“they are better than other spots like Made in New York, where I saw a guy literally blow his nose and then try to serve me pizza.”
H3
All 103 rated mentions, most helpful first
“they are better than other spots like Made in New York, where I saw a guy literally blow his nose and then try to serve me pizza.”
H3
“But now is literally worse than Prince St. You can't even get a slice that's cooked anymore.”
H2
“**1 Star:** Good pizza, grab if you walk by. * Made in New York”
H2
“Made in New York Pizza for a really decent "everyday" slice.”
H2
“Shit rules. I’ve officially sworn off the pizza of my motherland and pledge fealty to NY pies, the last bastion for crunch and reasonable amounts of crust.”
H2
“Best pizza is Made in NY pizza at 73nd and Amsterdam”
H2
“Ordered a grandma pie and the sauce was sweet, like someone dropped the bag of sugar in it.”
H2
“Made in NY makes a great eggplant slice”
H2
“Made in New York is the most underrated pizza. One of my favorites.”
H2
“Made in New York is an underrated slice place.”
H2
“Made in NY - best utility slice”
H2
“Made in NY does great slices as well”
H2
“It's the classic perfect slice that places like Joe's used to have back in the day. Like a time capsule.”
H2
“Believe it or not, Made in New York Pizza. It was started by one of the pizza makers from Prince Street Pizza and its spicy pepperoni square slice is very similar to Prince St”
H2
“Made in NY - one of the better utility slices around”
H2
“Made in NY is one of the best simple slices out there.”
H2
“One of the old pizza chefs from PSP opened his own spot called Made In NY Pizza. I think they have a few locations now. It's unfortunately named but almost as good as Prince St.”
H2
“Made in New York has a really good vodka slice”
H2
“Made in NY for a prince street clone that can be alright but is divisve”
H2
“Hate the name, but one of the more underrated slices in the city”
H2
“Near the Beacon, Made in NY Pizza, is hands-down my favorite, despite its lackluster name. They really get the crust right.”
H2
“If you want pizza, there's Made in New York pizza, which supposedly copied Prince Street's pepperoni square.”
H2
“what they have that people sleep on is an eggplant parm version that is delicious. Their margarita and classic NY style slices are also very good”
H2
“made in NY pizza has a few good specialty slices, but the rest is trash.”
H2
“they’ve been making amazing pizza for years”
H2
“there’s a made in new york pizza on like 37th and 7th that’s pretty 🔥”
H2
“It's become my go-to for a solid, no-frills slice.”
H2
“They put like honey or some other kind of substance on their square pepperoni slice which I really don't like”
H2
“Underrated: Guiseppina's, Made In NY, Angelo's”
H2
“Made in NY has some good Sicilian”
H2
“MiNY's upside down/red/whatever they call it is pretty good.”
H2
“the pizza’s great”
H2
“The slices are delicious and I’m particularly partial to the sauce.”
H2
“Made in NY Pizza (especially their vodka slice)”
H2
“I was skeptical bc of the tourist-attracting name but it’s just classic like what I grew up on in NY”
H2
“Slice shops - scarrs, pizza loves sauce, made in New York are all extremely good.”
H2
“Also a very good square slice.”
H2
“"Made in NY Pizza" is my favorite everyday slice from a business with multiple locations.”
H2
“Their Margherita is excellent.”
H2
“Made in New York Pizza on the Upper West Side (Amsterdam & W. 80th) has a fantastic plain slice. If you make it up to the UWS, definitely check it out.”
H2
“agree with this. it was started by some former prince st people and I think better”
H2
“it’s excellent pizza”
H2
“Made in NY Pizza has a good upside down square”
H2
“Made in New York Pizza on 38th and 7th is the best in the area.”
H2
“Made in NY’s eggplant slice clears them easily for me.”
H2
“Love their square eggplant and basil slice.”
H2
“Made in NY pizza in WV was also very good”
H2
“but they have great pizza”
H2
“Underrated: Made in New York Pizza”
H2
“Heck, even a slice at Made in New York Pizza is damn decent.”
H2