“If the quality was good I might understand it more, but in my opinion it’s usually very mediocre pizza with decent toppings.”
H3
All 81 rated mentions, most helpful first
“If the quality was good I might understand it more, but in my opinion it’s usually very mediocre pizza with decent toppings.”
H3
“From a pizza perspective... cardboard crust...very basic. From a caribbean perspective..mediocre curry, jerk aint happening and shrimp on a pizza is just sad.”
H3
“From a pizza perspective: painfully mediocre crust and the cheese tastes cheap. From a Caribbean food perspective, the oxtail seemed to work best as something unique, where as all the curry and "jerk" items just tasted bad.”
H3
“On a side note RE: their pizza; the dough was always atrocious and sloppy despite really tasty sauce.”
H3
“It’s the only slice of pizza I’ve literally ever thrown away. I ordered a chopped cheese slice and they non-consensually doused the slice in mayonnaise after it came out of the oven. Fucking disgusting.”
H3
“Crust was whatever. Nothing special. But I thought those toppings were pretty good.”
H3
“The oxtail slices are actually pretty good but I'd rather just get roti down the block.”
H3
“They debone the oxtail better than anyone in the city and it's incredibly sweet and tasty, also perfectly tender and well-seasoned. Don't really think any of their other slices are worth it. It's overpriced, and gimmicky and the wait can be long.”
H3
“Cuts and slices was all novelty hype and doesn’t belong on the list- with the exception of the oxtail slice which was solid, the flavors were reminiscent of a California pizza kitchen from a 90s mall. Wasn’t worth the line-up even a little bit.”
H3
“the crust is not very good but the sweet chili oxtail is among the best i’ve ever had.”
H3
“Incredibly overpriced. Also the worst part is I went and got a plain slice in addition to the oxtail one and it was so mid.”
H2
“their plain slice is 3.50, which is fine.”
H2
“the pizza was mid”
H2
“It's tasty, overpriced and not convenient to much of any other tourist stuff.”
H2
“Ny style with jamaican toppings * cuts and slices”
H2
“I love the flavor, and for me it’s plenty of food for one sitting, but it’s expensive for what you’re getting.”
H2
“The toppings are pretty good, but the pizza itself is mid”
H2
“It’s a try a unique slice once, kind of spot. I wouldn’t go back again”
H2
“The crust is bad. The toppings are good. It isn’t worth it.”
H2
“Pure trash, overpriced and mid”
H2
“It’s a mid pizza with decent special toppings.”
H2
“I enjoyed the slices but didn’t think it was worth the lines or the price.”
H2
“The regular slice looks mid idk”
H2
“I like it better than Cuts & Slices, though it is also pricey.”
H2
“Tasty like elevated dominos haha. Like if it was cheap pizza id love it, itd be my late night good bad pizza spot. But it is not NYC level at all lmao.”
H2
“Cuts and Slices is the prime example of overhyped and overpriced for me. I also live nearby and went a handful of times before it blew up. Thought it was fine”
H2
“they produce amazing toppings but the crust just didn’t do it for me. overall though definitely a top slice, if only for the creativity of their toppings.”
H2
“It’s trash and overpriced I can’t believe ppl travel that far for dry ass pizza”
H2
“Ditto on the chopped cheese slice. I'm not immune to novelty food, but you gotta deliver on the goods. It was more mayo than pizza.”
H2
“Everything about the pizza was mid.”
H2
“The oxtail pizzas at Cuts & Slices in BK.”
H2
“It's expensive for a slice joint, but tasty and different.”
H2
“They known for their oxtail and speciality slices but they honestly have very good quality cheese and crust.”
H2
“that oxtail pizza was crazy good. Mad expensive but I understood because that oxtail was cooked perfectly. There was chicken one too that was FIRE.”
H2
“Cuts and slices oxtail pizza”
H2
“Cuts and slices oxtail pizza”
H2
“Cuts and Slices is below average pizza.”
H2
“The oxtail pizza is so good.”
H2
“Their pizza was good but super expensive for what it was IMO.”
H2
“if you're getting shrimp or the chicken waffles... its not good but the oxtail OH MY GOSHHHH. regular slices aren't good but thats not their specialty.”
H2
“Cuts and Slices is overrated AF and I'm over the novelty of oxtail on pizza”
H2
“Cuts and Slices in Jamaica has some Oxtail versions that are something - cutsandslicesnyc.com”
H2
“The actual bread part of the pizza gave me flashbacks to pizza from school lunch”
H2
“it’s definitely the best fried shrimp and lobster alfredo pizza I’ve ever had but it doesn’t have any competition”
H2
“Garbage pizza..rather eat Red Baron frozen”
H2
“I think their garlic Parmesan shrimp slice is the best I’ve had there. Expensive but worth it imo.”
H2
“The toppings are unique and tasty but those guys don’t care about actually making good pizza. The dough is trash.”
H2
“Cuts & Slices is expensive for a pizza place, but quite cheap compared to fine dining, and it's very creative.”
H2
“The crust looks bad and their hype seems astro-turfed.”
H1
“the toppings were delicious but the crust felt like i was eating a cracker”
H1