Elio's

6.7/10Italian

AI-generated summary

Old school Upper East Side Italian that people either love or call overrated. Fans go for the , the , and the off menu , and say the bar is the fun place to sit. Critics say it's crowded, underseasoned, and that quality slipped after the owner died.

1621 2nd Ave, New YorkUpper East Side, ManhattanGoogle Maps

What Reddit says76

View all

in:What’s the last spot you ate at that totally blew you away?15 pts
“We had the Valentine Ravioli, might be one of the best things I have even eaten. Haven’t stopped thinking about it since Saturday night.”
H2
in:Favorite vodka sauce dish13 pts
“Elio's: Vodka pasta (off the menu)”
H2
in:Best Chicken Parm near midtown? 13 pts
“Other chicken parm's of note; Emilio Ballato Elio's”
H2
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?5 pts
“Great chicken parm”
H2
in:What is a Good Italian Place in the Upper East Side3 pts
“Sandros, L'incontro, Bella Blu, Adria (more seafood forward but SO UNDERRATED), Elios.”
H2
in:Best restaurant for a solo celebratory meal?2 pts
“Elio's at the bar!!! Such a fun vibe and great for a celebration :)”
H2
in:What is a Good Italian Place in the Upper East Side2 pts
“L'incontro, Campagnola, Elio's for more authentic experiences.”
H2
in:Best Italian food in NYC?1 pts
“I love Elios on the upper east side. Classic New York Italian place. Their fish is amazing!”
H2
in:Best red sauce joint for solo people watching & stuffing my face in the corner1 pts
“Elio’s UES is a bit more expensive but worth it IMHO.”
H2
in:Rustic Italian Restaurant Recommendations1 pts
replying to u/MrYoshinobu: Elios on 83rd and 2nd.
“Elios too insta lately and quality has nosedived since the owner passed away…….”
H2
in:Best eggplant dishes?1 pts
“Eggplant parm from Elio’s on the UES.”
H2
in:Looking for a great Italian spot in NYC that’s not IMPOSSIBLE to get into1 pts
“Elios & Sandro’s UES - VIBEY amazing specials great service and wine lists”
H2

See all 76 mentions