“Most of the time I'm happy, but every now and again you get an order with significantly smaller sized wings.”
H3
All 95 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Most of the time I'm happy, but every now and again you get an order with significantly smaller sized wings.”
H3
“lemon pepper wings at Dan and John’s (their best flavor IMO)”
H2
“Please disregard anyone that said Dan & John's. Those are awful”
H2
“dan and johns was a major MEH for me and really expensive.”
H2
“Dan and John’s: wings and fries and mozzarella sticks”
H2
“They’re a damn good wing.”
H2
“Dan and John’s! It’s a little pricey but very good. Lemon pepper and buffalo medium or hot are my faves.”
H2
“It’s a better wing spot than a sports bar”
H2
“Usually it’s great, exactly what I’m looking for. Fantastic wings and tots.”
H2
“Decent, but overhyped and overpriced”
H2
“They haven’t been good since they reopened imo”
H2
“Dan and John's is dogshit Terrible fast food wings”
H2
“Wildly overrated imo”
H2
“The last two times I ate there the food was terrible. First time, the wings were burnt. Second, they either used the wrong sauce or something was very off.”
H2
“It’s wild to me how disappointing Dan and John’s wings are.”
H2
“Dan and John’s is the best I’ve found as a Buffalo native.”
H2
“I personally still prefer dan and johns and scruffy duffy which also have perfectly cooked wings and their hot wings notably more heat.”
H2
“I know the quality can be inconsistent at Dan & Johns, but I like them. The Murray Hill location has always been fine in my experience.”
H2
“Dan & John’s are as close as you will get to true Buffalo, NY wings. I was born and raised there.”
H2
“I really feel their quality has dropped over the past years. Soggy and small wings, plus the blue cheese is now pre-packaged.”
H2
“Dan and John’s wings”
H2
“Dan and John’s on 14th are the closest thing to real traditional Buffalo NY wings I’ve had so far in the city.”
H2
“Dan and John’s (solid classic buffalo wings).”
H2
“Inferno Wing Challenge at Dan and Johns Wings!!!!!!”
H2
“I'm not a huge fan of just nuking chicken in a deep fryer and covering it in the same mediocre sauce”
H2
“100% D&J, the absolute best wings in the city.”
H2
“Dan & John’s all the way.”
H1
“Dan and John’s east village location”
H1
“Dan and Johns is pretty good.”
H1
“I haven't been anywhere in NYC that holds a candle to the original Buffalo wings (looking at you Dan & John's).”
H1
“it's not anything near Dan & John's.”
H1
“Can’t believe no one has said Dan & John’s! By far my favorite 🔥”
H1
“Dan & John’s”
H1
“Dan and John’s, all the way”
H1
“Dan and John's (Market Line at least) I found were aggressively mediocre. Just a data point.”
H1
“I personally like Dan and John's on 14th by 6th.”
H1
“I lived a couple blocks from the original until last year and it was always my go to.”
H1
“Dan and John’s they have a location in Murray Hill and Chelsea”
H1
“Dan & John's is pretty good”
H1
“Those are my neighborhood go tos when I don't go to Manhattan for Dan and Johns.. or to Buffalo (they're just tastier there)”
H1
“Dan & John's is top tier”
H1
“also gonna add Blondies on the UWS and Dan and Johns.”
H1
“Molly’s or Dan and John’s”
H1
“Dan and John’s is good too and convenient.”
H1
“For the city the best I’ve had are Dan And John’s, Wingbar in Carrol Gardens, and Bonnie’s Grill in Park Slope.”
H1
“I had Dan and John’s from the dekalb market delivered last night and it and really some of the worst food I’ve had in a long time.”
H1
“Usually it’s pretty solid! But the one at Dekalb Market probably is the worst one”
H1
“Dan and John's is my default”
H1
“They have dropped off significantly—feels like the whole recipe changed.”
H1
“Brooklyn DeKalb location still slangin fire”
H1