All 190 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Far and away my fav is red gate bakery. They have classic ones Weds and Thurs. and rotating flavors on Fri and sat. The specialty flavors are pretty hit and miss (black cherry vanilla yum, lemon and olive oil ehh). But the pastry part is always very good.”
H3
“I love red gate for everything except cake. Cookies are amazing. I even had my birthday cake done there and it was so disappointing. Wasn’t particular flavorful and not sweet (and not in the good way).”
H3
“I mean if you REALLY love chocolate , the midnight banana bread at Red Gate is one of the best things ever. So moist and deeply chocolatey but you can still taste banana.”
H3
“Red gate (Cannibal and fudgenutter my personal fav)”
H2
“Red Gate - pumpkin olive oil loaf”
H2
“Red Gate cinnamon roll and a cookie”
H2
“Everything cookie. Not sure they even make a chocolate chip cookie but damn is this cookie excellent”
H2
“Red gate bakery has these really good cinnamon rolls that I frequently get and they are $8-$10 and they feel worth it.”
H2
“- redgate bakery caramel brownie”
H2
“Technically not a chocolate cake I suppose but red gates midnight banana bread”
H2
“I’ve been getting cake from Redgate Bakery and that might be my favorite cake in the city now. For my most recent birthday, I ordered their strawberry pistachio cake, which uses a delightful French buttercream.”
H2
“Triple corn cake from Red Gate Bakery (summer special)”
H2
“red gate bakery has corn buns and corn cake rn”
H2
“in my experience red gate cake was super dry and tasted like cardboard”
H2
“A close second though is Red Gate bakery. They love to rotate with really cool flavors.”
H2
“Red Gate Bakery cinnamon rolls or cookies”
H2
“Though the pickled PB&J bar is my choice - sounds weird but highly underrated and haven’t been able to find anything similar elsewhere”
H2
“It was worth the wait though. 8/10”
H2
“Red Gate Bakery with the melted caramel top 🤤”
H2
“Carrot cake: Lloyds Hungarian pastry shop Mia’s Red gate bakery”
H2
“very very solid CC cookie.”
H2
“everything at these places is good for the records - red gate bakery (cinnamon rolls, pickled bar)”
H2
“Red Gate!!! He’s been doing different variations on cinnamon rolls nearly every weekend and they’re fantastic.”
H2
“They have a different flavor bun and cake every weekend and it always hits.”
H2
“Red Gate Bakery makes really high quality and fresh baked goods.”
H2
“Red Gate bakery, have to get whatever cake they’re slicing and must go on a Friday or Saturday morning to get one of their crazy cinnamon buns!”
H2
“never had that specific cake, but the bakery is very good, if you like rich desserts”
H2
“Also love Red Gate if you’re into the thinner cookies”
H2
“Redgate Bakery (check for opening hours) also has great stuff, lots of American-style treats like cinnamon buns with cream cheese icing.”
H2
“If you love cookies everything at red gate bakery is also amazing”
H2
“it's sourced from good batch bakery which for me has some the best chewy cookies in nyc, toss-up between good batch and red gate.”
H2
“Personally, taste-wise, I like cakes from Red Gate and Lady Wong but the decoration isn’t going to be as ornate as you’d like.”
H2
“Red gate bakery pb miso cookies or pb blondie.”
H2
“Red Gate, Culture Espresso, Janie's and Jacques Torres for cookies.”
H2
“Red gates choco toffee cookie”
H2
“Red gate bakery has malted lime bars, they’re soooo good.”
H2
“i think red gate and win son’s cookies are both superior cookies to pastry box.”
H2
“The pumpkin loaf from Red Gate Bakery!”
H2
“Second Red Gate. Some of the best cookies and on weekends great cakes.”
H2
“I also tried the malted lime bar and a chocolate chip cookie from Red Gate and liked both a lot!”
H2
“Red gate is too sweet for me but good idea”
H2
“The last great cookie I had was the choco-toffee cookie from red gate bakery.”
H2
“okay i went and got it today - it's a lil cakier and a lil more chocolatey than expected but i liked it!”
H2
“Red Gate Bakery—a little bit more of a walk, but worth it”
H2
“Also the Red Gate choco toffee cookie is up there.”
H2
“Their toffee chocolate chip is amazing!!!!”
H2
“Everything I’ve had there has been amazing! Their chocolate chip cookie is one of my favorites and I love the PB&J bars too.”
H2
“Their stuff is better than magnolia and levain combined”
H2
“They do a great yellow cake with cream cheese chocolate frosting that’s more tangy than sweet”
H2
“I've gone many weekends for their revolving slices of cake or for their excellent lime malt bar or brownie if the flavor de jour isn't to my taste.”
H2