“I heard good things about these cookies and really enjoyed them - even if they're a bit too thin and crunchy on the outside for me, I loved the chewiness in the middle, the chocolate chips, and the sea salt they used.”
H3
All 140 rated mentions, most helpful first
“I heard good things about these cookies and really enjoyed them - even if they're a bit too thin and crunchy on the outside for me, I loved the chewiness in the middle, the chocolate chips, and the sea salt they used.”
H3
“The Pastry Box on East 12th street is for me the best chocolate chip cookie in the city. It’s thin, it’s got crunch, but it is PACKED with flavor and a bit of salt too and it’s just a truly delicious bite”
H3
“Pastry Box. They bake small batches continuously throughout the day so the cookie is perfectly warm and fresh”
H3
“the Pastry Box in East Village has a great one! It's a bit thinner of a cookie and crispier on the outside, but the inside is nice and chewy and has great chocolate and sea salt.”
H3
“the pastry box wins for me. Perfect balance of sea salt, sweetness, good ingredients, and she makes several batches throughout the day so your chances of getting them warm are pretty good.”
H3
“Absolutely elite chocolate chip cookie. Perfect texture and just the right balance of toffee flavor, chocolate, and salt.”
H2
“The Pastry Box always hits the spot. Their chocolate chip cookies are otherworldly. Quite thin, but somehow super chewy and chocolatey.”
H2
“- dessert - The Pastry Box chocolate chip cookies”
H2
“we did a ten cookie blind tasting and the winner was the pastry box”
H2
“Pastry box is very good (although I prefer their chocolate chip cookie)”
H2
“The Pastry Box is one of the best cookies in the city.”
H2
“Pastry Box is hit or miss depending on what you want. Too sweet for me but if you're into that it might be the best in the city.”
H2
“I had the 1/4lb salted chocolate chip cookie from The Pastry Box- easily now on my list of favorites.”
H2
“Nice picks! Especially love their chocolate chip cookies.”
H2
“I think it's a nearly perfect chocolate chip cookie, but chocolate chip cookies are so down to personal preference.”
H2
“Fantastic mix of chewy and crispy.”
H2
“chocolate chip cookies: Culture Espresso, The Pastry Box”
H2
“Pastry Box's chocolate chip cookie is great too!”
H2
“If you like thin cookies Pastry Box is excellent - a must try if you haven’t already.”
H2
“The Pastry Box makes an excellent chocolate chip! Not overly sweet, it's great.”
H2
“Pastry Box in East Village for classic chocolate cookies.”
H2
“The Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie at the Pastry Box is actually phenomenal. The first time I ate it I could immediately tell it was something special.”
H2
“Yes!! Im picky and I had their choco chip cookie last week and i loooooved it”
H2
“As a lover of chewy but thinner cookies this one is my absolute favorite.”
H2
“Hani’s, Pastry box and Culture are good for cookies especially if you like chewier cookies.”
H2
“One of the best chocolate chip cookies in the city. The brownie is fantastic also!”
H2
“Cookies, including black and white, chocolate chip, and brown butter, as well as everything else, at The Pastry Box on E 12th btw Avenues A and B. Just go.”
H2
“I’m obsessed with their black and white cookie!”
H2
“Pastry Box has the best thin chocolate chip cookie imo.”
H2
“The kitchen sink cookie at the Pastry Box is the best version of this type of cookie!”
H2
“Just gonna take a moment to highlight the 1/4 pound chocolate chip cookies from Pastry Box in the East Village! It’s a woman and POC owned business and all of her stuff is really good.”
H2
“Would highly recommend the pastry box”
H2
“The Pastry Box in the east village makes a good black and white cookie!”
H2
“For cookies: pastry box”
H2
“i think red gate and win son’s cookies are both superior cookies to pastry box.”
H2
“You need to try the pastry box chocolate chip!”
H2
“Must’ve got a bad batch when I went. The cookie was way over baked. Nearly burnt.”
H2
“pastry box has the best chocolate chip cookies!”
H2
“Their campfire cookie is also amazing!!”
H2
“The pastry box in east village has amazing chocolate chip cookies”
H2
“Redgate Bakery and Pastry Box both have fantastic pumpkin loaves”
H2
“Best chocolate chip cookies”
H2
“The Pastry Box, From Lucie, Bahn by Lauren for pastries/cookies”
H2
“The Pastry Box's salted chocolate chip cookie is so so good!”
H2
“Pastry Box's choc chip cookie.”
H2
“For chocolate chip, Hani’s and Pastry Box are delicious.”
H2
“Pastry Box is my favorite, fresh and diff than the usual black and white cookies!”
H2
“The Pastry Box makes the best chocolate chip cookie I’ve ever had. Sorry mom.”
H2
“Try the chocolate chip cookie at pastry box I think you’ll find it rivals hanis”
H2
“Also preferred the CCC from pastry box over hanis”
H2