).”
“it is the best cheesecake no hyperbole”
“S&S - pick one up at Zabars”
“S&S Cheesecake.”
“Yes. Authentic New York Cheesecake.”
“S&S, which is the most authentic New York style in my opinion”
“S&S.”
“S&S in The Bronx”
“S & S (at Peter Lugers), mah ze dar, veniros (ricotta), caputos”
“S&S is the best”
“S & S Cheesecake in The Bronx”
“S&S but it's in The Bronx.”
“It is the best in the city though.”
“I really like S&S”
“I like [S&S Cheesecake](https://www.sscheesecake.com) much more, but Junior's is a pretty reliable staple (and more convenient to get for many folks).”
“S & S Cheesecake”
“I haven’t found anything close to being this good and I tried most of the other ones mentioned in this thread.”
“S&S tops both”
“I find it very lacking in flavor.”
“S&S In the Bronx.”
“S&S”
“S&s in the bronx.”
“they sell S&S, will spare you the trip”
“the only one better is in the middle of nowhere in the Bronx i.e. S&S”
“Yes!”
“This is my persona favorite.”
“Juniors, s&s, Carnegie deli are the classics. Thick texture.”
“Need some S&S.”
“S&S in the Bronx is the best in the city.”
“It’s more subtle than Eileen’s or S&S, to which I’m also partial, and both crust options are exceptional.”