“MiMi's on 86th, vodka g ma and a pep g ma my never disappoints.”
H2
All 96 rated mentions, most helpful first
“MiMi's on 86th, vodka g ma and a pep g ma my never disappoints.”
H2
“Underrated: Mimi’s pep square on UES”
H2
“Much better than Prince’s or Emmy Squared IMO”
H2
“Enjoyable pizza experience, nothing life-changing. Good for a quick bite, not a destination pie. 3.5/5”
H2
“Mimi's is fire, I go for the vodka square but im a slut for vodka sauce.”
H2
“Mimi’s Pizza (3rd and 86th) has a solid Sicilian slice.”
H2
“their normal slices are top tier”
H2
“Was looking for Mimi's...their vodka square is god”
H2
“There's slice joints immediately near me that are excessively greasy, stale, bland, so I go to Mimi's Pizza even though it's a little further out from me because it's more to my taste.”
H2
“For square slice Mimi’s on 86th, they also have regular slices but they’re known for the squares.”
H2
“Mimi's is a really good slice shop.”
H2
“That’s a great slice and my favorite when I lived on the UES.”
H2
“I know all the cool kids never go north of 14th street but this is a 3-star square pep slice that consistently eludes the attention of all these pizza experts and lists”
H2
“Fuckin LOVE Mimi’s! Epitome of a NYC slice that the locals eat on the regular”
H2
“The only place that has a legit NY pie / slices, and a family from Brooklyn (Mimi’s Pizza).”
H2
“Much better than Mimi's in my experience.”
H2
“Sal & carmine’s, Freddie & pepper’s, Mimi’s, cheesy pizza.”
H2
“I tried a lot of their slices, favorite was the pepperoni Sicilian, denso pizza.”
H2
“Mimi’s was my favorite pizzeria when I lived in Yorkville. They make a mean slice.”
H2
“Mimi's is great! I tried their plain slice a while back and I'm ready to put them up there with Joe's / OG Patsy's / NY Pizza Suprema”
H2
“the vodka g-mah is Gahd!”
H2
“Mimi's pizza,Lucia pizza but it's fast casual . Nick's pizza”
H2
“Recently had it for the first time; my wife and I have been KICKING ourselves for not trying it sooner. Grandpa Pepperoni and Vodka sauce pie are the favorites so far”
H2
“Mimi’s is solid pizza. It’s better in person than delivery.”
H2
“Mimi’s pizza chicken bacon ranch”
H2
“Mimi's on East 86th. My wife is very particular and orders the Eggant Parm from its other location on the UWS.”
H2
“Mimis pizza on the upper east side has a really great slice as well”
H2
“Mimi’s was the best slice I’ve had in a while. Highly recommend!”
H2
“Mimi's pepperoni square was amazing, the best slice I had.”
H2
“Mimi’s slaps if you gotta have a grandma slice. The pep and the vodka are my favorites.”
H2
“Mimi’s is solid pizza. It’s better in person than delivery.”
H2
“I've only had grandmas, which have gotten the job done, though the last time it was burnt.”
H2
“I live UES and could not agree more. The cup and char square roni slice is the real deal and deserves more attention.”
H2
“The denso pepperoni is top tier”
H2
“Mimi’s (UES) or Paulie Gee’s (Greenpoint) for pizza”
H2
“mimi is the best of the UES pizza.”
H2
“Mimi’s is one of the best pizza on the UES.”
H2
“Mimi’s (UES, UWS) pizza has good versions of these (grandma slices).”
H2
“I echo Mimi's. Way better than Emmys squared for the grandma pepperoni slice (or any grandma slice for that matter)”
H2
“Mimi's on 86th is good.”
H1
“Mimi’s upper east side is perfection”
H1
“Mimi’s Pizza”
H1
“Joe's, the OG Patsy's up in East Harlem, NY Pizza Suprema by Penn Station, Mimi's on the UES are all fine examples.”
H1
“If Mimi's pizza is still open, that's probably the closest food I'd recommend to the Met.”
H1
“Mimi’s ues goated”
H1
“Delish”
H1
“Mimi’s has been way better / more consistent, although I’ve only had square pies from them.”
H1
“Mimi's is an awesome exception”
H1
“For me that's Mimi's, Sal and Carmines, La Vera, Marinara.”
H1
“My go to’s: Pizza: Mimi’s”
H1