“this one had the most chocolate but it was not overwhelming and gave the cookie a great snap. The marzipan was not overpowering and actually added a more cake consistency”
H3
All 69 rated mentions, most helpful first
“this one had the most chocolate but it was not overwhelming and gave the cookie a great snap. The marzipan was not overpowering and actually added a more cake consistency”
H3
“I also love the black and white and macaroons from William Greenberg. NYC classics done right”
H2
“Black and white cookies from William Greenberg or Orwashers”
H2
“Black & White cookies from William Greenberg Desserts travel exceptionally well and the out-of-towners love 'em.”
H2
“The best rainbow cookies in the game are at William Greenberg. They’re made with marzipan.”
H2
“William Greenberg - incredible black and white cookie, founded in 1946”
H2
“William Greenberg has them year round, I always get one when I’m in the neighborhood!”
H2
“Black and white cookies from William Greenberg or Orwashers”
H2
“William Greenberg does great ones”
H2
“If you like marzipan, William Greenberg rainbow cookies are lights out.”
H2
“William Greenberg rainbow cookies slap super hard if you like marzipan”
H2
“Brownies from William Greenberg desserts.”
H2
“Get a black and white cookie there. They are great”
H2
“William Greenberg is exceptional for birthday cakes. So, so good.”
H2
“If you like marzipan/rainbow cookies go to William Greenberg desserts near the met”
H2
“William Greenberg desserts are the only answer ever for B&W's. with or without gluten.”
H2
“I think they’re brownies are top-3 NYC.”
H2
“the best b/w cookies are at orwashers, Russ & daughters and William Greenberg.”
H2
“William Greenberg has excellent black and white cookies, plus very good crispy style chocolate chip cookies”
H2
“the best rainbow cookie in the game is at William Greenberg. Old school place”
H2
“Hardest rainbow cookie in NYC.”
H2
“William Greenberg B&W cookies”
H2
“they're famous for their Black and White cookie.”
H2
“William Greenberg black and whites!”
H2
“William Greenberg on UWS has some of the best sweet treats in nyc (must try the black & white cookie).”
H2
“William Greenberg if you lookin for old school black and white cookies.”
H2
“They also have these sticky buns they call Schnecken that are a bit addictive.”
H2
“Has a strawberry shortcake that my family has been getting for birthdays for decades.”
H2
“Black & whites and ruggelah from Greenbergs is amazing and classic.”
H2
“their black and whites are amazing.”
H2
“they are delicious. The best I’ve had, admittedly not as many as you by far.”
H2
“An unexpected texture and flavor. It almost seems like a cake. Very good.”
H1
“I like William Greenberg Desserts.”
H1
“I have not found anything that comes even close to W. Greenberg B&W - they are in a league of their own.”
H1
“William Greenberg or Orwashers”
H1
“William Greenberg as others noted.”
H1
“They were still great one week later.”
H1
“I was INCREDIBLY disappointed by Greenberg. I’m pretty sure I didn’t bother eating the whole thing.”
H1
“highbrow choice as Greenberg”
H1
“I would put WG slightly over Orwashers, but wouldn't be disappointed to eat either. Really no others I know of that come close.”
H1
“But it’s the truth - Willy green or bust.”
H1
“I'm not a big enough of a fan of the B&W cookie to say William Greenberg is worth it”
H1
“Greenberg”
H1
“Check William Greenberg”
H1
“William Greenberg or Orwasher’s”
H1
“I genuinely do not understand why people love their stuff. Been twice and still haven’t had something I enjoyed or could even finish!”
H1
“william greenberg is the best”
H1
“Greenberg/Orwashers..”
H1
“William Greenberg probably the best”
H1
“Also, William Greenberg for the black & whites.”
H1