“It's definitely not the best bakery in the city or anything, I'd call it a middle ground between a supermarket bakery and an actual decent bakery.”
H3
All 166 rated mentions, most helpful first
“It's definitely not the best bakery in the city or anything, I'd call it a middle ground between a supermarket bakery and an actual decent bakery.”
H3
“berry napoleon was unreal”
H2
“I'm not saying it's the best bakery in the city by any means, but it really has everything going for it, between the perfect location, great goods, great sizes for the prices, and the weekday specials, which are usually what gets me in when I happen to be in the area.”
H2
“Martha’s Country Bakery isn’t bad but it’s mostly just ok, except for the Berry Napoleon which is amazing.”
H2
“Martha's Country Bakery is the only game in town for late-night dessert and they've saved my high ass several times in the past.”
H2
“Every kind of pie you can imagine, but not as good as Petee's.”
H2
“I feel like Martha’s has super gone downhill. The only thing that’s really worth getting there now is the berry napoleones. Anything else just tastes like grocery store bought cake”
H2
“Martha’s Bakery’s triple chocolate cake slice is my favorite cake of all time.”
H2
“Martha’s is on the sweet side.”
H2
“I live right by Martha’s which is good but sometimes too sweet.”
H2
“Martha's Country Bakery. Lots of options, all very sweet!”
H2
“Omg I loveeee tha Berry Napoleon is just amazing”
H2
“Martha’s is not good for a destination. Cheap ingredients. Very bright. Good to use for the bathroom and to get your kid a cake pop..”
H2
“I also like the one in Mia's and Martha's bakery (both in brooklyn though)”
H2
“A little too dense. Too sweet. The barometer I compare all other NY styles to.”
H2
“Martha's is definitely very so-so overall, but I really enjoyed their strawberry shortcake.”
H2
“I just don't think Martha's is anything unique. It's the type of bakery I can find in Iowa or Georgia, and I have been to them in both places.”
H2
“Whenever I get cake from them it ends up tasting like the cardboard box it came in lol”
H2
“for me it's the best cheese cake I've ever had. Super rich and creamy.”
H2
“Martha's in a pinch for solidly passable cakes of every variety”
H2
“i ordered it once and the cake was so dry and overly sweet. dont understand why people go there”
H2
“Martha’s Country Bakery. Blueberry pie and pistachio cheesecake - thank me later”
H2
“- Oatmeal pecan cookies from Martha's Country Bakery”
H2
“Their chocolate layer cake is amazing”
H2
“Get the Berry Napoleon. I’ve ordered a big one and ate like 80 percent of it in one sitting.”
H2
“that berry napoleon is insanely good. other stuff has gone downhill”
H2
“Although Martha’s country bakery has a surprisingly solid cheese danish, they’re just very hard to come by.”
H2
“Martha’s Country Bakery in Williamsburg probably came the closest in terms of offering decent chocolate cake with mousse.”
H2
“Martha’s bakery in Astoria and Forest Hills has incredible muffins including blueberry.”
H2
“I'm a huge fan of Martha's Bakery cheesecake.”
H2
“Triple chocolate mousse from Martha’s”
H2
“Martha's in Williamsburg has a yummy vegan carrot cake.”
H2
“Idk man I just love how rich and creamy it is I haven't found one I enjoy more personally.”
H2
“For pure chocolatey-ness, the fudge layer cake from Martha’s is phenomenal.”
H2
“I've been a couple times, and their desserts have only ever been mid at best to me. Just ... very sweet and not particularly memorable.”
H2
“Martha’s sucks ! Their cakes are always dry and cookies stale. Stay away from”
H2
“1000% used to be fire but its not good anymore and ive tried tons of different things. That being said, for being a vegan slice the vegan carrot cake is actually bangin”
H2
“Oreo cheesecake from Martha’s is the type of gluttony you can only enjoy while high”
H2
“Martha’s bakery Nutella peanut butter hot chocolate”
H2
“Or get the Brooklyn Blackout cake at Martha's Country Bakery or Mia's (both in Williamsburg).”
H2
“Martha’s Country Bakery chocolate fudge cake! 🤩”
H2
“Triple chocolate mousse cake from Martha's Country Bakery. body an entire slice every single time.”
H2
“I love Martha's Bakery cheesecake.”
H2
“Martha’s has some bomb cake.”
H2
“Martha’s Country Bakery is so far the most reliable red velvet slice I’ve had recently!”
H2
“Martha’s is not the best, but they do cream cheese and the cake isn’t stale”
H2
“Martha’s Country bakery makes the most sugar-laden cakes I’ve ever tasted.”
H2
“Their gluten free and vegan cake option was also not bad at all/better than most.”
H2
“Martha's makes a very good one.”
H2
“Martha’s is just pure garbage- I think they use oil instead of butter and just generally cheap ingredients.”
H2