“their slices sometimes get too greasy and heavy, but having stuff like barbecued calamari and good pesto options is impressive for the size.”
H3
All 119 rated mentions, most helpful first
“their slices sometimes get too greasy and heavy, but having stuff like barbecued calamari and good pesto options is impressive for the size.”
H3
“If you manage to get their best pizzaman that day, you’ll have the fluffiest, lightest yet wide, thin & airy cheese slice you’ll have ever tried. On every other day of the week, though, they’re okay and not the best:”
H3
“Apart from the cornmeal crust in the bottom the rest of it is pretty bland. And their shit literally sits out all day begging to be reheated.”
H3
“of course it's garbage. like it tastes like the restaurant is dirty. that being said, when you are drunk, some mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, and a white slice are incredible.”
H2
“Terrible cheese slice. I gave it other shots - toppings, Sicilian, etc. Still terrible.”
H2
“It’s not amazing or a destination pizza spot by any means but it’s reliably solid when you’ve gotten out of a show late or need a quick bite near work or the train or something.”
H2
“but Little Italy Pizza and Pizza Collective are also good.”
H2
“Little Italy Pizza is decent”
H2
“I genuinely love their crust. The buffalo chicken pizza hits.”
H2
“Honestly I think it’s decent, and they have fountain Diet Coke which makes any slice a good 50% better”
H2
“Nothing special by any means but a consistent slice at somewhat reasonable prices”
H2
“Slice Joint - Pizza Suprema or Little Italy on 45th Street.”
H2
“I also like Little Italy Pizza, but *only* the location on 45th and 6th next to BookOff.”
H2
“LI. Their red Sicilian is excellent.”
H2
“Little Italy Pizza is a solid slice joint.”
H2
“Little Italy on 45th is pretty great. Their hot sausage is 🔥”
H2
“Little Italy is most underrated”
H2
“When You want a slice that is the definition of “mid” you now you’re getting the same thing there, no wait, every single time…”
H2
“Not even on par with Little Italy pizza imo”
H2
“I will admit it's great. But it's crazy expensive for a tiny slice and a bit unconventional at that.”
H2
“Way more traffic and turnover, seemingly resulting in lower quality - also chaotic and loud af”
H2
“Little Italy is one of the worst NY slice shops there is.”
H2
“I was buzzed and had a slice from there, I thought it was good.”
H2
“Little Italy (specifically 3rd Ave, Turtle Bay) are pretty good value for money imo”
H2
“I love that extra crunch they have in the underside of the dough and the flavor of the sauce and cheese is phenomenal.”
H2
“they’re consistent, you know what you’re getting (obviously not an amazing pizza, suprise suprise) and they’re reasonably priced”
H2
“I admit I do like their cornmeal cruat.”
H2
“I like little Italy (specifically the one on the corner of 33th and 5th) because of the bottom/crust.”
H2
“the little Italy on 71/Bway is also hella underrated and has a textured crust that is really great”
H2
“It may not be the #1 best pizza in the city, but for the kind of pizza place that millions of New Yorkers go to every day, you will be near Little Italy Pizza (11 park place) on your 9/11 Memorial Day. I used to work near there and went often.”
H2
“Their grandma slice is quite tasty.”
H2
“I love Little Italy for late night delivery pizza…”
H2
“I've noticed the toppings went downhill in like the past 3 years or so. The crust is still great.”
H2
“Little Italy's grandma slice is excellent.”
H2
“But MY GOD, it was the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life😊 The margarita pizza was just awesome!”
H2
“Skip Koronet and Little Italy Pizza.”
H2
“As far as chains go little Italy pizza is definitely solid”
H2
“I agree about Little Italy Pizza in midtown. I also work in midtown and it's a solid standby (love the cornmeal crust texture).”
H2
“Underrated: I like the crispness of little Italy pizza 🤷🏼♂️”
H2
“I love a little Italy slice on occasion. I always go for their margherita slices.”
H2
“It’s a proper NYC neighborhood pizza spot; I like the crust and the tomato sauce.”
H2
“Little Italy pizza for experience - also not standout but solid”
H2
“It does exactly what it’s says on the packaging imo - a cheap, consistent not greasy slice - large selection, convenient and quick”
H2
“I only go to the one on 42nd st and it’s always so busy, the pizza always seems really fresh?”
H2
“I hated their crust/dough. Too sweet.”
H2
“Eewww Little Italy is so gross. I tried the one on 3rd Avenue and there was some kind of granular cornmeal bullshit on the bottom of the crust.”
H2
“Their pizza quality is about what you'd expect.”
H2
“I hate that they put panko bread crumbs on the bottom of their pies.”
H2
“I randomly got a slice at Little Italy Pizza in Midtown and it was bomb af lmao. It was a margarita slice and I was floored.”
H2
“I’ve been endorsing their locations (except the times sq one) ever since - you know what you’re getting and the quality is reasonable at least”
H2