“From Lucie had a really nice density to it and the ganache frosting was great. There is a slight coffee taste to From Lucie that really added a nice depth of flavor. Also nice frosting ratio.”
H3
All 166 rated mentions, most helpful first
“From Lucie had a really nice density to it and the ganache frosting was great. There is a slight coffee taste to From Lucie that really added a nice depth of flavor. Also nice frosting ratio.”
H3
“I hated how expensive the carrot cake was but damn if it wasn't one of the best I've ever had. The cake was so moist, light, and bouncy while the cream cheese frosting was almost whipped in its texture.”
H3
“I legitimately thought I had covid when I tried a slice of their cake because it tasted like literal nothing- it was a vanilla cake with blackberry jam and earl grey butter cream and all I tasted was like sweet, generic sugar.”
H3
“Agreed so sweet. You could tell they used lots of white sugar. Very dry and crisp, not a lot of chew”
H3
“the lemon olive oil cake with the lavender buttercream was absolutely delicious, but the chocolate cake was just ok. I would go back for the lemon cake but otherwise I'd say you don't have to go out of your way to try it”
H3
“ive tried a few of their cakes and some of them have that flavorless crisco texture and some of them have decent buttercream (i think their carrot cake was good)”
H3
“I find from lucie to be lacking, severely. I’ve been twice and each time the cakes were so dry they almost had a snap. And the icing is somehow chewy.”
H3
“The cake was moist (!!) but overall it was SOOOOO overly sweet. And WAY too much frosting.”
H3
“the chocolate chip cookie was ok, but the real star was the carrot cake. every time i took a bite the music just got louder in my head. i loved it. 9”
H2
“The pear cake was really yummy. In the Olive oil cake the lime frosting overpowered the cake too much”
H2
“cookie or slice of cake at from Lucie”
H2
“Dry, expensive cake, tasted worse than stale deli plastic wrapped cupcakes”
H2
“Today I had the chocolate chip cookie from From Lucie and didn’t love it.”
H2
“from lucie is so overrated, imho. their cookie was super flat and greasy”
H2
“The cakes are pretty. They don’t taste good, though. Not worth it.”
H2
“Tried, was dry and not worth it. Beautiful but that’s about it.”
H2
“From Lucie in the East Village has a great chocolate chip cookie”
H2
“The cookie from From Lucie unfortunately tasted like sugar and nothing else.”
H2
“From Lucie’s almost tasted like brown butter to me, and I’m not a huge fan of that.”
H2
“[From Lucie](https://fromlucie.com/products/lemon-olive-oil-lavender) bakery is amazing and uses Swiss meringue buttercream.”
H2
“From Lucie’s might be top cookie now”
H2
“From Lucie (if you like sweets, it's the best cake in town)”
H2
“Carrot cake: Lloyds Hungarian pastry shop Mia’s Red gate bakery S&P lunch From Lucie”
H2
“Yeah the cakes are pretty but are so average tasting and also it’s super $$ and the staff is extremely rude.”
H2
“I didn’t love either of those— and I like other things from both places! Found them both a bit sweet!”
H2
“From Lucie is at the top of my list for chocolate chip cookies.”
H2
“From Lucie has a really good cookie.”
H2
“From Lucie was okay but not enough chocolate imo - good for people who like the cookie part of a chocolate chip cookie.”
H2
“another spot that is incredibly underwhelming, where the cake is dry and tastes stale.”
H2
“From Lucie has great chocolate chip cookies too”
H2
“Chocolate Cake at From Lucie”
H2
“Victoria Sponge cake at From Lucie”
H2
“Honorable mention to From Lucie, they prefer thinner cookies but it’s also quality.”
H2
“Those cakes are absolutely terrible - dry, flavourless other than cloying sweetness in the buttercream.”
H2
“from lucie is my fav cookie in the city (as someone who’s tried many!)”
H2
“From Lucie is a different kind of chocolate chip cookie--thinner and chewier but amazing.”
H2
“From Lucie get the chocolate chip cookie and chocolate cake.”
H2
“Chocolate cake at From Lucie”
H2
“From Lucie’s vanilla cake with blackberry jam and earl grey frosting.”
H2
“From lucie: carrot cake”
H2
“I’d choose their carrot cake over from lucie’s any day”
H2
“salted chocolate cake from from lucie, so insanely good cold !!”
H2
“Hanis or from lucie for a sweet pastry after”
H2
“from lucie has a carrot cake i think about at least twice a week. It's not the most traditional cake but it's absolutely phenomenal”
H2
“lucie’s tastes like the Matilda cake (positive) and I think about it constantly”
H2
“The pear cake was really yummy. In the Olive oil cake the lime frosting overpowered the cake too much”
H2
“From lucie does an amazing slice of vegan cake. It was 10/10!”
H2
“i've had a few cakes from there and thought they were all pretty good.”
H2
“I’ve tried a few cakes and they’ve all been good, but not amazing.”
H2
“Absolutely not! Dry AF”
H2