“Thirding Brooklyn Farmacy. Highly recommend a malted Black & White milkshake... They line the glass with the thickest most ridiculous homemade hot fudge”
H3
All 96 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Thirding Brooklyn Farmacy. Highly recommend a malted Black & White milkshake... They line the glass with the thickest most ridiculous homemade hot fudge”
H3
“Huge fan of the Brooklyn Farmacy milkshakes, the classic chocolate one is amazing.”
H2
“Farmacy in Cobble Hill is worth a look”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy Affugazi Affogato! It’s an affogato Sunday which is closer I think to what you have posted here”
H2
“I get their black and white milkshake with malt added - it’s incredible.”
H2
“Classic black and white at Brooklyn Farmacy”
H2
“It was super tasty and it’s a restored vintage pharmacy so it’s got a nice vibe as well!”
H2
“Egg creams are great here. The frozen hot cocoa is also amazing.”
H2
“go to Farmacy for awesome sundaes (that beat out Serendipity for quality by a mile).”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain (Carroll Gardens) have a good maple walnut.”
H2
“damn I’m addicted to their frozen hot chocolate.”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy has a great one”
H2
“And their black and white!”
H2
“The classic black and white milkshake 😋”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy for sweet treats in Cobble Hill.”
H2
“I went to Brooklyn Farmacy to get their Black & White milkshake and it tasted phenomenal!”
H2
“* Sundae @ Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain”
H2
“Second! Their root beer float is bomb”
H2
“Agreed! Their cherry blossom is great too”
H2
“Farmacy in Brooklyn is great. Try the S'Mores Hot Chocolate.”
H2
“Brooklyn farmacy has old school flare and vibe. Just know they dont make their own ice cream and it’s a smidge underwhelming. The place itself tho, very cool.”
H2
“Love their affogato sundae”
H2
“I’ve honestly never been a fan of the ice cream there”
H2
“Farmacy in Brooklyn. Try adding their toasted marshmallow topping.”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda family is the best dessert. Especially the warm brownie with their homemade banana chocolate chip ice cream. To die for.”
H2
“the milkshake was lacking for being 10$.”
H2
“They add some homemade toasted marshmallow on top that’s also amazing”
H2
“Great spot - love their classic black & white milkshake”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy has a good ice cream sandwich.”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy in Carroll Gardens has great egg creams.”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy does old timey sodas that’s probably the closest you’ll get.”
H2
“wildly fun sundaes with many toppings and great hot chocolate!”
H2
“the Black & White shake it was very very good. Very simple and exactly what I’m looking for.”
H2
“The ice cream is fine but when you dress it in all the sundae toppings it doesn't really matter.”
H2
“Brooklyn Farmacy is amazing but not really an ice cream shop. More so a sundae shop.”
H2
“5/5 this was so good and the marshmallow was unbelievable”
H1
“it wasn’t as good as I remembered but was still good.”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain in Cobble Hill, Brooklyn.”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain”
H1
“If you want schtick and nostalgia Eddies Sweet Shop and Brooklyn Farmacy are kitschy and fun.”
H1
“Farmacy in Carroll Gardens.”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain”
H1
“For authentic soda shop feel I prefer Eddie’s Sweet Shop in Forest Hills to Brooklyn Farmacy”
H1
“Davey's, Ralph's, Uncle Louie G's, Ray's Candy, Marvel Frozen Dairy, Brooklyn Farmacy, Eddie's, The Social (some fancy flavors but they also have simple flavors), good ol' Carvel”
H1
“Suggestions in Brooklyn: Gage+Tollner, Farmacy (serves food too).”
H1
“Farmacy in Brooklyn”
H1
“Brooklyn Farmacy”
H1