“tl;dr It was good not great”
H3
6.5/10
AI-generated summary
This is a special occasion room, Italian and French, and people go on about how beautiful it is. Order the or the chicken. The $65 lunch tasting menu is the value pick, and regulars say get a at the bar first. Service divides people, some call it the best they've had and others call it terrible.
“tl;dr It was good not great”
H3
“The food was fine, nothing mind blowing especially for the price.”
H3
“we managed to get one small, forgettable hotdog (Cafe Carmellini x La Boite, priced at $15)”
H3
“Im quite fond of cafe carmellini; they have a balconly level where each table is semi-private and its both a great vantage and quite serene noise wise.”
H3
“Worst service of my life.”
H2
“Cafe Carmellini is absolutely gorgeous, it looks like an outdoor courtyard in Italy (trees inside + a mezzanine with tables that look like balconies).”
H2
“Best risotto i had in the city was at Cafe Carmellini’s Risotto del Giorno.”
H2
“Reads like an ideal event for Cafe Carmellini, French Italian in a beautiful spacious dining room”
H2
“Cafe carmellini has the same vibe as Le Coucou but the food is more interesting”
H2
“The Scallops Cardoz at cafe carmellini were beyond perfect.”
H2
“Maybe they should’ve made more creative food and not just very good versions of classic warhorses if that was the goal.”
H2
“the food was very mediocre and the service was teetering on bad.”
H2