“John's Pizza near Times Square (table service, whole pies only)”
H2
All 106 rated mentions, most helpful first
“John's Pizza near Times Square (table service, whole pies only)”
H2
“I'd probably take them to John's of Times Square. It's the same-ish pizza as John's of Bleecker Street, and the interior is really cool.”
H2
“John’s in the theater district isn’t anything special but it’s big and they make a nice stiff drink.”
H2
“John’s of Times Square but I think they only do pies”
H2
“John's of Times Square is great for kids, and it's also huge, which just is easier with out of towners. It's also not bad food.”
H2
“John’s pizza at Times Square is very good pizza.”
H2
“It was a big hit and the food was better than I expected”
H2
“Very good pizza in a unique space (it's an old church).”
H2
“John's Pizza, which has top-tier pies and is great for a group.”
H2
“for decent pizza in that area, I like John's of Times Sq”
H2
“John’s pizza so good”
H2
“Also, John's for pizza.”
H2
“John’s pizza is great.”
H2
“here are some good pizza places around Times Square — John’s of Times Square”
H2
“I second John's for pizza (whole pie only, but a good pizza) and vibe (converted church).”
H2
“John’s of Time Square for NY style pizza”
H2
“As for pizza, I like John’s of Times Square. Sort of a spin off of the more famous John’s of Bleecker street, but the pizza is basically the same.”
H2
“For pizza, try John's or Patsys.”
H2
“For sit-down NY style: John's in Times Square”
H2
“John's of Times Square. It has a big area style dining room & are super kid friendly.”
H2
“Pizza at Johns Time Square or See No Evil”
H2
“If you're limited to Times Square then definitely Johns pizzeria... Google it. The decor is almost as good as the pizza. Wine list is amazing and it'll work for all the ages you mentioned”
H2
“it’s a good place with good pizza and can accommodate a party your size”
H2
“I disagree but their garlic rolls are ridiculous.”
H2
“John’s pizza in time square is actually a solid sit down pizza spot and is cooked in brick ovens”
H2
“John's used to have locations uptown a couple decades ago and that's my comfort pie.”
H2
“John's Pizza is in my opinion the best in the city and is inside a former church with stained glass on 2 levels”
H2
“Definitely not the best pizza joint in NYC by any means but it is definitely unique in that it is located in a former church with all the inner decor preserved including the stain glassed windows.”
H2
“John's Pizza is decent. Yes it's over priced. Everthing is, but a whole pie should feed them and it's good.”
H2
“John’s pizza in Times Square is pretty great”
H2
“I eat there occasionally (I’m partial to the calzones) and Dave Portnoy rated it rather high”
H2
“John's Pizzaria of Times Square would be my first choice prioritizing distance and being decent.”
H1
H1
“So I would recommend Broad Nosh or Bagel Pub for bagels and NY Pizza Suprema (slices) or John’s of Times Square (whole pies only).”
H1
“Also John's Pizza.”
H1
“if you want a nice sit-down for pizza, Johns Pizza of Times Square is not bad and should be under budget.”
H1
“I work in the area and frequently go to John’s when I need a fast pre-show meal, or post show if I just want to eat near by.”
H1
“Sitdown Pizzeria - John's”
H1
“John’s”
H1
“John’s of Times Square is a good option if you don’t want to leave the Broadway area.”
H1
“John’s Pizza is great for large groups.”
H1
“Carmine's or John's Pizza of Times Square (which does pastas and parms and similar as well.)”
H1
“Carmine's, Parm, Serafina, John's, Patsy's, Emmy Squared, Mighty Quinns BBQ, PJ Clarke's, Schnipper's, Shake Shack, Stardust Diner, American Girl Doll Store/restaurant, Serendipity.”
H1
“I always recommend John's Pizza to visitors staying in midtown”
H1
“I've gone to John's pizza in times square--is it the best no, but you can sit down and the food it fine.”
H1
“John’s of Times Square is a good option too.”
H1
“Always really good food. Cool looking spot inside as well.”
H1
“Would def choose it over juniors or carmines.”
H1
“Johns pizzeria of times square. Check the photos on Google maps.”
H1
“There are no reservations, and there will be a wait - but if you have the time to spare and pick a shop nearby, it’s the best pizza in the area.”
H1