Rosemary's

All 125 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What restaurant does a plate so perfectly, you’ll just always eat there if you’re craving it?16 pts
“They make it fresh to order and put two chicken milanese and a high quality cheese on a crusty roll with tomato sauce. It's one of the best sandwiches I've had for 15$.”
H3
in:Has the service from a restaurant turned you off completely from it?5 pts
“Rosemarys. Took 20 mins to take even a drinks order (early dinner + the restaurant was less than half empty with plenty of staff), misled our table about one of the dishes our party had ordered, delivered 2 dishes with barely-cooked pasta.”
H3
in:What are the most controversial restaurants in nyc?3 pts
replying to u/not_so_basic: Rosemarys. Food came undercooked & staff were rude af
“I was SO underwhelmed here, ordered $75 truffle pasta that didn’t taste like truffles at all… rude ass hostess and server and bathrooms were disgusting. I won’t go back”
H3
in:What’s an NYC food opinion that will have you like this?2 pts
“Rosemary’s is like the only Italian place that I’ve been to that I would say is worth it Got their carbonara and it was sooooo rich without being super heavy and the pasta was dense as well: I was very full and satisfied”
H3
in:Name a place to eat at thats nasty af but people hype tf out of it97 pts
“The floor SWARMED with mice. Looked like a carpeted converter belt. Never ever EVER go there.”
H2
in:Manhattan Mid Range bring your picky family restaurants59 pts
“Decent prices for the quality, very fresh but not too pretentious menu”
H2
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?19 pts
replying to u/Mofrdo: Rosemarys
“The portions were so small for what they’re charging omg”
H2
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?9 pts
replying to u/Mofrdo: Rosemarys
“Horrendous service for mid food and bad drinks”
H2
in:Help! Orecchiette With Sausage and Broccoli Rabe9 pts
“Honestly the one at Rosemary’s kinda slaps”
H2
in:For locals: Do you have a favorite restaurant where you could take almost anyone that comes to visit you? A place that's almost like a Goldilocks, one size fits all restaurant. 8 pts
“Rosemary’s. Great atmosphere and great food. And awesome for gluten-free friends.”
H2
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?8 pts
replying to u/FluidSpecific503: I just went. The portions were so small for what they’re charging omg
“It’s also just not good and bad service”
H2
in:My boss is taking my team to dinner with a $100pp budget before tip.6 pts
“Rosemary’s sounds like your price point.”
H2
in:What are the most controversial restaurants in nyc?5 pts
replying to u/not_so_basic: Rosemarys. Food came undercooked & staff were rude af
“The food is nothing special but it’s good for large groups and picky eaters, which is not an easy combination in Manhattan!”
H2
in:Manhattan Mid Range bring your picky family restaurants5 pts
replying to u/ChampagneManifesto: I always take my less adventurous guests/parents to Rosemary’s. Decent prices for the quality, very fresh but not too pretentious menu, they have a rooftop garden they get their veggies from so there’s a little gimmick if you’re into that, and it’s pretty spacious so you won’t get the “why are the tables so smawl” complaints.
“Food is great, certainly not a standard nyc pizza place in pricing and will be $50 a head if you have any wine, but everyone walks away happy”
H2
in:Mid-level restaurant4 pts
“Food is ok, not terribly expensive (my husband disagrees, though, haha. Says it’s pricey for what you get.) and the space looks nice.”
H2
in:What are the most controversial restaurants in nyc?3 pts
“Food came undercooked & staff were rude af”
H2
in:cheap but delicious restaurants in the city3 pts
“Rosemary's East in Stuytown (1st and 20th) has an amazing chicken parm sub for 14$.”
H2
in:Critique my (downtown) restaurant picks3 pts
“Via Carota is 100x better than Rosemary’s.”
H2
in:Can anyone recommend Ramen spot3 pts
“rosemarys or Don Angie if you rly want a expensive, special and memorable dinner.”
H2
in:Yes I am a NYer & no I cannot think of a place for dinner3 pts
replying to u/huxley78: Rosemary’s. Always solid and reliable Italian.
“Good carbonara.”
H2
in:Gramercy / Union Square restaurant recs2 pts
“Rosemary’s East on First Ave has great pizza and pasta.”
H2
in:Cute West Village restaurants2 pts
“Rosemary’s is so cute! Love the different focaccia options for apps :)”
H2
in:What are the most controversial restaurants in nyc?2 pts
replying to u/not_so_basic: Rosemarys. Food came undercooked & staff were rude af
“I second that - undercooked food and rude staff”
H2
in:Most memorable veggie dish2 pts
replying to u/Hobbyjogger31: Gunpowder dosa at Semma Paneer appetizer at Dhamaka Whipped ricotta toast with Jimmy Nardello peppers at Misi Buttered date salad at Eyval/Sofreh Grandma Walking Through the Forest pasta at Rezdora Tofu Fried Tofu sandwich at Superiority Burger
“Rosemary’s pea puree pasta”
H2
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?2 pts
replying to u/Mofrdo: Rosemarys
“Rosemarys is literally only good for their drinks at happy hour and everything else is a wasg”
H2
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?2 pts
replying to u/Mofrdo: Rosemarys
“Overpriced and small portions.”
H2
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?2 pts
replying to u/Mofrdo: Rosemarys
“I like the food but it’s ridiculously overpriced.”
H2
in:Name a place that actually lives up to its hype2 pts
replying to u/kikikza: I love how this thread has some of the same places upvoted as the other thread, make up your damn minds people I'm gonna put Yakitori Totto in the ring
“Rosemary, Essa, carbine, industry are most overrated.”
H2
in:help with disgruntled boss who loves via carota2 pts
“Have visited all and typically enjoy the whole vibe/food.”
H2
in:Looking for toddler-friendly (but not touristy) restaurants near West 37th & 8th/9th2 pts
“Midtown East has Rosemary, which is a very spacious good Italian restaurant with good outdoor seating.”
H2
in:What was the best meal you ate in 2023?1 pts
“The chicken parm sandwich at rosemary's east. I am going too miss it. I don't live in Stuytown anymore. It was freshly made everything, simple efficient. I probably had it 50 times.”
H2
in:Large group walk-in recommendations?1 pts
“It’s nothing mind blowing, but it’s a beautiful space and has something for everyone on the menu.”
H2
in:What are your recommendations based on what we liked?1 pts
“it has decent food, has a large seating area/capacity and the noise level is far less than other places.”
H2
in:Looking for a great Italian spot in NYC that’s not IMPOSSIBLE to get into1 pts
“the pasta is YUMMY. it's big yet somehow cozy with lots of candlelight...went this past weekend with a friend and loved it!”
H2
in:My boss is taking my team to dinner with a $100pp budget before tip.1 pts
replying to u/Mucciii: Rosemary was in an “overrated and/or filthy places” thread just this week so I’d skip that one
“I’d say it was overrated, though not filthy. But for 100 bucks a head…quite serviceable.”
H2
in:Name a place to eat at thats nasty af but people hype tf out of it1 pts
replying to u/Anal_Vengeance: Rosemary’s in WV. Waited for a ride outside there after a night at happiest hour. The floor SWARMED with mice. Looked like a carpeted converter belt. Never ever EVER go there.
“The EV one is genuinely good, despite it being so expensive”
H2
in:Name a place to eat at thats nasty af but people hype tf out of it1 pts
replying to u/Anal_Vengeance: Rosemary’s in WV. Waited for a ride outside there after a night at happiest hour. The floor SWARMED with mice. Looked like a carpeted converter belt. Never ever EVER go there.
“I was in rosemarys at dinner and a mouse ran across the floor during meal service, and none of the waitstaff even batted an eye!”
H2
in:Name a place to eat at thats nasty af but people hype tf out of it21 pts
“Rosemarys in WV”
H1
in:Restaurant rec for my parents to meet my girlfriend18 pts
“Rosemary’s, Balthazar, Lafayette. They’ll be good for conversation, but also the food is good and the atmosphere is good.”
H1
in:what's a place that everyone recommends but you violently disagree?11 pts
replying to u/Mofrdo: Rosemarys
“One of the worst meals I’ve ever had in this city”
H1
in:West village casual dressed acceptable dining10 pts
“Some suggestions: Quality Eats, L'Artusi, Barbuto, Rosemary's, Daddies, En Japanese Brasserie...”
H1
in:West Village Dinner, no reservations10 pts
“Rosemary's”
H1
in:Looking for the BEST Italian downtown7 pts
replying to u/Fluid_Spend_6729: I Sodi, Morandi, Rosemarys, Lupa, Il Mulino to name a few
“Rosemarys sucks”
H1
in:Restaurant recommendations for a group of 25-30 people?7 pts
“it's pretty cute with decent food.”
H1
in:aesthetic brunch spots?6 pts
“Rosemary’s”
H1
in:Restaurant to impress 12 yo step daughter near Chelsea6 pts
“rosemary's, jack's wife freda, cafe cluny, cookshop.”
H1
in:Where’s the good food in midtown that’s not $50+ and not corporate slop?6 pts
“there’s also Rosemarys in midtown east which is a safe (and I find under/appropriately rated) option”
H1
in:Yes I am a NYer & no I cannot think of a place for dinner6 pts
“Rosemary’s. Always solid and reliable Italian.”
H1
in:Restaurant Recs that will take 7p-ish Saturday Reservation near Comedy Cellar 5 pts
“Rosemary’s”
H1
in:First Date Night Restaurant Ideas NYC5 pts
“Couple places to check out… Rosemary’s”
H1