Super Nice

All 88 rated mentions, most helpful first

postFollow up to my last post: Super Nice Pizza was great!27 pts
“Dough on the pizza was good and airy. Ingredients were great. I’d probably try a different white pie next time, but the sausage was fantastic.”
H3
in:Best donut shops in Manhattan?2 pts
replying to u/lootandpollute: Super Nice, they have a location in Chelsea
“Super nice really excels at fruity or acidic donuts. Their regular glazed and chocolate donuts are downright not good in my opinion, but their passionfruit, loganberry, and strawberry donuts are exceptional.”
H3
in:Best glazed donut?0 pts
replying to u/jabrundage: Super Nice
“i went once and the donuts were dripping in grease. the bag ripped from the oiliness.”
H3
postMy personal NYC food round-up (real life and kid-friendly focused) 55 pts
“The Blood Orange Donut was so light, tangy, bright and completely delicious.”
H2
in:One thing I love about NYC is its donuts14 pts
“I try to go to Super Nice for them every couple weeks, from Loganberry to the mango to the basic sprinkles with strawberry they always hit!”
H2
in:Favorite donut shops in NYC?12 pts
“Super Nice if you like a simple yeast donut done well”
H2
in:Thinking about doing breakfast at Tiffany’s at the Tiffany cafe for my birthday, is it worth it?12 pts
“Thai diner, Croft alley, super nice pizza, crispy heaven for great food”
H2
in:What’s an absolute gem of a place you don’t hear talked about very much in the city? 8 pts
“Super Nice on 117 (also on the list of best donuts in the city)”
H2
in:Best glazed donut?8 pts
replying to u/jabrundage: Super Nice
“Honestly I’m a huge fan of Super Nice cake donuts and their glazes are a cut above the rest”
H2
in:Pure ambience: the most beautiful coffee shops?7 pts
replying to u/Cptn_Jib: Their upscale bakery/coffee combo is kindof unmatched. Because usually if the coffee is that good the baked goods fall off or vice versa.
“I feel like Super Nice uptown is another that nails both though (the donuts are on another planet).”
H2
in:Staying at NYC around Chelsea. Any lunch recommendations to eat around Penn Station. 7 pts
“An incredible donut from super nice is a nice for a treat.”
H2
in:Donuts in Manhattan/Brooklyn7 pts
“Super nice has my vote, always consistent and the coffee taste wonderful which is a big plus”
H2
in:Just moved to East Harlem, any favorites or gems?6 pts
“Super Nice also has good cookies”
H2
in:Best donut shops in Manhattan?6 pts
replying to u/Old_Presentation_107: This seems like one of the best options in Manhattan from the store’s website. I’ll have to check it out, thanks!!!
“I second super nice acidic doughnuts. Their cake donuts are also really good but they only offer them on weekends.”
H2
in:One thing I love about NYC is its donuts5 pts
replying to u/qj66: I try to go to Super Nice for them every couple weeks, from Loganberry to the mango to the basic sprinkles with strawberry they always hit!
“Came here to say Super Nice has super nice doughnuts. The cornmeal doughnuts they have in the fall are sublime.”
H2
in:What are your favorite midrange donuts?5 pts
“I love them, especially the fruity/citrussy glazes. I had a sugar/lime this morning that was straight fire”
H2
in:Wait times at Golden Diner5 pts
“super nice pizzas brunch has an amazing and fairly similar dish”
H2
in:Help me find a clam pizza slice5 pts
“Super nice pizza , UWS!!!!!! I’m a clam pizza person and it’s fab.”
H2
in:Another pancake question (I know, don't hate me)4 pts
“Hellbender, chez ma tante, comal, super nice pizzas brunch”
H2
in:Any Pancake Recommendations on UWS, UES or Midtown? 🥞4 pts
“Super Nice Pizza has stellar pancakes (a lot like the Golden Diner ones) during weekend brunch.”
H2
in:Lack of Doughnut Shops in Upper Manhattan?3 pts
replying to u/BankshotMcG: Super Nice is all you need, though.
“Super Nice has some of the best donuts ever.”
H2
in:What are your favorite midrange donuts?3 pts
replying to u/urbanstoop88: Why oh why does Super Nice never get any love on these posts? Is it just the somewhat uncool UES/UWS location? I will admit that I would consider myself a donut novice, but I love them, especially the fruity/citrussy glazes. I had a sugar/lime this morning that was straight fire
“Their mango chili or whatever rules”
H2
in:Donuts in Manhattan/Brooklyn3 pts
replying to u/GabrielEspi: Super nice has my vote, always consistent and the coffee taste wonderful which is a big plus
“Agreed, super nice is the best in my opinion. The cake donuts in particular are ridiculously good.”
H2
in:What are your top single donuts (not locations) that you’ve tasted in the city?3 pts
“Logan berry - from Super Nice! Rip donut project”
H2
in:Donuts not at a donut shop?3 pts
replying to u/Garconavecunreve: Supermoon bakehouse Yellow rose Super nice coffee and bakery
“Super nice’s mango and tajin donut is incredible”
H2
in:Favorite donut shops in NYC?2 pts
replying to u/lgetsstuffdone: Super Nice if you like a simple yeast donut done well
“That donut is so good”
H2
in:Donuts in Manhattan/Brooklyn2 pts
replying to u/GabrielEspi: Super nice has my vote, always consistent and the coffee taste wonderful which is a big plus
“Another vote for Supernice. My favorite! Great people, great donuts.”
H2
in:Favorite Sweets Recommendations 2 pts
“Donuts from Super Nice”
H2
in:NYC weekend eats part ✌🏻2 pts
“Chocolate cake at Super Nice Pizza in the UWS is excellent (and the slice about the size of your head)”
H2
in:Best food places around 108th street2 pts
replying to u/TrynaCatchTheBeat: The bar Nobody Told Me on 107/108 and Amsterdam does a great burger. Donuts from Super nice coffee and bakery are next level Banh for Vietnamese food Nan Xiang soup dumplings
“The pizza at Super Nice is very good, and the chocolate cake (a slice about the size of your head) is next level delicious”
H2
in:Best food places around 108th street2 pts
“Super Nice for Donuts/Pastry.”
H2
in:Donuts or Doughnuts? Tour2 pts
replying to u/ElMatadorJuarez: Thank you for this post hot damn. I’ve been looking for decent donuts in the city. Fww I occasionally go to super nice coffee & bakery uptown and those are some pretty good donuts, but I lack a decent frame of reference
“Donuts are great and their other baked goods are excellent as well.”
H2
in:Recommendations for pizza places that use non-brominated flour2 pts
“It's great pizza that I'd eat regardless of this latest food ingredient panic.”
H2
in:Let’s say I’m a visitor staying at a hotel in Chelsea, on 24th st between 6th and 7th, and I wanted to find a good NYC BEC on Monday morning somewhere within walking distance, where might I walk to? 1 pts
replying to u/SleepingAntz: Brooklyn bagel at 24 and 8. Best bagels in manhattan IMO.
“OP grab coffee from Super Nice on the way over.”
H2
in:Best donut shops in Manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/lootandpollute: Super Nice, they have a location in Chelsea
“Super nice east Harlem has the BEST donuts! Mango chili, loganberry, passion fruit, blood orange are all amazing, and in the fall they have a great pumpkin cake donut.”
H2
in:Donuts in Manhattan/Brooklyn1 pts
“cake donuts at Super Nice on 117th (only available on weekends).”
H2
in:What are your top single donuts (not locations) that you’ve tasted in the city?1 pts
“Super nice's cinnamon sugar is delicious”
H2
in:What are your top single donuts (not locations) that you’ve tasted in the city?1 pts
“The blood orange donut at Super Nice in East Harlem is the best I've had by far.”
H2
in:Donuts not at a donut shop?1 pts
“Seconding super nice. It’s the best donut I’ve had in a long long time.”
H2
in:Has anyone been to Super Nice Pizza?1 pts
“It was okay, but a little expensive for what you’re getting.”
H2
in:Best chocolate cake slice you’ve had in NYC or surrounding areas1 pts
“Super Nice Pizza has a great and huge chocolate cake slice.”
H2
in:Best chocolate cake slice you’ve had in NYC or surrounding areas1 pts
replying to u/GoodEatsNYC: I’ll throw in an unknown rec, pretty high up on the UWS, but Super Nice Pizza has a great and huge chocolate cake slice.
“i just had Super Nice's chocolate decadence at a bridal shower today and i must say, it was so outrageous. 10 layers at least of ganache, chocolate cake and more.”
H2
in:I am having a huge craving for fried calamari. What are some standout places to get it, like either personal favorites, cheap but somehow still good quality, more-massive-than-average portion sizes, or ones that are served different than with the typical tomato sauce or aioli?1 pts
“Shockingly, the fried calamari at super nice pizza was maybe the best I’ve ever had. Was not expecting that.”
H2
in:Recommendations for Potato Pizza 🥔 🍕1 pts
“Super Nice Pizza has an incredible potato pizza”
H2
in:Best food places around 108th street1 pts
replying to u/pigeonmachine: The pizza at Super Nice is very good, and the chocolate cake (a slice about the size of your head) is next level delicious
“i love super nice pizza! great food great vibes”
H2
in:Best food places around 108th street1 pts
“Yeasted doughnuts are amazing”
H2
in:Restaurant recommendation around Harlem/UWS1 pts
“Super Nice Pizza! Kind of cocktail lounge meets wine bar meets ridiculous pizza.”
H2
in:Help me find a clam pizza slice1 pts
replying to u/bgj87: Super nice pizza , UWS!!!!!! I’m a clam pizza person and it’s fab. Also the chocolate cake …
“Yes this was quite nice, very fresh tasting”
H2
in:Help me find a clam pizza slice1 pts
replying to u/bgj87: Super nice pizza , UWS!!!!!! I’m a clam pizza person and it’s fab. Also the chocolate cake …
“+1 for the clam pie at super nice. outstanding.”
H2
in:Help me find a clam pizza slice1 pts
“Had good clam pies (not slices) at Super Nice and Motorino”
H2