Pete's Tavern

All 66 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Restaurant recommendations for American food in Manhattan48 pts
“Pete’s Tavern in Gramercy. Since 1864. Where O’Henry wrote Gift of the Magi.”
H2
in:Drinks near Union Square with outdoor seating?4 pts
“Pete’s tavern for beer”
H2
in:Restaurant recommendations for American food in Manhattan3 pts
replying to u/bandlizard: P. J. Clarke’s js what you’re looking for. Since 1884 in NYC. Pete’s Tavern in Gramercy. Since 1864. Where O’Henry wrote Gift of the Magi. Keen’s steakhouse, but sit at the bar. It’s an American classic.
“Pete’s is a great vibe, but the food is pretty bad.”
H2
in:Delivery in Manhattan with a daily $40 lunch budget?3 pts
“The burger at Petes Tavern.”
H2
in:Good places like In-N-Out in NYC?2 pts
“U want a good burger??? Go to petes tavern or corner bistro”
H2
in:Trying to make good dinner choices...can you check my homework?2 pts
“Pete’s Tavern is my go-to for holiday drinks, it’s pretty and it’s one of the oldest bars in NY, and it’s close to all the others.”
H2
in:4 more days left it NYC where should I eat 2 pts
“Pete’s tavern historical cool bar for $6 drafts m-f 4-6 happy hr”
H2
in:christmas restaurants!2 pts
“Pete’s tavern decorates a lot and while it’s just bar food, it’s definitely much much better than Rolf’s”
H2
in:Dinners in NYC next week2 pts
replying to u/wdrub: Great vibe there especially this time of year. Sip and guzzle, bar pisellino, employees only, Dante. But to be honest revisiting bobo that you enjoy and pairing it with Palma is a great idea. Have fun!
“Pete’s is cute and festive but could replace with a different less Christmas specific vibe.”
H2
in:Best mac and cheese in NYC? 1 pts
“Pete’s tavern in gramercy has a killer truffle Mac and cheese.”
H2
in:Help me make my family’s first trip to NY spectacular with food!1 pts
“Petes Tavern for burgers”
H2
in:Restaurants like 4 Charles?1 pts
“Petes Tavern has amazing burgers.”
H2
in:Best pre-dinner drinks best Flatiron1 pts
“Pete’s Tavern which is good for both beers and cocktails”
H2
in:Where's a forlorn gal taking herself out to dinner + a drink1 pts
“Pete’s Tavern is an old school good time and vibe!”
H2
in:Feedback: 4 solo dinners in NYC0 pts
“Petes Tavern for burger and onion rings”
H2
in:Thick burger, 6-10 oz. Tender, soft, juicy and doesn't taste like rough ground beef but a soft patty. No sauce, just simple cheese and meat. Are there any in lower Manhattan or downtown Brooklyn/Dumbo/Williamsburg? Thanks.-1 pts
“Pete’s Tavern has one of the best burgers I’ve had in my life!”
H2
in:Worst place to eat in NYC?-2 pts
“steak is good everything else well bar food lol”
H2
in:Best holiday decorated bars in Manhattan21 pts
“Pete’s tavern is usually pretty nice without being too overly Christmasy.”
H1
in:What are the best restaurants in NYC that are not fine dining or super expensive?9 pts
“Petes Tavern”
H1
in:What are your favorite “local” bars?8 pts
“Old Town Bar Pete’s Tavern Dive 75”
H1
in:Looking for xmas themed speakeasy or bar that isn’t super loud and filled with 20 year olds6 pts
“Pete’s tavern?”
H1
in:Christmas bars6 pts
“Pete's Tavern on 18th and Irving Pl”
H1
in:Best holiday decorated bars in Manhattan5 pts
“Pete’s Tavern fo’ shiz, fo’ shiz 🙌🏽”
H1
in:Favorite restaurants during the holidays?5 pts
“Lillie's Victorian and Pete's Tavern are great but are bars/pubs”
H1
in:72hr Visit, Manhattan, need help.5 pts
“Pete’s Tavern”
H1
in:Sunday Night Dinner Solo Diner Bar Seating Preferred5 pts
“Corner bistro, jg mellons, Pete's tavern, Whitehorse are all good choices.”
H1
in:Recommendations for: large bar in lower Manhattan with quality food4 pts
“Pete's Tavern”
H1
in:What are places in NYC that match this winter cozy vibe?3 pts
“For dinner, maybe one of the booths at Pete's Tavern”
H1
in:Some help with planning a NYE weekend visit2 pts
“Pete’s is also better for just a drink, is your reservation for the back dining room?”
H1
in:Best chicken pot pie in the city?2 pts
“Pete's Tavern”
H1
in:Family-style places for a rehearsal dinner in Manhattan2 pts
“Pete’s Tavern is pretty good for this”
H1
in:Top 5 NYC old school burgers 2 pts
“Pete’s Tavern”
H1
in:I'm part of a burger league trying 20+ burgers in NYC. These are my stats so far. Any places we should add?2 pts
“and Pete’s Tavern.”
H1
in:EV bars open tonight/xmas eve?2 pts
“Pete’s Tavern always good this week”
H1
in:Great late lunch near Gramercy / Flat Iron2 pts
“Pete's Tavern”
H1
in:Hi everyone! My grandparents (82 & 85) are visiting NYC for the first time this June and I really want to give them a nostalgic, classic New York experience. They love all kinds of food and are still very adventurous eaters.2 pts
“Also Pete's Tavern.”
H1
in:Most Iconic/essential NYC bars (NOT BEST OR MOST POPULAR)2 pts
“+1 to McSorley's and Pete’s Tavern”
H1
in:Private dining recs for rehearsal dinner?1 pts
“I had my 30th at Pete’s in Gramercy - great private room upstairs. I’d recommend”
H1
in:Good places like In-N-Out in NYC?1 pts
“Fanellis, corner bistro, petes tavern, black iron burger”
H1
in:Best holiday decorated bars in Manhattan1 pts
replying to u/ThePathOfTheRighteou: Pete’s tavern is usually pretty nice without being too overly Christmasy.
“just don't eat the food haha.”
H1
in:Best holiday decorated bars in Manhattan1 pts
replying to u/ThePathOfTheRighteou: Pete’s tavern is usually pretty nice without being too overly Christmasy.
“This would be my choice!”
H1
in:Best burger in the city1 pts
“Petes Tavern!!!!”
H1
in:Good Christmas-Themed Restaurants - NYC?1 pts
“Pete’s tavern!”
H1
in:First Time New York1 pts
“Balthazar, petes tavern, lords, rubirosa, John's of Bleecker”
H1
in:Best burger spot1 pts
“Petes Tavern!!!!!”
H1
in:Best holiday cocktails (ideally lower Manhattan)1 pts
“Pete’s Tavern”
H1
in:cheap but romantic dinner?1 pts
“Petes Tavern”
H1
in:Favorite Historic Food Spots in NYC?1 pts
“Forgot to mention my favorites.”
H1
in:Staying in NoMad / Flatiron1 pts
“Food is average.”
H1
in:Like Minetta Tavern, Balthazar, Gramercy Tavern....1 pts
“Petes Tavern”
H1