Alidoro

All 168 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Sandwiches Manhattan10 pts
replying to u/ourlegacyfan: Alidoro is the best I’ve found
“Still good but horrible value now.”
H3
in:People who go to office everyday, what do you guys order for lunch? What's your go to spot?3 pts
replying to u/mulleargian: Two others near Bryant Park that are superb; - Omar’s (shawarma/mediteranean) - Alidoro (sandwiches)
“Alidoro is great but they are too slow and they skimp on the meat too much. Portions used to be bigger and after I missed a meeting once (no joke 40 min wait for my sandwich) I said never again.”
H3
in:What is your go-to spot around Grand Central?76 pts
“I can second Alidoro for sandwiches.”
H2
in:Best sandwiches SOHO31 pts
“they churn out Platonic ideals of sandwiches down there.”
H2
in:Awesome lunches to go near Rockefeller Center21 pts
“Alidoro for an Italian sandwich”
H2
in:10 more sandwiches in NYC14 pts
“Gonna say Johnnys Roastbeef, Il Sole, and the Chili Chicken. I could easily change this around on a second/third try tbh.”
H2
in:Best sandwich in New York13 pts
“Pinocchio from Alidoro in Soho is also great.”
H2
in:Any must-go food places around Penn Station NYC?12 pts
“Alidoro makes an excellent sandwich”
H2
in:Best take out lunch spot near Grand Central?11 pts
“Alidoro has great sandwiches.”
H2
in:Parm NYC 11 pts
“For sandwiches, Alidoro / Pisillo are obvious yet well-deserved choices.”
H2
in:Decently priced lunch options around Rockefeller Center10 pts
“Alidoro I really like—an Italian gourmet sandwich shop in the rockefeller center concourse.”
H2
in:Deli near Penn Station?8 pts
“Head to Alidoro within Moynihan Hall for Italian sandwiches”
H2
in:Sandwiches Manhattan7 pts
replying to u/Responsible-Big2044: Alidoro Milano Market
“Alidoro is the best I’ve found”
H2
in:Sandwiches Manhattan6 pts
replying to u/str8grizzlee: Faiccos
“Alidoro is also great and portion size more sensible.”
H2
in:Best sandwiches SOHO6 pts
replying to u/Jyqm: Alidoro. Take-out only (at least in this weather), but they churn out Platonic ideals of sandwiches down there.
“It hits that sweet spot between old school Italian deli and slightly artisanal.”
H2
in:Any NYC restaurants today or in the past have ordering protocols similar to those of "The Soup Nazi" from Seinfeld?6 pts
replying to u/InstructionNo3616: Alidoro on Sullivan St when the wife worked there. I once witnessed her tell a customer, “don’t let the door hit ya where the good lord split ya.” after denying her a sandwich because she wanted to add mayo to it.
“They make a damn good sandwich though.”
H2
in:If I’m a Portlander who has fallen in love with Italian sandwiches, visiting Manhattan, anywhere Harlem and below, and I want a legit NY Italian Sub (quality cured meats, quality formaggio, fresh baked bread) where am I going to get the real deal? 6 pts
“Alidoro. Get the "Pinocchio" on semolina roll (prosciutto, sweet sopressata, fresh mozzarella, sweet roasted peppers, olive paste).”
H2
in:When the boss offers to buy lunch6 pts
“Alidoro for sandwiches”
H2
in:Looking for your best hero/sandwich recommendation in LIC6 pts
“Their sandwiches are overpriced but delicious”
H2
in:Any decent food near Times Square / Grand Central?6 pts
“Alidoro for sandwiches.”
H2
in:Bryant Park - Lunch Recommendations?5 pts
“Alidoro on 39th is a decent enough sandwich”
H2
in:Visiting for one day. Want a sandwich.4 pts
“Other non-pastrami options I’d rec are alidoro (il sole) or all’antico (great focaccia sandwiches)”
H2
in:Best Food Near Bryant Park, NYC?4 pts
“Alidoro for Italian sandwiches. Out of this world.”
H2
in:If I’m a Portlander who has fallen in love with Italian sandwiches, visiting Manhattan, anywhere Harlem and below, and I want a legit NY Italian Sub (quality cured meats, quality formaggio, fresh baked bread) where am I going to get the real deal? 4 pts
replying to u/Routine-Condition-21: Alidoro!!
“This team makes a fantastic sandwich (don’t sleep on the focaccia)”
H2
in:Good $20 or less lunch places around East Midtown?3 pts
“Could be a touch above $20, but worth a try.”
H2
in:Lunch ideas around RCMH3 pts
“Alidoro ( tasty sandwiches )”
H2
in:Best take out lunch spot near Grand Central?3 pts
replying to u/iwantapenguin: The menu at Alidoro looks incredible- that’s exactly what I’m looking for, thank you!
“I’d suggest ordering from them as I find there sandwiches even better than Ali ☺️”
H2
in:Best tuna sandwich??3 pts
“Alidoro has a delicious tuna sandwich”
H2
in:Best burrata caprese sandwich in downtown/midtown3 pts
“Alidoro has great sandwiches and has a few locations.”
H2
in:Focaccia or Stecca based Sandwiches in NYC?3 pts
replying to u/Touslesceline: Alidoro in Soho.
“I love Alidoro, but can't stand their focaccia. It's like super thick and dense.”
H2
in:Day off today and craving a really good, relaxed sandwich for lunch3 pts
“The Enzo from Alidoro”
H2
in:Best deli near Penn Station?3 pts
“alidoro for takeaway sandwiches”
H2
in:Favorite quick service/fast lunch option in Soho?2 pts
“Alidoro, Olive's or M&O for sandwiches.”
H2
in:Best sandwiches SOHO2 pts
replying to u/Jyqm: Alidoro. Take-out only (at least in this weather), but they churn out Platonic ideals of sandwiches down there.
“Had me a nice Pavarotti sandwich there today, delish”
H2
in:Where to eat near Penn Station right now?2 pts
“I like the sandwiches from Alidoro”
H2
in:If I’m a Portlander who has fallen in love with Italian sandwiches, visiting Manhattan, anywhere Harlem and below, and I want a legit NY Italian Sub (quality cured meats, quality formaggio, fresh baked bread) where am I going to get the real deal? 2 pts
“Alidoro but ONLY the Sullivan St location. The expansion locations are a joke, in my experience. The line is entirely worth it.”
H2
in:My week in NYC, how did I do?2 pts
replying to u/GotLittUp: It's hard to find a good vegetarian sandwich! Do you have suggestions?? For me the Pesto Suppli was my favorite of the bunch!
“Alidoro does pretty great sandwiches”
H2
in:Big Sandwich?2 pts
“As far as a good Italian sandwich, I'd go to Alidoro.”
H2
in:West Village / Chelsea lunch recs (~$30 daily budget)2 pts
“I absolutely love their sandwiches.”
H2
in:Deli near Penn Station?2 pts
replying to u/NorthPomelo5307: Head to Alidoro within Moynihan Hall for Italian sandwiches
“Yup. I grabbed one there 2 days ago and it slapped”
H2
in:Midtown Cheap Eats2 pts
“Italian sandwiches- Alidoro has location on 39th and also in the Hugh as mentioned.”
H2
in:Any must-go food places around Penn Station NYC?1 pts
replying to u/phunkytime: Alidoro makes an excellent sandwich
“alidoro is great, deff not budget friendly tho lol”
H2
in:Rudest waitstaff in NYC ?1 pts
“The lady who takes orders at Alidoro in SoHo is notoriously mean, but their sandwiches are oh so worth it”
H2
in:Rudest waitstaff in NYC ?1 pts
“Alidoro on Sullivan - lady loses her shit if you make any substitutes to a sandwich”
H2
in:Looking for the MUST EATS!1 pts
“Alidoro makes great sandwiches”
H2
in:Looking for lunch/dinner near Bryant Park1 pts
“Alidoro for very good Italian sandwiches”
H2
in:Hello 👋🏼 my fiancée and I are visiting next month for a Yankee game and staying here for the weekend. We are looking for good coffee spots/bagels/ or any food options you all suggest. We are new to visiting NY and would love to try some good eats. Thanks in advance 1 pts
“Alidoro has incredible Italian sandwiches.”
H2
in:2 Day Food/Drink Itinerary1 pts
replying to u/camduv01: Yes location - we are coming from murray hill to central park - All'Antico Vinaio might be the move instead - Thank you!
“I love Alidoro. Think it’s one of the best sandwiches in the city”
H2
in:Recommendations for NYC hidden gems? 1 pts
“Great sandwich which is big enough to share.”
H2
in:Creating a mini book of illustrated NYC dishes - need suggestions!1 pts
“Gothamist from Alidoro!!! 🥪🥪🥪”
H2